RESTRAINING ORDERS AGAINST INVESTIGATION AND PROSECUTION: JUDICIAL INCURSION INTO EXECUTIVE ACTIVITIES  By Luqman Hassan, Esq.

RESTRAINING ORDERS AGAINST INVESTIGATION AND PROSECUTION: JUDICIAL INCURSION INTO EXECUTIVE ACTIVITIES By Luqman Hassan, Esq.

 

Introduction

Nigeria is a constitutional democracy founded on the principle of separation of powers amongst the tripod of legislature, executive and the judiciary. This is aptly captured by the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1999 (as amended). Section 4 of the Constitution makes clear provisions on legislative powers and donates the powers to the National Assembly and States’ Houses of Assembly at both national and subnational levels respectively. The executive powers of government aptly provided under section 5 of the Constitution reside in the President of the Federation and Governor of each state of the federation.  Section 6 of the Constitution provides for judicial powers which are exercisable by various courts in the country both at federal and state levels. All the three arms of government are independent of each other without any overlap. Although the Constitution appreciates the position of checks and balances in the exercise of government powers by various arms of government, it does not envisage usurpation or disruption of the activities of any other arm of government duly carried under the law. The independence of each arms of government has received judicial blessings in plethora of cases which include: Kayili v. Yilbuk (2015) 7 NWLR (Pt. 1457) 26 SC and Friday v. Gov., Ondo State (2022) 16 NWLR (Pt. 1857) 585 SC.

 

In Kayili v. Yilbuk (supra), the Supreme Court held that:

Section 6 of the 1979 Constitution is in pari materia with section 6 of the 1999 Constitution, and vests the judicial powers of the Federation in the courts; while section 5 of both Constitutions vest the executive powers of the Federation and the States in the President and the Governors respectively. The Constitution is very clear and specific on separation of the powers between the arms of government, to wit: the Executive, the Legislature and the Judiciary at both the Federal and State levels. Thus, the Executive cannot exercise or usurp the powers of the Judiciary and vice versa. (P. 55, paras. D-G)

 

It is imperative for each arm of government to know the extent of its powers and the limits thereof. It is not within the contemplation of the Constitution that an arm of government will take over, impugn or override the powers of the other arms.  The Nigerian Apex Court further explained the imperative of separation of powers and independence of each arm of government thusly in Friday v. Gov., Ondo State (supra):

The principle behind the concept of separation of powers is that none of the three arms of government under the Constitution should encroach into the powers of the other. Each arm -the executive, legislative and judiciary is separate, equal and coordinate department and no arm can constitutionally take over the functions clearly assigned to the other. The powers and functions constitutionally entrusted to each arm cannot be encroached upon by the other. The doctrine is to promote efficiency in governance by precluding the exercise of arbitrary power by all the arms and thus prevent friction. The doctrine of separation of powers is the bulwark or anchor on which the survival of Nigeria as a nation must depend. While each arm of government must respect the other arm in the interest of the smooth running of government machinery, such respect must never degenerate to the level of one arm being allowed to usurp or impinge on the exclusive domain of the other as spelt out in the Constitution. [A.-G., Abia State v. A.-G., Federation (2003) 4 NWLR (Pt. 809)124; Kadiya v. Lar (1983) 2 SCNLR 368; Unongo v. Aku (1983) 2 SCNLR 332; Lakanmi v. A.-G., Western Nigeria (1971) 1 WNLR 201; A.-G., Anambra State v.Okafor (1992) 2 NWLR (Pt. 224) 396 referred to.] (Pp. 644-645, paras. D-F; 648-649, paras. G-B)

 

Despite the pronouncements of the Supreme Court in the above mentioned cases and several others, it is curious that some recent decisions coming from different courts in the land tend to supplant this truism, impugn the essence of the separation of powers and independence of the three arms of government. This is the basis upon which the recent judicial orders across the country stopping investigation and/or prosecution will be reviewed.

 

  • Case of Dr Abdullahi Umar Ganduje – Ex Governor of Kano State

The Kano State Public Complaint and Anti-Corruption Commission announced on July 18, 2023 that it has begun an investigation into the allegation of missing 100 Billion Naira local government fund of the State. A letter of invitation had been sent to the former governor of Kano State, Dr Abdullahi Umar Ganduje who was the Chief Executive of the State between 2015 and 2023 by the anti-graft commission. A day after the announcement, Federal High Court Kano Division granted an order restraining the anti-graft commission from continuing with its investigation pending the determination of the substantive suit. Justice S. A. Amobeda in his ruling gave an interim order:

“restraining the respondents jointly and severally, personally or through their agents, servants, privies and/or assigns, from arresting whomever and however from inviting, investigating, arresting, detaining, harassing and/or intimidating the applicants in respect of local governments herein, pending the hearing and determination of the applicants’ motion on notice.”

The court further stops the Commission from “taking any further steps in connection with, or relating to, or arising from the invitation by the respondents against the applicants, as communicated in the first respondent’s letters, dated July 7 and 10, 2023, respectively, pending the determination of the applicants’ motion on notice.”

 

It is needless to state that it is within the vires of the Kano State Anti-Corruption Commission to investigate and prosecute corruption cases as an executive body. An injunction, although interlocutory, which tends to undermine the exercise of this executive power is apparently arbitrary to say the least.

 

  • Case of Hudu Yunusa-Ari – suspended Adamawa State Resident Electoral Commissioner

Hudu Yunusa-Ari was INEC Resident Electoral Commissioner for Adamawa State before he was suspended for his infamous role in the declaration of the candidate of the All Progressive Congress (APC) as the winner of the Governorship Election in Adamawa while collation was still on-going after April 15, 2023 supplementary election. Mr Yunusa-Ari was suspended by INEC and the case was reported for investigation and possible prosecution. On July 10, 2023, the suspended Resident Electoral Commissioner approached a Federal High Court in Suit NO FHC/ABJ/CS/935/2023 asking the court to stop his prosecution pending the determination of the election petition before the governorship election tribunal in respect of Adamawa State 2023 governorship election. Justice Dontus Okorowo after listening to Michael Andoaka, SAN on behalf of Mr Yunusa-Ari asked the parties to maintain status quo. The order effectively stops further investigation or prosecution of Mr Yunusa-Ari. This amounts to restraining the respondents which include INEC and the Attorney General of the Federation (AGF) from taking further steps against Mr Yunusa-Ari pending the hearing of the substantive application. The AGF is the highest prosecuting authority in Nigeria in line with the provisions of section 174 of the Constitution. A restraining order against the AGF ultimately restrained all prosecuting authorities in the country.

 

  • The case of Mr Godwin Emefiele- Suspended Governor of Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN)

In December 2022, a High Court of the Federal Capital Territory presided over by Hon. Justice M. A. Hassan granted restraining orders against the AGF, the State Security Service (SSS), the Inspector General of Police and the C.B.N from arresting the ex-Central Bank Chief. This order was granted in an application brought by the Forum for Accountability and Good Leadership. It is curious that the beneficiary of the order, Mr Godwin Emefiele was not a party to the suit. The order was granted ten (10) days after the initial processes were filed. Apart from being a record in the adjudication practices in Nigeria, it is curious why the respondents were not given enough time to respond to the application.

In a related development, two Judges of the High Court of the Federal Capital Territory voided the arrest and detention of Mr Godwin Emefiele by the State Security Service (SSS) as illegal and a violation of the initial order of Justice M. A. Hassan. The ruling of Hon. Justice Hamza Muazu was made on July 13, 2023 while that of Hon. Justice Bello Kawu was made on July 14, 2023.

 

  • The case of Ex-Governor Bello Matawalle of Zamfara State

The immediate former Governor of Zamfara State, Bello Matawalle is also a beneficiary of judicial order restraining the anti-graft agency, the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) from arresting, inviting or prosecuting him. It is noteworthy that the EFCC has been investigating the activities of the former Governor and some other state officials in respect of funds meant for security votes, estacodes and other sundry expenses. However, in a ruling delivered by Hon. Justice A. B. Aliyu in SUIT NO: FHC/GS/CS/30/2021, the Federal High Court sitting in Gusau, Zamafara State made the following orders against the AGF and EFCC in favour of Matawalle as follows:

“An order of injunction is made restraining the EFCC whether by itself, its agents, employees, servants, operatives, detectives, privies, investigating officers and other persons by whatever name called, from inviting or further inviting, intimidating, harassing and threatening to arrest or detain or from arresting or detaining any past or present official of the government of Zamfara state on the basis of the same facts or similar facts as herein stated.”

