by juritrustlaw | Nov 8, 2023 |
- Background
Jungle justice, also known as mob justice or extrajudicial punishment, refers to the act of individuals taking the law into their own hands by meting out punishment to alleged offenders without due process. This practice has been a recurrent issue in Nigeria. The Aluu Four incident in October 2012 which led to the murder of 4 students in the Aluu Community of Rivers State by members of the community, who acted based on false allegations is among the numerous painful incidences of jungle justice in Nigeria.
Jungle justice has become a disturbing trend in Nigeria, often fuelled by public frustration at the perceived inefficiency and corruption within the formal criminal justice system and an irate desire to impose immediate punishment on suspected individuals. In most cases of jungle justice, individuals accused of crimes are often subjected to brutal beatings, torture, and even death, without any legal proceedings. This practice not only undermines the rule of law but denies individuals their fundamental rights to a fair trial.
This note highlights the implications and impact of jungle justice on the administration of criminal justice in Nigeria, while highlighting relevant provisions of the law as well as recommend certain measures to bring an end to this menace.
- Implications of Jungle Justice:
a. Denial of Due Process: One of the most significant implications of jungle justice is the denial of due process. Every accused person under law has the right to be presumed innocent until proven guilty, the right to legal representation, and the right to a fair trial. Jungle justice bypasses these fundamental rights, leading to the conviction and punishment of individuals summarily without proper investigation or evidence.
b. Vigilante Violence: Jungle justice perpetuates a cycle of violence and vigilantism. When individuals take the law into their own hands, they act as judge, jury, and executioner. This not only undermines the authority of the State but also encourages a culture of violence, where anyone can become a target based on mere suspicion or rumour.
c. Creates avenues for false and malicious accusations: Jungle justice creates room for persons with vindictive intentions to lay malicious accusations on innocent persons with intent to cause them harm or death, since an accused person facing jungle justice is not given any room to declare their innocence or guilt, there is usually a high chance that the accuser will succeed in leading unsuspecting and overzealous members of the society into doing their dirty work.
d. Ineffectiveness of the Criminal Justice System: The prevalence of jungle justice reflects a lack of confidence in the formal criminal justice system. When citizens resort to extrajudicial means, it highlights the perceived inefficiency, corruption, and delays in the legal process. The failure to trust the established system hinders the administration of justice and erodes public faith in the rule of law.
- Relevant Provisions:
a) The Nigerian Constitution: The 1999 Constitution of Nigeria in Sections 33-36 guarantees the fundamental rights of every citizen, including the right to life, liberty, and fair hearing. These provisions seek to protect individuals from arbitrary punishment and ensure that justice is administered in a fair and transparent manner.
b) Criminal Code and Penal Code: The Criminal Code and Penal Code contain provisions that criminalize acts of jungle justice. Sections 316-319 of the Criminal Code Act and Sections 221-223 of the Penal Code Act explicitly prohibit acts of violence, assault, and murder. Perpetrators of jungle justice can be prosecuted under these provisions.
- Strategic Reforms and Suggestions to Curb Jungle Justice:
To address the issue of jungle justice and its implications on the administration of criminal justice law in Nigeria, several measures need to be taken. These include:
- Strengthening the criminal justice system: Government should invest in improving the capacity and efficiency of the legal system, ensuring that it is capable of effectively investigating and prosecuting crimes. This includes providing adequate resources, training, and support to law enforcement agencies, prosecutors, and judges.
- Public awareness campaigns: There is a need to educate the public about the dangers and consequences of jungle justice. This can be done through media campaigns, community dialogues, and educational programs that promote the importance of the rule of law and respect for human rights.
- Law enforcement and community engagement: The police and other law enforcement agencies should work closely with communities to build trust and encourage them to report crimes rather than resorting to jungle justice. This can be achieved through community policing initiatives, where officers are trained to engage and collaborate with the community to prevent crime and promote safety.
- Accountability and justice: Perpetrators of jungle justice should be held accountable for their actions. The government should ensure that those involved in mob violence are identified, arrested, and prosecuted according to the law. This will send a strong message that such acts will not be tolerated and will help deter future incidents.