“An order is made setting aside EFFC’s letter of invitation to past and present officials of the Zamfara state government dated 28th, September, 2021 or any other date same being ultra vires (beyond) the powers of the EFCC, and therefore, null and void and of no effect whatsoever.”

 

The ex-governor has approached the Federal High Court Abuja Division to give effect to the judgment of Hon. Justice A. B. Aliyu. The point argued in Suit No: FHC/ABJ/CS/753/2023 has been taken and judgment in the case has been adjourned to August 30, 2023.

 

Limits of the Jurisdiction of Courts

The jurisdiction of courts in Nigeria is constitutional and as stated above, encapsulated by section 6 of the Constitution. The limit of the jurisdiction of court lies in the provisions of the Constitution and laws establishing various courts. Where there is no jurisdiction, the courts lack the right to make a decision. This was the position of the Supreme Court in the case of President, F.R.N. v. National Assembly (2023) 3 NWLR (Pt. 1870) 1:

Jurisdiction is the authority a court has to decide matters, and where the court has no jurisdiction, with respect to any matter before it, the juridical basis for the exercise of any power with respect to such matter is also absent. [Ajomale v. Yaduat (No.1) (1991) 5 NWLR (Pt. 191) 257 referred to.] (P. 49, paras. B-C).

 

It is apparent from the decisions of the Supreme Court that the courts do not have jurisdiction to interfere with the workings of the other arms of government. The executive bodies created under the Constitution or other laws have their respective mandate which the courts do not have power to impugn or interfere. The constitutional or statutory functions of the executive bodies such as the Police, the EFCC, ICPC or any anti-graft or investigative agencies cannot be usurped by the Courts. Likewise, the courts cannot stop these agencies from performing their constitutional or statutory functions. This position has received judicial blessings severally. In the case of I.G.P. v. Ubah (2015) 11 NWLR (Pt. 1471) 405 CA, it was held that:

The court lacks the power to issue declaratory and injunctive reliefs with a view to impeding the result of police investigation made pursuant to the statutory duty under section 4 of the Police Act. (P. 450, para. B)

 

In addition, the Court of Appeal in upholding the powers of the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) to investigate and prosecute offenders without interference from the court held in Danfulani v. E.F.C.C. (2016) 1 NWLR (Pt. 1493) 223 that:

For a person to go to court to be shielded against criminal investigation and prosecution is an interference with the powers given by the Constitution to law officers in the control of criminal investigation. In the instant case to argue that the 1st respondent could not investigate the complaint would be an argument seeking to preclude the body from exercising its duty conferred upon it by the enabling statute. [A.-G., Anambra State v. Uba (2005) 15 NWLR (Pt. 947) 44 referred to.] (P. 246, paras. D-F)

 

This position was reiterated by the Court of Appeal in Nwafor v. E.F.C.C. (2021) 13 NWLR (Pt. 1794) 548 CA. The Court stated clearly that the EFCC cannot be stopped legitimately by a Court from carrying out its statutory duties. The Court held:

 

Whilst performing its legitimate duties, no court of law has the power to stop the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) from investigating a crime and, therefore, no person against whom there is a reasonable suspicion of having committed an offence or likely to commit an offence would be granted any relief capable of shielding him against criminal investigation and prosecution, since no citizen has any right to be an outlaw under the laws of this country. [Atakpa v. Ebetor (2015) 3 NWLR (Pt.1447) 549; I.G.P. v. Ubah  (2015) 11 NWLR (Pt.1472) 405;  Nzewi v. C.O.P. (2000) 2 HRLR 156; Badejo v. Minister of Education (1996) 8 NWLR (Pt.464) 15; Hassan v. EFCC (2014) 1 NWLR (Pt.1389) 607; Fawehinmi v. I.G.P. (2002) 7 NWLR (Pt.767) 606; A.-G., Anambra State v. Uba (2005) 15 NWLR (Pt.947) 44; Christlieb Plc v. Majekodunmi (2008) 16 NWLR (Pt.1113) 324; Onah v. Okenwa (2010) 7 NWLR (Pt.1194) 512; Amaechi v. INEC (2008) 5 NWLR (Pt.1080) 227 referred to.] (Pp. 600-601, paras. H-C).

 

The Court is the constitutional bulwark against abuse and ultra vires actions by both the legislative and executive arms of government. The courts are empowered by the Constitution to come in when the other arms of government act contrary or in excess of their powers. The power of Courts however does not extend to impeaching or eroding the powers rightly exercised by other arms. The power of the judiciary to curb inordinate exercise of powers by other arms of government was given judicial imprimatur in Alamieyeseigha v. F.R.N. (2006) 16 NWLR (Pt. 1004) 1 CA where the Court of Appeal held as follows:

The judiciary has a fundamental role to play as the protector and guardian of the Constitution. It also has the mandate to curb the excesses of overbearing executive and legislative acts by its pronouncements. [Ekpenkhio v. Egbadon (1993) 7 NWLR (Pt.308) 717; Lekwot v. Judicial Tribunal (1993) 2 NWLR (Pt.276) 410 referred to.] (P. 126, paras. F-G)

 

This important role of the judiciary to protect the Constitution from abuse and excesses does not culminate into judicial appropriation of powers of other arms of government. In Inuwa v. Gov., Gombe State (2020) 5 NWLR (Pt. 1716) 32, the Court of Appeal pronounced that:

The concept of separation of power is that none of the three arms of government under the Constitution, that is, the Executive, Legislature and the Judiciary should encroach into or usurp the powers of the other. [Amadi v. N.N.P.C. (2000) 10 NWLR (Pt. 674) 76; A.-G., Abia State v. A.-G., Fed. (2003) 4 NWLR (Pt. 809) 124 referred to.] (Pp. 55-56, paras. G-A)

 

Effects of Judicial Encroachment on Executive Power

It is necessary to advance the negative effects of judicial intrusion into executive powers of investigation and prosecution through judicial orders. It is a constitutional aberration for an arm of government- the judiciary in this case whose duty is to serve as gatekeeper for constitutionalism- to trespass on the powers of the other arms of government. It weakens the rule of law and promotes illegality and abuse of powers. Judicial orders which stop investigation or prosecution tend to overrun the exclusive powers of the Executive; it has the potency of promoting corruption and financial crimes in the country with suspects secured in their knowledge that the Judiciary will always come to their aid whenever approached. Whereas the Constitution places obligations on all arms of government to ensure a corruption free Nigeria under Section 15(5). The judicial attitude of stopping investigation or prosecution may serve as further impetus to perpetuate Executive disregard of Court orders as a form of resistance.

 

Notably, the judicial orders under review and others of the same tenor emanated from the Federal and States High Courts. The Court of Appeal and the Supreme Court have maintained unyielding position against usurpation of powers of other arms of government. It is therefore necessary for the Judiciary as an arm of government to look inward and take practical steps to stem the tide of issuing orders stopping investigation and prosecution in underserving cases. Training and retraining of judicial officers on the limit of judicial powers, separation of powers and the rule of law need to be emphasized. The judiciary needs to stand firm and wield its disciplinary stick against any erring judicial officer who yielded without justification to impugning the investigation or prosecution of corruption cases in the country.

 

It is important to add that the Judiciary should learn how to wait until its jurisdiction and powers are appropriately and properly invoked before exercising same. While investigation in suitable cases will eventually culminate into prosecution, the Judiciary would therefore, be well seized to make appropriate orders at the stage of prosecution without any let or hindrance. This would also not give out any inordinate impression to the public that the Judiciary is not only usurping the powers of other arms of government but in cahoots with corrupt officials to perpetuate illegality and unconstitutionality.

 

Conclusion

It is clear from the foregoing that each arm of government has its constitutionally assigned role. It is not within the contemplation of the Constitution that an arm of government should preside over the affairs of the other arms. The Judiciary is clearly assigned the role of policing other arms of government to ensure supremacy of the rule of law and ward off abuses or excesses. The powers given to the judiciary does not extend to usurping, appropriating or impeaching lawfully exercised powers of the other arms of government.

 

It is however improper to find decisions of courts in recent times which stepped on the constitutional and statutory powers of other arms or agents of government. This is more so when it is noted that a single thread that ran across all the cases under review is that they were filed by politicians or politically exposed persons and rulings/judgments were delivered in their favour in utter disregard for the constitutionally protected principle of separation of powers. It is necessary to warn the Judiciary against abuse of its highly cherished constitutional role of checks on the other arms of government. While it must stand as watchman against legislative and executive recklessness, the court must be wary of becoming the danger it is often sought to prevent.

 

 

 

NOTE: The section on legal Briefs is a forum for frank and open scholarly notes by research staff and guest contributors. Views expressed in these notes are personal to the authors and are not to be attributed to the Centre.

DO YOU WANT TO SHARE YOUR VIEWS ON OUR BLOG?

JURITRUST Centre for Socio Legal Research and Documentation invites submission of short articles from VOLUNTEER CONTRIBUTORS who are interested in sharing their perspectives on salient issues in the administration and development of the Nigerian Criminal Justice System, comparative systems and related issues. CLICK HERE find out how to send us your articles. Thank you

CONFISCATION OF PROCEEDS OF CRIME UNDER THE PROCEEDS OF CRIME ACT 2022 (POCA)      By Mrs Adaobi Nwosu-Okonta Esq

CONFISCATION OF PROCEEDS OF CRIME UNDER THE PROCEEDS OF CRIME ACT 2022 (POCA) By Mrs Adaobi Nwosu-Okonta Esq

Introduction

The Proceeds of Crime (Recovery and Management) Act (POCA) was passed into law in Nigeria in 2022. The Act was enacted to make comprehensive provisions for the seizure, confiscation, forfeiture, and management of properties reasonably suspected to have been derived from unlawful activities. The enactment of POCA was well received in view of the fact that corruption is a huge problem in the Nigerian public sector. The Act has provisions that target the receipt and management of proceeds of crimes including stolen public funds which may have been stashed in offshore banks or used to acquire assets in foreign countries.

POCA provides for non-conviction based recovery and conviction based recovery of the proceeds of crime. In conviction based recovery, an order of confiscation is made by the court only if the defendant has been convicted of the crime. Confiscation is defined in section 82 of POCA to mean “the permanent deprivation of funds or other assets by order of a competent authority or a Court”. The recovery of proceeds of crime is important for the following reasons: to compensate the victim of the crime, to prevent the proceeds from being employed to commit further crimes and to deter others from committing the same crime.

In the News

Recently, a British court in the United Kingdom issued an order directing Mr James Ibori, a former Governor of Delta State, Nigeria to immediately pay 101.5 million pounds or face an eight-year jail sentence. The confiscation order of the court directing Ibori to pay 101.5 million pounds was made pursuant to the conviction of Ibori in a British court in 2012. While facing trial before the British court, Ibori pleaded guilty to money laundering and related offences of fraud to the tune of 50 million pounds which he committed during his tenure as the Governor of Delta State. He was sentenced to 13 years of imprisonment and after serving the minimum term of imprisonment, he was released from jail. In the confiscation proceedings which were held years after his release from jail, the Judge formally declared that Ibori had benefited from criminal conduct in the sum of 101.5 million pounds and made an order for Ibori to pay that amount.In response to the confiscation order, Ibori stated that he would file an appeal and he also raised issues of his properties being the subject of a restraint order and that his assets are below the amount of the confiscation order. Although Ibori’s case was tried in a British court and the court’s orders were made under the United Kingdom’s Proceeds of Crime Act 2002, the issues raised in his case are still relevant to a discussion on the Nigeria Proceeds of Crime Act, 2022.

Implementation of a Confiscation Order

Section 45 (1) of POCA provides that the Court may make a confiscation order requiring a person to pay to the relevant organisation for deposit into the designated account, an amount equal to the total proceeds of a person’s criminal activities. As seen in Ibori’s case, certain issues may arise from the implementation of a confiscation order. These sorts of issues will be outlined below with a note on how Nigeria POCA addresses those issues.

  1. Issue of how the assets of the defendant are ascertained

In the investigation and seizure of assets pursuant to restraint or confiscation orders, there are cases where the assets and properties of other persons who are not parties to the case are lumped together with those of the defendant. The question then arises as to the proper way of ascertaining that certain assets are owned by the defendant and not third parties.

Section 48 (1) of POCA lists properties of the defendant which may be realized to satisfy a confiscation order.  They are-

  1. Property held by the defendant.
  2. Property held by a person to whom that defendant has directly or indirectly made any affected gift.
  3. Property that is subject to the effective control of the defendant.

Section 50 (3) defines “affected gift” to mean any gift made by the convicted person concerned, where it was a gift of property received by that convicted person in connection with an offence committed or any part which directly or indirectly represented in that convicted person’s hands property received by him in connection with an offence committed by him or any other person.The relevant organisations are expected to follow the provisions of POCA in identifying properties that are realizable for the satisfaction of court orders against the defendant. Where there are third-party claims to such properties, it is expected that those third parties apply to the court to prove their ownership of those properties as well as to prove that the properties are not proceeds of criminal activity.

2. Issue of the defendant’s assets being subject to a restraint order

A confiscation order is made after the defendant is convicted of the crime. While the trial is ongoing, restraint orders are usually made on the assets of the defendant to prevent the defendant from disposing of those assets before the conclusion of the criminal case.  Restraint orders do not automatically expire when a confiscation order is made and remain in force until the confiscation order is satisfied. The issue that arises is the inability of the defendant to satisfy the confiscation order because he cannot sell his assets due to the existence of a restraint order on those assets.

Section 36 (5) (a) of POCA provides that the court making a restraint order shall, at the same time, make an order authorising the relevant organisation or an authorised person acting on its behalf, to take custody or control of any property specified in the order. Under section 33 (c) and (e), the relevant organization is expected to implement confiscation proceedings against a convicted person and the realisable properties are supposed to be preserved and available to satisfy a confiscation order. From the above provisions, it is clear that under POCA, the same organization is tasked with the implementation of restraint and confiscation orders. Where a defendant is unable to satisfy a confiscation order due to the presence of a restraint order on his assets, it is easy for the relevant organization to dispose of the same assets to satisfy the confiscation order since it has custody and control of the assets.

Under the United Kingdom’s POCA, different persons implement restraint and confiscation orders. A management receiver protects properties that are subject to a restraint order while an enforcement receiver disposes properties for the purpose of satisfying a confiscation order. Where a defendant is unable to satisfy a confiscation order within the time specified, it is expected that the enforcement receiver will liaise with the management receiver for the disposal of the defendant’s properties which are subject to the restraint order.

3. Issue of the value of the confiscation order being greater than the value of the assets that are subject to a restraint order

There are instances where the value of the confiscation order is different from either the value of the proceeds of the crime committed or the value of the properties that are subject to a restraint order. This variation of the confiscation order is dependent on the law of the jurisdiction where the case is tried. In Ibori’s case, for example, he was convicted of offences to the tune of 50 million pounds while his confiscation order was set at 101.5 million pounds. This is because, under United Kingdom’s POCA, the confiscation order is calculated based on what the defendant has benefitted from the crime. The calculation therefore goes beyond the financial crime amount but includes the resulting gain from the defendant employing the wealth, resources and property gotten from the commission of the crime.

Under Nigeria’s POCA, section 45 (5) puts an upper limit on the amount the court can ask the defendant to pay in the confiscation order. Section 45 (5) provides that the amount that the court may order a convicted person to pay to the relevant organisation shall not exceed-

(a) the value of the convicted person’s proceeds from the offences or criminal activity, as determined by the court, in accordance with the provisions of the Act; or

(b) an amount, which in the Court’s opinion may be realised, if the Court is satisfied that the amount which might be realised as contemplated under this Act is less than the value referred to in paragraph (a) of this subsection.

From the provision of Nigeria’s POCA, it is not contemplated that the amount in the confiscation order may be greater than the amount of funds derived from the crime. Instead, the court may assess the amount on the confiscation order to be lesser.In both the Nigeria and United Kingdom’s POCA, where the value of the properties of the defendant that are subject to a restraint order is less than the value of the confiscation order, the defendant is expected to make up the balance that may remain on the confiscation order after selling his assets. However, in both jurisdictions, the court also has the discretion to vary the confiscation order to a lesser amount than the amount of the proceeds derived from the criminal activity.

Conclusion

The Nigeria Proceeds of Crime Act 2022 makes extensive provisions for the recovery of proceeds of crime. This is an important law in Nigeria which ought to help in curbing corrupt practices and ensuring that looted funds are recovered and returned to the rightful owners which is the public. The Act makes extensive provisions covering the making of confiscation orders by the court and the implementation of those orders. Some issues that may arise in the implementation of confiscation orders have been highlighted and discussed above.

 

NOTE: The section on legal Briefs is a forum for frank and open scholarly notes by research staff and guest contributors. Views expressed in these notes are personal to the authors and are not to be attributed to the Centre.

DO YOU WANT TO SHARE YOUR VIEWS ON OUR BLOG?