Conclusion:
Jungle justice in Nigeria has severe implications for the administration of criminal justice, denying individuals their fundamental rights and perpetuating a culture of violence. To combat this issue, it is crucial to strengthen the formal criminal justice system, promote public awareness of legal rights, and hold perpetrators of jungle justice accountable under the law. By upholding the principles of due process and the rule of law, Nigeria can foster a society where justice is served through established legal channels, ensuring a fair and equitable society for all.
NOTE: The section on legal Briefs is a forum for frank and open scholarly notes by research staff and guest contributors. Views expressed in these notes are personal to the authors and are not to be attributed to the Centre.
DO YOU WANT TO SHARE YOUR VIEWS ON OUR BLOG?
JURITRUST Centre for Socio Legal Research and Documentation invites submission of short articles from VOLUNTEER CONTRIBUTORS who are interested in sharing their perspectives on salient issues in the administration and development of the Nigerian Criminal Justice System, comparative systems and related issues. CLICK HERE find out how to send us your articles. Thank you
by juritrustlaw | Nov 3, 2023 |
BY
ATOYEBI O.M. SAN and BIBIANA A. ADENIJI
There is no gainsaying the fact that technology remains the principal revolutionary agent of the human society.[1] Its impact has been felt in every sector of human interactions and interrelations. From medicine to agriculture, communications, aviation, sports, arts, law, etc., technology has permeated human affairs. Hence nations across the world are fast yielding to the legal demands necessitated by the evolution of technology. This is imperative as a result of the fact that law is the foundation of a modern society[2] and as such must be in tune with the demands of the modern society.
On the 12th of June 2023, President Bola Ahmed Tinubu, the President of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, signed the Evidence Act (Amendment Act) 2023 into law. The aim of the law was to make provisions in relation to the admission of evidence, which is in tune with international best practices. Hence, several adjustments were made to the provisions of the Evidence Act 2011 (the Principal Act) which took cognizance of the growing impact of technology even on the matters of evidence. This article will therefore be giving an overview of the provisions of the 2023 Amendment Act.
KEYNOTE PROVISIONS OF THE EVIDENCE (AMENDMENT) ACT 2023
The Act, in order to bring the provisions of the Evidence Act 2011 up-to-date in accordance with global technological advancements in evidence-taking,[3] made the following amendment:
a. Inclusion of Electronic
The Act amends the provisions of Section 84 of the principal Act relating to the admissibility of electronically generated evidence,[4] particularly subsection 2 of the section which provides for the conditions for their admissibility. More specifically, Subsection 2 (a) was amended to the words ‘electronic records’ implying that a statement contained in a document or an electronic record must satisfy the conditions stated therein for its admissibility. Thus, where an electronic record is sought to be tendered, it must be contained in the certificate of compliance that the computer which produced same was in regular use during that period. Also, a new condition was substituted for Section 84(2)(b) of the Act providing to the effect that information contained in the electronic record, or such information forming a part of a larger body of information must be shown to be regularly fed into the computer in the ordinary course of activities during that period.[5] Furthermore, the conditions stipulated under Section 84 (2) (c) and (d) were amended to apply to electronic records. Thus, the provisions of 84 (2) now apply not only to documents generated from computers in paper form, but also to electronic records.
b. Information in Electronic Form[6]
New sections (Sections 84A – 84D) have been inserted after the provisions of Section 84 of the principal Actrecognising the existence, validity and admissibility of any information produced and tendered in electronicform. Hence, where any law in Nigeria provides for an information to be hand or typewritten or printed, suchlaw will be deemed to be complied with where the information is produced in electronic form and accessiblefor subsequent reference.[7]
c. Admissibility of Computer Records[8]
The Act further expands the meaning of a document to include information contained in an electronic recordprovided the conditions stipulated by the Act are met, and same shall be admissible in evidence without thenecessity of producing the original of such document.[9]
d. Introduction of Digital Signature[10]
In line with the requirement of the law that for a document to be admissible in evidence, same must be dulyexecuted or authenticated, the Act has provided for the authentication of electronic records through the useof digital signatures in such manner or by such technique as may be stipulated by the Act or such othertechnique as the Court may consider reliable.[11] The Conditions for reliability as provided by the Act include:
- The data for creating the signature or the authentication data, within the context of usage, can only belinked to the signatory or authenticator and none other,
- Where an alteration is made to the digital signature, after affixing it to the electronic record for authentication, such alteration must be detectable,
- Where the information contained in the electronic record is altered after same has been authenticated by the digital signature, such alteration must be detectable, and such other conditions as may be prescribed bylaw.