JURITRUST Centre for Socio Legal Research and Documentation invites submission of short articles from VOLUNTEER CONTRIBUTORS who are interested in sharing their perspectives on salient issues in the administration and development of the Nigerian Criminal Justice System, comparative systems and related issues. CLICK HERE find out how to send us your articles. Thank you

THE ROLE OF THE JUDICIARY IN THE TRAFFICKING IN PERSONS (PROHIBITION AND ENFORCEMENT) ADMINISTRATION ACT (TIPPEA) 2015

THE ROLE OF THE JUDICIARY IN THE TRAFFICKING IN PERSONS (PROHIBITION AND ENFORCEMENT) ADMINISTRATION ACT (TIPPEA) 2015

by

AJIBOLU AFOLABI, LL.B, B.L, PRINCIPAL STUDIES FELLOW, STUDIES DEPARTMENT, NATIONAL JUDICIAL INSTITUTE, ABUJA (EMAIL: ajibolabi@yahoo.com, ajibolabi84@gmail.com.)

&

AKA FANEN, B.A. (FRENCH), PRINCIPAL RESEARCH FELLOW, RESEARCH DEPARTMENT, NATIONAL JUDICIAL INSTITUTE, ABUJA (EMAIL: faxrule@gmail.com )

 

INTRODUCTION

The new form of modern day slavery otherwise known as human trafficking is estimated to be a $150 billion global industry with Nigeria ranked 38 out of the 160 countries with the highest number of slaves, according to the 2023 Global Slavery Index. The National Agency for the Prohibition of Trafficking in Persons (NAPTIP), reported in 2021 that women who are eighteen years and above are the highest number of trafficked persons in Nigeria, which maintains its posture as a Tier 2 country on the United State of America State Department’s Trafficking in Persons Report (2022).

This rampant menace of human trafficking cuts across Nigeria’s neighbouring nations – Niger Republic and Chad to the North, Benin Republic and Togo to the East, Cameroon and Equatorial Guinea to the South. These countries not only serve as trafficking routes but also serve as countries of origin, transit and destination for victims of human trafficking within the West African sub region. These, coupled with the general factors that increase vulnerability to trafficking in Nigeria such as extreme poverty, lack of economic opportunities, corruption, conflict/insecurity, climate change which invariably led to irregular and dangerous  migration have resulted in an even more distressing dimension of human trafficking. There have been series of declarations, conventions, bills of rights, charters and other statutes both at the international and domestic levels prohibiting trafficking in human beings, yet this crime goes on.

Nigeria has ratified and is a signatory to a number of international conventions which are directly or indirectly related to trafficking. Some of which include- The United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights; Forced Labour Convention, 1930; Worst Forms of Child Labour Convention (no. 182) 1999; the Convention on the Rights of the Child; Convention on the Elimination of all Forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW); African Charter on Human and People’s Rights; ECOWAS Declaration and Plan of Action Against Trafficking In Persons (2001). There is also the Memorandum of Understanding between Nigeria and Republic of Benin on cross-border crimes, smuggling, human trafficking and drug trafficking, signed on 14th August, 2003, which mandates parties to the Memorandum of Understanding to collaborate on sharing information and delegating resources to fight cross-border crimes particularly human trafficking and drug trafficking. However, in light of the ECOWAS Declaration and Plan of Action against Trafficking in Persons which ECOWAS States signed in the year, 2001; it became imperative for ECOWAS member states to create special units to combat human trafficking in the region, thus NAPTIP was established by the Trafficking Act of 2003.

It is on record that Nigeria is the first African country to enact a specific anti-human trafficking law. Nevertheless, prior to the passage of the Trafficking in Persons (Prohibition) Law Enforcement and Administration Act, 2003, Nigeria did not have specific anti-human trafficking law explicitly set aside to combat human trafficking. Similarly, before the enactment of the Child Rights Act in 2003, Nigeria had no comprehensive special law protecting the rights of children, noting however, that children are vulnerable and largely fall victims of human trafficking.

  • THE LEGAL FRAMEWORK FOR COMBATING TRAFFICKING IN PERSONS (TIP) AND SMUGGLING OF MIGRANTS (SOM) IN NIGERIA

Several other laws provide for the prosecution of trafficking in persons, for clarity some of these laws are reproduced as follows:

In light of the discussion above, it is important to further shed light on the provisions of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1999 (as amended); which contains provisions which clearly outlaw slavery and forced labour or compulsory labour, sexual exploitation and deprivation of personal liberty of Nigerians (see Sections 17, 34 and 42 of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1999 (as amended). These relevant constitutional provisions which outlaw forced labour and slavery are very unambiguous.

In addition, it is interesting to note that a victim or victims of trafficking can challenge the infringement of the above mentioned rights under Section 46 of the 1999 Constitution (as amended). Section 46 states that “any person who alleges that his or her fundamental human rights has been or is being or likely to be contravened in any State in relation to him may apply to a High Court in that state for redress”. Also, Section 254C (1) (i) of the Third Alteration of the Constitution provides that the “…National Industrial Court shall have and exercise jurisdiction to the exclusion of any other court in civil causes and matters – connected with or related to child labour, child abuse, human trafficking or any matter connected therewith or related thereto”.

 

In discussing the Criminal Code, there are various provisions against ‘slave dealing’ which could be used to prosecute trafficking in persons and prostitution. Section 223 provides that: “Any person who – (1) procures a girl or woman who is under the age of eighteen years and is not a common prostitute or of known immoral character to have unlawful carnal connection with any other person or persons, either in Nigeria or elsewhere, or (2) procures a woman or girl to become a common prostitute, either in Nigeria, or elsewhere; or (3) procures a woman or girl to leave Nigeria with intent that she may become an inmate of a brothel elsewhere; or (4) Procures a woman or girl to leave her usual place of abode in Nigeria, with intent that she may, for the purpose of prostitution, become an inmate of a brothel, either in Nigeria or elsewhere; is guilty of a misdemeanor, and is liable to imprisonment for two years.”

 

Section 224 further provides that any person who by threats, intimidation, false pretense or by administering drugs, with intent to stupefy or overpower a woman or a girl or girls in order to enable any man to have unlawful carnal knowledge of her is guilty of misdemeanor and is liable to imprisonment for two years. Sections 365, 366 and 369 of the criminal code cover the field with regard to some of the main methods of intimidation used by traffickers. For instance: Section 365 deals with unlawful confinement or detention against a person’s will while Section 366 covers compelling someone to do something by threats, surveillance or other intimidation and is punishable by one year imprisonment.

The Criminal Code in Section 369 of the Criminal Code outlawed slave dealing and defined same as purchasing, selling, dealing with or transferring persons so they may be treated or held as slaves or placed in servitude as a pledge or security for debt or entering into a contract or agreement in furtherance of these purposes. This is punishable by imprisonment for up to fourteen (14) years under the criminal code.

The Penal Code which is applicable in the Northern States has similar provisions to the Criminal Code, with the term “trafficking” not however expressly defined. The term ‘slave’ is used and the relevant sections are Sections 275, 278, 279, 280.

The Nigeria Immigration Act, 2015 prohibits all forms of smuggling of illegal migrants. The Act also gives effect in the Federal Republic of Nigeria to the provisions of the Protocol Against the Smuggling of Migrants by Land, Sea and Air, thereby supplementing the United Nations Convention Against Transnational Organised Crime. Relevant sections are as follows: S. 64 which prohibits all forms of smuggling migrants in Nigeria, S. 65 creates a number of offences relating to SOM, S.66 prohibits the abuse of the vulnerability of the smuggled migrant, S. 67 proscribes enabling illegal residence, S. 68 proscribes the procurement of fraudulent travel or identity documents, Aiding and abetting of smuggling migrants is captured under Ss. 69 & 70; while escape and aiding and abetting escape is under Section 73.

The Child’s Rights Act, 2003 prohibits the exposure of children to the use, production and trafficking of narcotic drugs under Section 25, while section 26 generally prohibits the use of children for criminal activities of whatever nature. The penalty for breach is fourteen (14) years imprisonment. All forms of sexual abuse and exploitation of children below the age of eighteen (18) years are equally prohibited by Sections 31 – 32 of the Act. Sanctions include life imprisonment and fourteen (14) years imprisonment respectively.

  • TRAFFICKING IN PERSONS (PROHIBITION AND ENFORCEMENT) ADMINISTRATION (TIPPEA) ACT, 2015

 

In view of the need to combat human trafficking and the illegal smuggling of migrants, amendments were introduced to the Trafficking Act of 2003 in 2005 and the 2005 legislation has now subsequently been modified vide the TIPPEA 2015. The recent amendments enable relevant agencies to exercise some powers to rescue victims of human trafficking both within and outside Nigeria. In addition, the recently enacted Trafficking in Persons (Prohibition and Enforcement) Administration (TIPPEA) Act, 2015 provides for the role of the judiciary in combating human trafficking as well as giving powers to NAPTIP aimed at combating human trafficking and the illegal smuggling of migrants.