Additionally, for a duly authenticated electronic record to be admissible, a digital signature alleged to havebeen affixed by a person must be proven to belong to such person. This however does not apply to a securedigital signature and a digital signature will be deemed to be secure if:
- The creation data of the signature was under the exclusive control of the signatory alone, and
- Same was stored or affixed in an exclusive manner as may be prescribed.
Besides, the provisions of Section 93 of the Evidence Act 2011 relating to the proof of signature, handwriting or electronic signature were amended to include a digital signature.[12]
e. Electronically Generated Affidavits[13]
The Act amends the provisions of Section 108, 109, 110 and 119 of the principal Act relating to the depositionof affidavits. In line with the new provisions, affidavits can now be deposed to electronically before suchpersons as may be duly authorised to take same but a copy of such must be filed in the registry and may berecognised for any purpose for which it is intended to be used in the court. Hence affidavits deposed towhether in Nigeria[14] or, subject to the provisions of Section 110, outside Nigeria,[15] in person or throughaudio-visual means, are admissible before any court in Nigeria. Furthermore, the requirement of a jurat toaccompany an affidavit under Section 119 of the Principal Act also applies to an electronically generatedaffidavit. Hence where an affidavit is taken via audio-visual means, the electronic record must state whichaudio -visual method was made use of and the date on which it was used.[16]
f. Recognition of an Electronic Gazette[17]
The Amendment Act now recognises an electronic gazette and provides to the effect that any regulation, ruleor such other matters required to be published in the Federal Government Gazette will be deemed to havebeen validly published if same is published in an electronic Gazette.
Finally, the Act amended the interpretation Section of the Principal Act by providing interpretations oftechnological terms used in the Act.
CONCLUSION
Technology continues to shape the human society in more ways than man is conscious of. There is however, aneed to provide legal basis for the interaction of man with technology in the different spheres of humaninterconnection, as the law gives validity to human actions, generally. Thus, the amendment of the EvidenceAct 2011 can be regarded as a step in the right direction, in alignment with international best practices, aimedat providing relative ease to the system of justice administration, curbing administrative bottlenecks in thesystem and generally changing the face of litigation practice in Nigeria.
[1] Mishra, Sriya Shubhalaxmi, “The Advent of Technology and its Impact on the Society” (2019). Available atSSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3598962 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3598962 man, (https://ssrn.com/abstract=3598962) (https://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3598962)
[2] See Jason Neidleman, “The Social Contract Theory in a Global Context” (2012) E-International Relations;https://www.e-ir.info/2012/10/09/the-social-contract-theory-in-a-global-context/ (https://www.e-ir.info/author/jason-neidleman/)
(https://www.e-ir. info/2012/10/09/the-social-contract-theory-in-a-global-context/) (https://omaplex.com.ng)
[3] See the long title to the Evidence Act (Amendment) Act 2023
[4] Section 2 of the Evidence Act (Amendment) Act 2023.
[5] Section 2 (b) EA(A)A 2023.
[6] Section 3 EA(A)A 2023.
[7] See Section 3 EA(A)A 2023.
[8] Section 3 EA(A)A 2023.
[9] Section 84B of the Evidence Act.
[10] Section 3 EA(A)A 2023.
[11] Section 84C of the EA.
[12] Section 4 EA(A)A 2023.
[13] Section 5 EA(A)A 2023.
[14] Section 6 EA(A)A 2023.
[15] Section 7 EA(A)A 2023.
[16] Section 8 EA(A)A 2023.
[17] Section 9 EA(A)A 2023.
NOTE: The section on legal Briefs is a forum for frank and open scholarly notes by research staff and guest contributors. Views expressed in these notes are personal to the authors and are not to be attributed to the Centre.
DO YOU WANT TO SHARE YOUR VIEWS ON OUR BLOG?