Sections 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 and 11 of TIPPEA, 2015 address the powers, functions and administration of NAPTIP. The Act established different departments comprising investigation, legal, public enlightenment, counselling and rehabilitation, as well as other relevant units within NAPTIP to enable the agency carry out its functions effectively. As regards investigation and prosecution, Section 6, subsection (a) of TIPPEA, 2015 empowers NAPTIP to investigate whether any person, body or entity has committed an offence under the Act or the offence of trafficking under any other law. By virtue of Section 6, subsection (c) of the TIPPEA, 2015; and without prejudice to the powers of the Attorney General of the Federation (Sections 174 and 211 of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1999 (as amended) to discontinue proceedings, NAPTIP is empowered to arrest, detain and prosecute offenders under the Act or any other law on trafficking in persons in Nigeria.

According to Section 36 of the Act, it confers on the High Court, jurisdiction to try and punish all offences created under it and Section 82 defines Trafficking or traffic in persons as ‘the recruitment, transportation, transfer, harbouring or receipt of persons by means of threat or use of force or other forms of coercion, abduction, fraud, deception, the abuse of power of a position of vulnerability or the giving or receiving of payments or benefits to achieve the person having control over another person or debt bondage for the purpose of placing or holding the person whether for or not in involuntary servitude (domestic, sexual or reproductive) in forced or bonded labour, or in slavery-like conditions, the removal or organs or generally for exploitative purposes;”

  • INNOVATIVE ROLES OF THE JUDICIARY UNDER TIPPEA, 2015

Generally the judiciary is conferred with the constitutional responsibility of interpretation of the law vide section 6 of the 1999 Constitution (as amended) however, there are roles assigned to the judiciary under the TIPPEA, 2015. Additionally, Judges in line with constitutional provisions have the powers to grant or refuse bail applications (see section 36 (5) 1999 constitution (as amended). Furthermore, it is trite to note that the innovations of the TIPPEA, 2015 have gone a long way in combating the crime of human trafficking. For example, the innovative provision for witness protection under the TIPPEA 2015 encourages witnesses especially persons who have been trafficked, to come forward to give their testimony in court against traffickers.

In addition, there is a novel innovation of the Act which must not be ignored and this is the aspect of the creation of a victims’ trust fund. This innovation is novel as assets of persons convicted of human trafficking are forfeited to the state and its proceeds used to cater to victim(s) of human trafficking. Consequently, it is important to adumbrate some of these innovations of the TIPPEA 2015; and also highlight the powers given to judicial officers under the Act. These innovations are (but not limited to):

  • Witness protection private proceedings to be managed by the judge (see Section 47 TIPPEA, 2015)
  • Forfeiture of asset to victims’ trust fund (see Section 67 and 68, TIPPEA, 2015)
  • Adoption of measures to avoid delays and abuse of court process (see section 37 TIPPEA 2015)
  • Adjudicate over requests from foreign states for mutual legal assistance (see Section 69 TIPPEA, 2015)
  • Sentencing which is the judgment of a court is also the exclusive preserve of judges and is a constitutional role of judges not just in TIP/SOM cases but generally in criminal cases. Under the TIPPEA 2015, where any person is convicted of an offence under the Act, any punishment which the court imposes in passing its sentence must equally be accompanied by an order of forfeiture to the Victims of Trafficking Trust Fund, the properties which facilitated the commission of the offence or properties acquired with proceeds of any unlawful activity under the Act. (Section 36 (2) TIPPEA 2015).
  • Furthermore, where it is established that any convicted person has assets or properties in a foreign country, acquired as a result of any of the offences under the Act, such assets or properties subject to any treaty or arrangement with such foreign country, shall be forfeited to the Victims of Trafficking Trust Fund (See section 50 (1) TIPPEA 2015).
  • Interim attachment order after seizure of property (see Section 55 TIPPEA, 2015)
  • Final order of forfeiture (see Section 56 TIPPEA, 2015)
  • Freezing order on banks or other financial institutions. (see Section 60 TIPPEA, 2015)
  • RECOMMENDATIONS

With the above innovative roles of Judges as per the TIPPEA 2015, it is important to note that there is more to be done on the part of judges in protecting trafficked persons. These recommendations are based on provisions under the TIPPEA 2015 which though not expressly stated as responsibilities of judges, should be taken up by Judges to ensure effective implementation of TIPPEA, 2015 and delivery of substantial justice to victims. It is therefore recommended that Judges should:

  • ensure that trafficked persons and smuggled migrants should be assisted with information on relevant administrative and court proceedings (see Section 63 TIPPEA, 2015),
  • ensure adequate protection for particularly vulnerable victims such as children, disabled persons, victims of sexual abuse and so on ( 61 and 62 TIPPEA 2015)
  • in smuggling cases; inter alia: provide for some special rights of smuggled migrants (Ss. 61 and 62 TIPPEA 2015)
  • ensure the protection of victims of smuggling cases from reprisal, intimidation or threat,
  • ensure that the rights of trafficking victims to compensation or restitution by the trafficker are protected (section 65 TIPPEA 2015)
  • objectively assess trafficking cases devoid of technicalities
  • CONCLUSION

The menace and ills of human trafficking have been brought to the knowledge of the average Nigerian on the streets via awareness and sensitization campaigns carried out through the media and consultative forums between stakeholders and communities. The judiciary plays a vital role in this fight against human trafficking and should be encouraged to ensure that incidences of human trafficking in Nigeria are brought to the barest minimum if not completely eradicated. Finally, it can be deduced that the innovations of the TIPPEA 2015 are novel and same will encourage speedy dispensation of justice for victims of human trafficking.

 

NOTE: The section on legal Briefs is a forum for frank and open scholarly notes by research staff and guest contributors. Views expressed in these notes are personal to the authors and are not to be attributed to the Centre.

DO YOU WANT TO SHARE YOUR VIEWS ON OUR BLOG?

JURITRUST Centre for Socio Legal Research and Documentation invites submission of short articles from VOLUNTEER CONTRIBUTORS who are interested in sharing their perspectives on salient issues in the administration and development of the Nigerian Criminal Justice System, comparative systems and related issues. CLICK HERE find out how to send us your articles. Thank you

The Bailiff/Sheriff Department: A Cesspool of Corruption    By Bayo Akinlade Esq

The Bailiff/Sheriff Department: A Cesspool of Corruption By Bayo Akinlade Esq

What is the essence of justice if one cannot reap its benefits? Why go to court and be there for several years only to get judgement in your favour but you cannot enforce it and thus loose the benefit of it.

One area of our justice system that needs our attention is the issue of enforcement of Court Orders and Judgements. It is unfortunate that we have laws that ensure that court judgements are obeyed yet those same laws have provisions that lawyers have cleverly used to circumvent justice.

 The Role of Lawyers in corrupting enforcement of Judgements:

There are 2 principal ways lawyers have developed in compromising the justice system in this regard:

1.The abuse of the Appeal Proceedings

Lawyers have taken advantage of the slow pace of our justice system, the over-crowed docket of the Courts and the lack of adequate number of judges available to handle cases to abuse the process.

While the constitution gives one the right to appeal to a higher court if the person feels he has not obtained justice at the court of first instant, this process has however, been abused by lawyers to the extent that our courts are no longer respected as courts of justice.

The Courts on the other hand have sought to rectify this problem by pronouncing that an appeal or notice of an appeal does not act as a stay of Proceedings at the lower court nor does it stop the enforcement of a ruling or judgement of a lower court, but nevertheless; the same lower court have many time refused to abide by the pronouncement of the higher court on this….WHY? I will give you a hint later.

2.The Sheriff and Civil Processes Act requires that in enforcing a judgement of a Court, the Nigeria Police is to be involved to provide security. Now this provision though well-meaning, has created an avenue for corruption and has hindered the enforcement of court orders and judgements. I will not go into details but we all know that the police will demand for money before they accompany a judgment creditor and the Court Bailiff to enforce anything.

Many Lawyers use these requirements to have a policeman present to enforce orders of court to compromise Justice as they can simply bribe the police and stall any execution of the Judgement of the Court.

Lawyers have also been known to procure fake judgements and orders with the help of staff of the Judiciary….even judges and magistrates are alleged to be involved in this horrible practice.

 The Role of the Courts

In a recent complaint received by FIACIJ against the National Industrial Court; we see clearly the corruption within the Court itself especially if a judge or the chief judge himself is interested in the case.

This of course is a most unfortunate situation which makes a gross mockery of the entire justice system. The internal proceedures of some judiciaries requiring the Chief Judge to sign off on almost every enforcement of its judgements is a scandal to say the least.

 FIACIJ had cause to investigate and interrogate the Sheriff Department of the High Court of Lagos a few years back and discovered that a certain Chief Judge personally reviewed almost every item that was meant to be auctioned by the court and dealt with those items corruptly to the detriment of the Judgement creditor and basically to all parties concerned.

Why are we keeping silent? Why are litigants and lawyers not raising any alarm? Why have our Bar Associations and anti-corruption agencies turned a blind eye to these subtle corrupt practices that damage the integrity of our justice system?

We have to STOP these acts of internal sabotage of our justice system.

FIACIJ condemns these acts and call out all heads of courts and lawyers involved in this disgraceful practice to desist from compromising our Justice system.

We are monitoring, we are watching and we are collecting evidence against perpetrators of these acts……the day of reckoning is near!

 

About the author

Bayo Akinlade is the Convener, FIACIJ and Secretary Nigerian Law Society.

 

NOTE: The section on legal Briefs is a forum for frank and open scholarly notes by research staff and guest contributors. Views expressed in these notes are personal to the authors and are not to be attributed to the Centre.

DO YOU WANT TO SHARE YOUR VIEWS ON OUR BLOG?

JURITRUST Centre for Socio Legal Research and Documentation invites submission of short articles from VOLUNTEER CONTRIBUTORS who are interested in sharing their perspectives on salient issues in the administration and development of the Nigerian Criminal Justice System, comparative systems and related issues. CLICK HERE find out how to send us your articles. Thank you

 

 

 

HUMAN RIGHTS ISSUES RELATING TO CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION AND TRIALS: A NIGERIAN PERSPECTIVE By Chioma Henrietta Okoli

HUMAN RIGHTS ISSUES RELATING TO CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION AND TRIALS: A NIGERIAN PERSPECTIVE By Chioma Henrietta Okoli

Introduction:

Nigeria, the most populous country in Africa, is a constitutional democracy with a diverse population and complex legal system. The country has made significant strides in promoting human rights, as evidenced by the ratification of various international human rights treaties. Nigeria, as a democratic nation, places significant importance on upholding human rights within its constitution and legal framework. The criminal investigation and trial processes play a critical role in protecting these rights and ensuring justice for all citizens. However, the criminal investigation and trial processes in Nigeria face numerous human rights challenges, impacting the fairness and effectiveness of the justice system.

This paper examines the key human rights issues within the Nigerian criminal justice system, analyzes their implications, and proposes potential solutions to strengthen human rights protection and ensure fair and just criminal proceedings.

 

The Right to a Fair Trial:

The right to a fair trial is a cornerstone of the criminal justice system and is protected under section 36 of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1999 (as amended); the Administration of Criminal Justice Act, 2015 and other relevant Nigerian laws. It is also protected under regional and international human rights instruments such as the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights; the Universal Declaration on Human Rights; and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. However, several factors impede the realization of this right in practice.

 

 Prolonged Pre-Trial Detention:

One of the major human rights challenges in Nigeria is the excessive use of pre-trial detention. Many individuals, particularly those from marginalized communities, experience prolonged detention without trial, violating their right to liberty and the presumption of innocence. The Nigerian criminal justice system often faces delays in processing cases, leading to overburdened courts and backlogs.

To address this issue, the Nigerian government should invest in alternatives to pre-trial detention, such as bail reform and diversion programs. Implementing legal reforms to streamline the judicial process and provide timely trials can help reduce the backlog of cases and alleviate pre-trial detention pressures.

 

  Access to Legal Representation:

The right to legal representation is a crucial aspect of a fair trial. However, many accused individuals, especially in rural areas, face difficulties in securing competent legal counsel, leading to an imbalance within the adversarial system.

To address this issue, Nigeria must enhance legal aid services to ensure that all citizens, regardless of their financial status, have access to qualified legal representation. Awareness campaigns can be conducted to inform citizens of their right to legal representation and the avenues available to access legal aid.

 

Trial Delays and Backlogs:

Trial delays are a common issue in the Nigerian criminal justice system, affecting both victims and accused individuals. Lengthy trials can undermine the right to a speedy trial, impacting the lives of those involved and impeding justice.

To tackle trial delays, the Nigerian government should invest in modernizing court infrastructure and adopting case management systems. Additionally, the judiciary should employ case management techniques to ensure the timely resolution of cases. Adequate training and resources for judges and judicial staff are essential to expedite proceedings.

 

Police Misconduct and Brutality:

Instances of police misconduct and brutality have been a significant concern in Nigeria. The excessive use of force during arrests and interrogations, arbitrary arrests, and torture have been reported, particularly in vulnerable communities. These actions not only violate the right to life and liberty but also erode public trust in law enforcement and the criminal justice system.

 

Excessive Use of Force:

The use of excessive force by law enforcement is a recurring problem in Nigeria. Often, confrontations between security forces and civilians result in unnecessary violence, leading to injuries and loss of life.

To address this issue, Nigeria should establish robust mechanisms for independent oversight and accountability. Independent bodies responsible for investigating allegations of police misconduct should be empowered and adequately resourced. Moreover, comprehensive training on human rights and the use of force should be mandatory for all law enforcement personnel.

 

Torture and Extrajudicial Killings:

Torture and extrajudicial killings are grave human rights violations that have been reported in Nigeria. Victims of torture often suffer physical and psychological trauma, and extrajudicial killings deny individuals their right to life and due process.

To combat torture and extrajudicial killings, Nigeria must prioritize the investigation and prosecution of security personnel involved in such acts. Establishing specialized units within the police force and judicial system to handle cases of police misconduct can enhance accountability and deter future abuses.

 

Lack of Accountability:

The lack of accountability for police misconduct and brutality remains a significant barrier to justice in Nigeria. Cases involving security personnel often face challenges in the prosecution and conviction of the perpetrators.

To promote accountability, Nigeria should ensure that investigations are transparent and impartial. Independent bodies, such as civilian oversight commissions, should be tasked with overseeing investigations and holding law enforcement personnel accountable for their actions.

 

Right to Privacy and Surveillance:

Advancements in technology have expanded the capabilities of criminal investigations in Nigeria, but they have also raised concerns about violations of the right to privacy. The use of surveillance technologies, such as mass data collection and electronic monitoring, may infringe upon individual privacy rights.

 

Mass Data Collection:

Mass data collection by government agencies and private entities can compromise individual privacy rights in Nigeria. The extensive gathering and storage of personal data without proper safeguards can lead to abuse and unauthorized access.

To safeguard privacy rights, Nigeria needs to enact comprehensive legislation to regulate the use of surveillance technologies. Legal frameworks must be established to ensure that surveillance practices are subject to judicial oversight, strict adherence to proportionality tests, and respect for individual rights. Additionally, independent bodies, such as data protection agencies, should be tasked with overseeing and enforcing data protection laws.

 

 Electronic Monitoring and Phone Tapping:

The use of electronic monitoring and phone tapping by law enforcement agencies has raised concerns about the violation of privacy in Nigeria. Surveillance without proper authorization and oversight can lead to unwarranted intrusions into the lives of individuals.

To prevent abuses, Nigeria must establish clear legal procedures for obtaining and using electronic surveillance evidence in criminal investigations. Judicial warrants should be required for surveillance, and access to such evidence should be restricted to authorized personnel.

 

Safeguarding Privacy Rights:

Nigeria must prioritize the safeguarding of privacy rights in the digital age. Public awareness campaigns can be instrumental in educating citizens about their rights and raising awareness about potential privacy violations. Additionally, the Nigerian government should collaborate with international organizations and privacy experts to develop best practices for data protection and surveillance.

 

Impartiality and Independence in Investigations:

The impartiality and independence of criminal investigations are vital to ensuring fair and just criminal proceedings in Nigeria. However, challenges related to political interference and inadequate resources can undermine the integrity of investigations.

 

 Political Interference:

Political interference in criminal investigations remains a significant concern in Nigeria. The influence of politicians and powerful individuals on law enforcement agencies and prosecutorial bodies can compromise the objectivity of investigations.

To bolster impartiality and independence, Nigeria should strengthen the role of independent prosecutorial bodies, such as the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) and the Independent Corrupt Practices and Other Related Offenses Commission (ICPC). These bodies should be insulated from political influence, and their leadership should be appointed through transparent and merit-based processes.