JURITRUST Centre for Socio Legal Research and Documentation invites submission of short articles from VOLUNTEER CONTRIBUTORS who are interested in sharing their perspectives on salient issues in the administration and development of the Nigerian Criminal Justice System, comparative systems and related issues. CLICK HERE find out how to send us your articles. Thank you
by juritrustlaw | Nov 2, 2023 |
Fines are a common sanction in countries in all regions of the world. They also pose a significant risk of economic discrimination. Unless they are perfectly scaled to defendants’ financial circumstances, they over-penalise people living in poverty both directly and by triggering additional sanctions where defendants cannot afford to pay. These effects add up to what we call “poverty penalties”: tougher punishments for low-income people resulting from inadequately scaled fines and their snowballing consequences.
In our article “Poverty Penalties as Human Rights Problems” published in the American Journal of International Law in July 2023 together with five other co-authors, we explore harmful poverty penalties around the world and discuss the human rights concerns they raise. We have drawn on the work of domestic scholars, activists, and journalists to identify laws or practices in many countries, including (among others): Australia, Brazil, China, Croatia, Denmark, the Democratic Republic of the Congo, France, Germany, Ghana, Great Britain, Hungary, India, Japan, Jordan, Kenya, Mexico, Nicaragua, Nigeria, Papua New Guinea, Poland, Qatar, Romania, Russia, South Korea, Switzerland, the United Kingdom, and the United States.
Examples of poverty penalties
Poverty penalties come in many forms. Consider the following varieties:
Using fines and costs without adequate attention to individual financial circumstances. Financial sanctions are often imposed without adequately considering the financial situation of the person charged. Many countries set mandatory minimums on certain fines. In Qatar, for example, the fine for intentionally bouncing a check is a minimum of QR 3,000. Even in countries that use “day fines” (income-based fines theoretically scaled to a person’s ability to pay), these fines may be set too high. In 2016, nearly 8,000 people entered German prisons for the petty crime of fare evasion because they couldn’t pay their day fines.
Incarcerating for failure to pay fines. In many countries, if you can’t pay a fine, the typical consequence is imprisonment. In Kenya, for example, Penal Code Section 28 provides that whenever a person is sentenced to a fine, the court may order prison time for defaults on payment of that fine, even if the offence was originally punishable only by a fine. These practices are especially troubling for people in poverty who may never be able to afford the fines in the first place.
Piling on more fines, costs, and fees. Failing to pay fines and fees can result in additional financial sanctions, including through the use of unrealistic installment payment plans. These practices can create a snowballing cycle of debt that is nearly impossible for people living in poverty to escape. For example, in South Korea, if someone cannot pay their fine for a minor offence, then Article 8 of the Punishment of Minor Offences Act provides that they must pay the fine plus a 20% surcharge within twenty days of the original payment deadline. Per Article 9 of that same act, failure to pay by the new deadline can result in additional fines.
Imposing other legal sanctions for defaulting on fine payments. People who fail to pay fines may be subject to other legal sanctions, like drivers’ license suspensions, denial of access to social welfare, or loss of voting privileges. In Brazil, for instance, people can be removed from voter rolls and lose their right to work for nonpayment of fines. Drivers’ license suspensions are common in the United States, where, as of 2021, at least 11 million people could not drive because of their inability to pay fines and fees.
Fining socially marginalised communities. Fining practices can target or disproportionally harm people who are already vulnerable because of race, gender, disability, or other protected statuses. During the COVID-19 lockdowns in the United Kingdom and France, for example, fines for violating the lockdown fell disproportionately on people of colour, raising concerns not just about disproportionate effects but also about intentional targeting.
Although we give only one or two examples for each of these practices here, our research uncovered many more (as discussed in our article). It is clear that nations around the world over-penalise low-income people through their uses of financial sanctions, even though the degree of over-penalisation can vary considerably from place to place.
Poverty penalties raise grave human rights concerns
Poverty penalties are a global issue. They have the effect of discriminating against low-income people, often lead to imprisonment, and can result in other disproportionately harsh punishments. These fining practices are counterproductive for states striving to achieve the Sustainable Development Goal of “[e]nd[ing] poverty in all its forms.”