 

Independent Prosecutorial Bodies:

The effectiveness of independent prosecutorial bodies in Nigeria depends on their autonomy and capacity. Adequate resources should be allocated to these bodies to ensure effective and efficient investigations. Moreover, coordination and collaboration between different law enforcement agencies and prosecutorial bodies are crucial to avoid conflicts of interest and promote comprehensive investigations.

 

Adequate Resources for Investigations:

Nigeria should invest in the capacity-building of law enforcement agencies and investigators to ensure that they have the necessary resources and training to conduct thorough and impartial investigations. The recruitment and training of specialized investigators can enhance the quality and effectiveness of criminal investigations.

 

 Juvenile Justice:

The treatment of juveniles within the criminal justice system remains a pressing human rights issue in Nigeria. Despite legal protections for children, many young offenders find themselves subjected to the same punitive measures as adult criminals.

 

Detention of Juveniles:

Detention of juveniles should be a measure of last resort, according to international human rights standards. However, overcrowded juvenile detention centers and a lack of rehabilitation programs continue to be challenges in Nigeria.

To promote juvenile justice, Nigeria should prioritize diversion programs and restorative justice practices to keep young offenders out of the formal criminal justice system. Specialized courts and detention centers that cater to the needs of juveniles should be established, focusing on rehabilitation and reintegration rather than punishment.

 

 Lack of Rehabilitation Programs:

Rehabilitation programs for juvenile offenders are essential in breaking the cycle of criminal behavior and reintegrating them into society. Nigeria should invest in education, vocational training, and counseling programs for juvenile offenders to facilitate their successful reintegration into the community.

 

Diversion and Restorative Justice:

Diversion programs that divert young offenders away from the formal criminal justice system can be effective in promoting juvenile justice. Restorative justice practices, which involve dialogue and reconciliation between offenders and victims, can also contribute to reducing recidivism among juvenile offenders.

 

Discrimination and Disparities:

Discrimination based on ethnicity, religion, and socioeconomic status remains a persistent challenge in Nigeria’s criminal justice system. Racial profiling and targeting of certain communities by law enforcement agencies raise concerns about systemic bias and disparate treatment.

 

 Ethnic and Religious Bias:

Ethnic and religious biases can influence police conduct, investigations, and trial outcomes in Nigeria. Prejudices based on ethnicity and religion can lead to targeted arrests and unfair treatment of certain groups.

To address these disparities, Nigeria must invest in cultural competency training for law enforcement personnel. Data collection and analysis should be used to identify disparities and inform evidence-based policy changes to eliminate systemic bias.

 

Socioeconomic Disparities:

Socioeconomic disparities can also impact access to justice and the treatment of individuals within the criminal justice system. Individuals from lower socioeconomic backgrounds may face challenges in accessing legal representation and obtaining a fair trial.

To mitigate socioeconomic disparities, Nigeria should invest in legal aid services to ensure that all citizens, regardless of their financial status, have access to competent legal representation. Awareness campaigns can also be conducted to inform citizens of their rights and the avenues available to access legal aid.

 

 Addressing Systemic Bias:

Addressing systemic bias in Nigeria’s criminal justice system requires comprehensive reforms and a commitment to promoting equality before the law. The Nigerian government should engage with civil society organizations and international partners to identify and address areas of systemic bias within the justice system.

 

Challenges in the Criminal Justice System:

In addition to specific human rights issues, Nigeria’s criminal justice system faces broader challenges that impact human rights protection and the rule of law.

 

Overcrowded Prisons:

Overcrowded prisons are a persistent problem in Nigeria, leading to unsanitary conditions, human rights abuses, and increased risk of disease outbreaks.

To address this issue, Nigeria should explore alternatives to incarceration, such as community service and probation, for non-violent offenders. Investing in prison infrastructure and enhancing rehabilitation programs can also alleviate prison overcrowding. 

 

Corruption in the Justice System:

Corruption within the criminal justice system undermines the integrity of investigations and trials, eroding public trust in the rule of law.

To combat corruption, Nigeria must prioritize the enforcement of anti-corruption laws and establish independent oversight bodies to investigate and prosecute corrupt practices within the justice system. Strengthening internal accountability mechanisms within law enforcement agencies can also deter corrupt behaviour.

 

Inadequate Training for Criminal Justice Personnel:

The effectiveness of Nigeria’s criminal justice system depends on the competence and professionalism of its personnel. Inadequate training can impede the quality of investigations, trials, and victim support.

To address this challenge, Nigeria should invest in continuous training programs for law enforcement officers, prosecutors, and judicial staff. Training should focus on human rights principles, legal procedures, and best practices for handling criminal cases.

 

Strengthening Human Rights Protections:

To ensure fair and just criminal proceedings and protect human rights, Nigeria should adopt a holistic approach that encompasses legal reforms, awareness campaigns, and collaboration with civil society and international organizations.

 

Legal Reforms and Policy Changes:

Nigeria should undertake comprehensive legal reforms to address the human rights issues identified in this paper. Reform efforts should prioritize protecting the right to a fair trial, curbing police misconduct and brutality, safeguarding privacy rights, and promoting impartiality and independence in investigations.

 

Awareness and Sensitization Programs:

Public awareness campaigns are essential in educating citizens about their rights and raising awareness about potential human rights violations. Government agencies, civil society organizations, and the media can collaborate on educational programs aimed at promoting human rights within the criminal justice system.

 

Collaboration with Civil Society and International Organizations:

Collaboration with civil society organizations and international partners can enhance Nigeria’s efforts in protecting human rights within its criminal justice system. Civil society organizations can serve as watchdogs, advocating for human rights, and providing support to victims. International organizations can offer technical assistance, expertise, and financial support for human rights initiatives.

 

Conclusion:

Protecting human rights within criminal investigations and trials is crucial to upholding the rule of law and ensuring justice for all citizens in Nigeria. The right to a fair trial, addressing police misconduct and brutality, safeguarding privacy rights, promoting impartiality in investigations, ensuring juvenile justice, eliminating discrimination and disparities, and overcoming broader challenges within the criminal justice system are essential steps toward creating a fair, just, and human rights-respecting criminal justice system in Nigeria.

By prioritizing legal reforms, awareness campaigns, and collaboration with civil society and international partners, Nigeria can strengthen human rights protections and enhance public trust in its criminal justice system. A comprehensive and multifaceted approach is essential to promoting justice, fairness, and respect for human rights within Nigeria’s criminal investigations and trials.

 

About the author

Chioma Henrietta Okoli is a Senior Legal Officer at National Human Rights Commission, Nigeria where she promotes and protects human rights policies. She is also currently enrolled as a PG student at the Centre for Human Rights, University of Pretoria, South Africa.

 

DO YOU WANT TO SHARE YOUR VIEWS ON OUR BLOG?

JURITRUST Centre for Socio Legal Research and Documentation invites submission of short articles from VOLUNTEER CONTRIBUTORS who are interested in sharing their perspectives on salient issues in the administration and development of the Nigerian Criminal Justice System, comparative systems and related issues. CLICK HERE find out how to send us your articles. Thank you

 

 

BAIL AND TERRORISM CHARGES – WHAT IS THE LAW? by LUQMAN HASSAN, Esq

Introduction
Bail is a concept of liberty in criminal justice administration. It follows the constitutional presumption of innocence enshrined under section 36 (5) of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1999 as amended. Bail is basic, common place and do not require scholarly definition. However, in order to drive home the point, it is important to allude to the pronouncement of the Court of Appeal in the case of Ojo v. F.R.N. (2006) 9 NWLR (Pt. 984) 103, where it was stated that:

Bail is the freeing or setting at liberty one arrested or imprisoned, upon others becoming sureties by recognizance for his appearance at a day and place certainly assigned, he also entering into self-recognizance. The accused/convict is delivered into the hands of sureties, and is accounted by law to be in their custody, though they may free themselves from further responsibility if they surrender him to the court before the date assigned. (Pg 115, paras. E-F)
Bail is mainly of two types- bail pending trial and bail pending appeal. The two types of bail have been aptly described by the court as follows: “In bail pending trial, a court of trial, pursuant to provisions made by the enabling law or other statutes which create the offence(s) charged, may admit to bail any person to be tried before it, while he is awaiting trial or during his trial. In bail pending appeal, the convict who has lodged an appeal may be admitted to bail pending the determination of the appeal. The circumstances for bail vary in both situations. This is largely due to the fact that before conviction there is a presumption of innocence. After conviction, the convict, save under exceptional circumstances, has no right at all to bail.” (see Ojo v. F.R.N. (supra) Pp. 115-116, paras. F-A)

Bail and Judicial discretion
It is imperative to state that bail pending trial is mostly as of right which is often granted at the discretion of the Court; the discretion must be exercised judicially and judiciously. There are three circumstances under which the Court may consider bail pending trial. These are adequately captured by sections 161, 162 and 163 of the Administration of Criminal Justice Act (ACJA), 2015. The first circumstance is provided under Section 161 of the ACJA and it deals with bail when the defendant is charged with an offence punishable with death. In this case, bail will only be granted under exceptional circumstances which include ill health, extraordinary delay in investigation or prosecution or any other circumstances the judge may consider exceptional (see sections 161 (1) and (2) of the ACJA).
Another circumstance for granting bail pending trial is where the offence is punishable with imprisonment for a term exceeding three years. This is provided under Section 162 of the ACJA. Here, the defendant will be released on bail as of right except where there is evidence that the defendant if released on bail will:
a. commit another offence;
b. attempt to evade trial;
c. attempt to interfere with witness or investigation;
d. attempt to conceal or destroy evidence;
e. prejudice proper investigation; or
f. undermine or jeopardize the objective of criminal justice administration.

From the foregoing, it is clear that the duty is on the prosecution to show that the defendant will do any of the above before the court will deny bail; otherwise, the court will grant bail the moment it is satisfied that the defendant has shown reasons to be granted bail. In Ibrahim v. F.R.N (2017) 15 NWLR (Pt. 1589) 499, Okoronkwo, J. C. A. clearly explained this position when he held as follows:
Section 162 of the Criminal Justice Administration Act did not merely codify principles relating to bail as learned counsel for the respondent argued in 4.08 and 4.09 of his brief. The section i.e. 162 ACJA properly placed the burden of proof where it customarily should be – on the prosecution. (See page 516 paras F – G)
Further to the above stated two sections of the ACJA, Section 163 also states: “In any other circumstances other than those referred to in section 161 and 162 of this Act, the defendant shall be entitled to bail, unless the court sees reasons to the contrary”. This simply implies that where the offence is not punishable with death and does not attract terms of imprisonment exceeding three years, the court would ordinarily grant bail. The conditions for bail under this provision, although discretionary, are mostly simple and very liberal.

Bail Pending Appeal
Bail pending appeal is governed by the Court of Appeal Act, the Supreme Court Act, Court of Appeal Rules, 2021 and the Supreme Court Rules. For instance, section 28(1) of the Court of Appeal Act provides: “The Court of Appeal may if it thinks fit on the application of an appellant admit the appellant to bail pending the determination of the appeal”.
The clear text of the section shows that the constitutional right to bail is lost at the moment of conviction. The Court of Appeal can only grant bail where the applicant applies and the Court “thinks fit”. Therefore, the appellant must show exceptional circumstances which will entitle him to bail. Those circumstances are not exhaustive but have been alluded to in many judicial pronouncements. For instance, it was held in George v. F.R.N. (2010) 11 NWLR (Pt. 1206) 531:
The Court of Appeal will not as a rule grant bail to a prisoner pending the determination of his appeal unless there are exceptional and unusual reasons why bail ought to be granted to him. It is the duty of every applicant for bail to present the necessary materials before the court in support of his application to enable the court exercise its discretion in his favour. The exercise of the discretion must be judicial and judicious. (P. 555, paras. E-G)

Bail and Terrorism Charges
From the foregoing, it is clear that bail pending trial has a lot to do with the nature of the offence and its gravity will come to play in considering application for bail by the defendant at that stage. However, bail pending appeal does not necessarily consider the nature of the charge, although it may come to play in considering the exceptional or unusual circumstances to warrant bail or deny same.
Offences of terrorism in the last decade have become common in Nigeria with attendant threats to corporate existence and survival of the country. For a long time, what constitute offences of terrorism was not poignantly defined by Nigerian laws save sparring reference made to it by the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) Act. Nevertheless with the enactment of a law on Terrorism in 2011 the offences became codified in our laws. (Note that the 2011 Act was amended in 2013 and re-enacted in 2022)
Section 2(1) of the Terrorism (Prevention and Prohibition) Act, 2022 prohibits all acts of terrorism and terrorism financing while subsection (3) of the same section gives elaborate definition of what an act of terrorism means. Punishments for different categories of acts of terrorism ranging from death sentence to different terms of imprisonment including life imprisonment are well outlined under the Act. Offence of terrorism is one of the most serious and heinous crimes in Nigeria. This was alluded to by the Supreme Court in the case of Ogwuche v. F.R.N. [2021] 6 NWLR (Pt.1773) 545 – 547. The Apex Court stated in the case that:
The offence of terrorism which creates intense fear and anxiety both physically and psychologically in the minds of members of the public and which in most cases leads to the death of innocent persons should not be trivialized. It must be given the weight it deserves.
In view of the above, courts are usually circumspect when faced with bail application either pending trial or pending appeal in offences bordering on terrorism. This is not unconnected with the seriousness of the offences, the punishments attached to the offences and the national security consequence of the offences. In Dokubo-Asari v. F.R.N. (2007) 12 NWLR (Pt. 1048) 320; the Supreme Court stated it clearly that where national security is threatened, individual liberty is secondary. Taking a cue from the above, it is not surprising that the Courts are weary of granting bail in terrorism related cases. In fact, section 66 of the Terrorism (Prevention and Prohibition) Act, 2022 empowers the Court upon application ex parte to order detention of a suspect for terrorism related offences for 60 days pending investigation. The detention order is renewable for a similar period where there is a justification to so do. This provision, which is in pari materia with the provision of section 27 of the Terrorism (Prevention and Prohibition) Act, 2011 as amended has been held to be a valid derogation from right to personal liberty and it is not contrary to section 35 of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1999 as amended. In the case of Ogwuche v. F.R.N. [supra], the Supreme Court held that:
The provision in section 27(1) of the Terrorism(Prevention) (Amendment) Act 2013, which empowers the trial court to remand a person reasonably suspected of committing terrorist offences pending conclusion of prosecution or trial of the case is not contrary to section 35(4) of the1999 Constitution (as amended). Section 27(1) of the Terrorism (Prevention) (Amendment) Act, 2013 is empowered by section 35(7)(a) of the Constitution. (P. 560, paras. G-H)
In determining whether a defendant facing trial for offences of terrorism is entitled to bail as envisaged under section 35(4) of the Constitution, the Supreme Court stated clearly that the defendant is not entitled to bail especially where the punishment for the offence is death. In the words of the Supreme Court; “… by virtue of section 35(7)(a) of the Constitution, section 35(4) of the Constitution could not apply to the case of the appellant who was arrested and detained upon reasonable suspicion of having committed an act of terrorism, a(b)capital offence”. (Ogwuche v. F.R.N. [supra] P. 560, paras. A-G)
On bail pending appeal in terrorism cases, the Court of Appeal, towing the line of the Apex Court’s decisions held in ACHEM v. FRN (2014) LPELR-23202 (CA), that:
It should be mentioned that the applicant was convicted and sentenced for offences relating to terrorism, which in recent times have grown in intensity and magnitude and have become a threat to our national security. Courts should therefore be very circumspect in granting bail pending appeal to a person convicted for any offence relating thereto. See also Mohammed v. State (2015) 10 NWLR (pt. 1468) 496 at 512

Conclusion
The summation from the above decisions of both the Court of Appeal and Supreme Court is that despite the provision of right to bail in some circumstances, the right does not inure in a defendant charged with offences of terrorism. The seriousness of the offence and the punishments attached thereto take the right to bail away from the defendant either pending trial or subsequent to conviction. It is however important to emphasise that it is not within the powers of the state to detain indefinitely. Save as provided under section 66 of the Terrorism (Prevention and Prohibition) Act, 2022 which provides for remand protocol in terrorism cases and allows the detention of a suspect for 60 days, renewable for the same period, the state must present a suspect before a competent court of law for prosecution after the exhaustion of the remand period. The tendency of the security apparatus of state to abuse this window is rife. The Courts are therefore, called upon to stand as the bulwark against executive terrorism by granting bail where there are justifiable reasons to do so in line with their powers under section 6 and Chapter IV of the 1999 Constitution as amended notwithstanding the charge of terrorism.

DO YOU WANT TO CONTRIBUTE TO OUR BLOG?

JURITRUST Centre for Socio Legal Research and Documentation invites submission of short articles from VOLUNTEER CONTRIBUTORS who are interested in sharing their perspectives on salient issues in the administration and development of the Nigerian Criminal Justice System, comparative systems and related issues. Click here find out how to send us your articles. Thank you