Our article highlights how these practices may undermine international human rights instruments. In particular, these practices raise serious human rights concerns under the ICCPR and ICESCR. They can constitute discrimination on the basis of property. They can subject people to arbitrary arrest and detention because of their inability to pay. They can amount to disproportionally harsh punishments and intrude on the free enjoyment of economic rights by trapping low-income people in a cycle of never-ending debt. And they frequently target or disproportionately affect racial minorities and other socially marginalised groups. These are serious concerns that the international human rights community must address.
Innovators tackling poverty penalties offer a blueprint for future work
There is growing attention to the issue of poverty penalties, both domestically and internationally. Below are some examples of recent progress in this area:
- In South Korea, Jean Valjean Bank, a microcredit group, has begun lending money to people incarcerated for their inability to pay their criminal fines. Its goal is to create a more equitable system where people living in poverty are no longer imprisoned simply because they are unable to pay.
- In Ghana, the NGO Crime Check Foundation launched the Petty Offenders Project to pay criminal fines for people charged with petty offences, sentenced to pay fines that they could not pay, and subsequently ordered to serve between three to twelve months in prison for defaulting.
- In the United States, the highest court in Washington State struck down economic sanctions of $547 imposed for a parking infraction on a Native American man living in poverty and experiencing homelessness. The court held that the financial sanctions were excessive fines and therefore unconstitutional.
- The Campaign to Decriminalise Poverty and Status brought together an international group of advocates, experts, and activists to address the routine criminalisation of poverty around the world. The resulting Cape Declaration on Decriminalising Poverty and Status noted that the use of fines and other financial sanctions creates a “two-tier system of justice” that disproportionately harms low-income people.
- Several UN Special Rapporteurs have raised grave concerns about fines imposed on low-income people, including in the United States and Cambodia.
These are just some examples of this important work around the world. Our article identifies harmful fining practices, analyses how they raise grave human rights concerns, and proposes reforms. But our work was limited to the languages our research team speaks and the data we could find. We call on stakeholders to examine fining practices in their jurisdictions and evaluate whether these too can act as poverty penalties in practice. With more data, international human rights and criminal justice communities can begin to combat the scourge of poverty penalties.
Credit: Panel Reform International
NOTE: The section on legal Briefs is a forum for frank and open scholarly notes by research staff and guest contributors. Views expressed in these notes are personal to the authors and are not to be attributed to the Centre.
DO YOU WANT TO SHARE YOUR VIEWS ON OUR BLOG?
JURITRUST Centre for Socio Legal Research and Documentation invites submission of short articles from VOLUNTEER CONTRIBUTORS who are interested in sharing their perspectives on salient issues in the administration and development of the Nigerian Criminal Justice System, comparative systems and related issues. CLICK HERE find out how to send us your articles. Thank you
by juritrustlaw | Sep 29, 2023 |
Introduction
The Evidence (Amendment) Act 2023 was passed by the National Assembly and assented to by President Bola Tinubu in June 2023. The Principal Act which it amends i.e. the Evidence Act was enacted into law in 2011. The explanatory memorandum to the 2023 Amendment Act states that the amendment of the Evidence Act is intended to bring its provisions in accordance with global technological advancements in evidence taking which will be applicable to all judicial proceedings in or before courts in Nigeria. The text of the Amendment Act does justice to this intention by making provisions which ensure that evidence may be submitted in an electronic form without the need for a printout of the electronic record or the submission of an electronic record through a physical device. The innovations in the Amendment Act are commendable and will be highlighted below. There are, however, some issues with the Amendment Act in the area of its drafting. These will also be discussed below.
Innovations in the Evidence (Amendment) Act 2023
- Admissibility of electronic records in electronic form
Section 2 of the Amendment Act amends section 84 of the Principal Act (which deals with admissibility of statement in documents produced by computers) by providing for the insertion of the words “or electronic record” after the word “document” in several subsections under section 84. This amendment signifies that electronic records may be tendered directly as evidence. Before the amendment, the Principal Act provided for documents produced by computers to be tendered either in printed form or in a physical device such as a disc or tape. What the amendment does in effect is to reduce the need for submission of hard copy documents or submission of electronic evidence in a device and allow for the electronic record to be tendered in an electronic form, for example by sending through email or by uploading onto a database or the internet.
- Admissibility of electronic forms of information that ought to be submitted in typewritten or printed form
Section 3 of the Amendment Act inserts a new section that states that where a law provides that an information or any other matter shall be in writing or typewritten or printed form, then notwithstanding anything contained in that law, such requirement shall be deemed to have been satisfied if the information is made available in electronic form and accessible when required. This amendment in effect means that electronic copies of documents, information or any other matter are admissible in place of hard copies notwithstanding that a law specifically states that such information must be submitted in printed form.
Admissibility of printout of electronic records without production of the original
Section 3 of the Amendment Act inserts a new section that provides that printouts or copies of an electronic record are admissible without further proof or production of the original as long as the other conditions in the Act are satisfied.
- Use of digital signatures
Section 3 of the Amendment Act inserts a new section that states that digital signatures may be affixed on an electronic record as a means of authenticating the electronic record. A digital signature is defined in the Amendment Act to mean “an electronically generated signature which is attached to an electronically transmitted document to verify its contents and the sender’s identity”. Section 93 of the Principal Act (which provides for proof of execution of documents) is also amended by the insertion of the words “or digital signature” after the words “electronic signature”.
- Use of electronic means to depose to an affidavit
Section 5 of the Amendment Act makes it possible for a person to depose an affidavit electronically using audio-visual means. This means that a person deposing an affidavit does not have to be physically present but may do so through a live audio-visual session which is to be recorded.
- Publication of Gazettes in electronic form
Section 9 of the Amendment Act states that where a law provides that a rule, regulation, notification, or any other matter be published in the Federal Government Gazette, the requirement shall be deemed to have been satisfied if the rule, regulation, notification, or any other matter is published in the Federal Government Gazette or electronic Gazette. This provision, in effect, supports the publication of the Federal Government Gazette in electronic form and the submission of electronic copies of such Gazettes as evidence.
Definition of the word “computer” to include “mobile phones”
Section 10 of the Amendment Act specifically includes “mobile phones” in a new definition of the word “computer”. Although the definition of the word “computer” that was contained in the Principal Act can be interpreted to cover mobile phones, a new definition may have been necessary for the avoidance of doubt.
Drafting Issues with the Evidence (Amendment) Act 2023
- Section 2 of the Amendment Act amends section 84 of the Principal Act by skipping the amendment of section 84 (1) and providing for the amendment of section 84 (2) and other subsections that follow it. This amendment referred to here is the insertion of “electronic records” as a type of documentary evidence that may be admitted by the court. The insertion of “electronic records” by the Amendment Act ought to have started by first amending section 84 (1). This is because section 84 (1) is the foundation for the provisions on the admissibility of statements in documents produced by computers.
- Section 4 of the Amendment Act amends section 93 (1) – (3) of the Principal Act by inserting the words “or digital signature” after the words “electronic signature”. Section 93 (1) of the Principal Act does not have the words “electronic signature” but uses the phrase “signature or the handwriting” in its provision. A reading of section 93 (1) shows that it is outside the purview of the amendment intended by section 4 of the Amendment Act. The Amendment Act should have provided for the amendment of only section 93 (2) – (3).
- Section 10 of the Amendment Act amends section 258 of the Principal Act by inserting the definition of some terms, one of which is “audio-visual communication”. The Amendment Act does not use “audio-visual communication” as a term in its text. It only uses “audio-visual” in certain places and does not use the word “communication” The words that ought to have been defined are “audio-visual” or “audio-visual means”.
- Section 10 of the Amendment Act defines “electronic signature” to mean “authentication of any electronic record by a subscriber by means of the electronic technique specified in the Second Schedule and includes digital signature”. Neither the Amendment Act nor the Principal Act contains a Second Schedule so it is uncertain what Second Schedule is being referred to.
Conclusion
The enactment of the Evidence (Amendment) Act 2023 is commendable. The Act amends the Evidence Act by making provisions that allow the submission of information, documents and evidence in electronic form. The innovations introduced by the Amendment Act, if implemented, will aid the Judiciary in efficient adjudication of matters before it, especially in the areas of easy and fast receipt, storage and retrieval of information, data and evidence. There are, however, errors in the drafting of the Amendment Act. A law that is poorly drafted impedes a clear understanding of the provisions of the law and also has the potential of enabling needless litigation on the interpretation of its provisions. It is imperative that laws are drafted in a clear and correct manner for the easy understanding and interpretation of their content.
NOTE: The section on legal Briefs is a forum for frank and open scholarly notes by research staff and guest contributors. Views expressed in these notes are personal to the authors and are not to be attributed to the Centre.
DO YOU WANT TO SHARE YOUR VIEWS ON OUR BLOG?
JURITRUST Centre for Socio Legal Research and Documentation invites submission of short articles from VOLUNTEER CONTRIBUTORS who are interested in sharing their perspectives on salient issues in the administration and development of the Nigerian Criminal Justice System, comparative systems and related issues. CLICK HERE find out how to send us your articles. Thank you
by juritrustlaw | Sep 6, 2023 |
By
EFENUDU ILUEZI, Studies Fellow, National Judicial Institute, Abuja (Email: EfenuduIluezi@gmail.com )
INTRODUCTION
Data privacy is an increasingly critical issue in the digital age, with individuals’ personal information becoming more vulnerable to misuse and unauthorized access. In Nigeria, data privacy preservation holds significant importance in safeguarding citizens’ rights and ensuring a secure and trustworthy digital environment. As the country continues to embrace digital transformation and the widespread use of technology, protecting personal privacy becomes imperative to foster trust, facilitate economic growth, and uphold human rights.
In recent years, Nigeria has witnessed a surge in the adoption of digital platforms and services, from e-commerce and social media to mobile banking and telecommunication. While these advancements offer numerous benefits and conveniences, they generate vast amounts and categories of personal data which if mishandled can have severe consequences such as identity theft, financial fraud, and reputational damage. Therefore, it is crucial to establish robust legal and regulatory frameworks prioritizing data privacy and ensuring the responsible use and protection of personal information.
The Nigerian Constitution guarantees the right to personal privacy, protecting citizens’ homes, correspondence, telephone conversations, and telegraphic communications. The Nigeria Data Protection Regulation (NDPR) enacted in 2019 provides guidelines for data protection, consent, purpose limitation, data security, data subject rights, and enforcement mechanisms. Despite these legal protections, Nigeria faces challenges due to rapid technological advancements, evolving cyber threats, and limited awareness about data privacy rights.
In light of these considerations, this essay examines the legal framework for data privacy in Nigeria, the fundamental principles governing its protection, the challenges faced, and the measures necessary to enhance data privacy. A comparative analysis of data privacy frameworks in other jurisdictions will also be conducted to draw valuable insights and lessons that can inform and shape Nigeria’s data privacy landscape. By prioritizing the preservation of data privacy, Nigeria can establish itself as a leader in data protection, fostering trust and confidence in the digital ecosystem while respecting individuals’ right to personal privacy.
LEGAL FRAMEWORK FOR DATA PRIVACY IN NIGERIA
As stated in Section 37, the constitutional right to privacy aims to safeguard citizens’ homes, correspondence, telephone conversations, and telegraphic communications. It also serves to protect the overall rights and freedoms of citizens.
The Cybercrime Act of 2015 addressed the prevention, detection, response, investigation, prohibition, and prosecution of cybercrimes and related matters. The Act establishes criteria for law enforcement and security agencies when requesting and using private data information. Section 38 mandates service providers to retain traffic data and subscriber information for two years, using it solely for legitimate purposes with due regard to individuals’ constitutional right to privacy and appropriate measures to preserve data confidentiality. Additionally, the Act penalizes unauthorized access to computer systems, with hackers facing fines of up to N10 million or imprisonment of up to 5 years, depending on the nature of the hack. Recognizing ethical hacking as a legitimate profession, organizations holding sensitive data should be compelled to engage their services to identify vulnerabilities.
Numerous other government institutions have regulations addressing privacy within their specific domains. For instance, the National Identity Management Commission (NIMC) Act of 2007 prohibits the disclosure of registered information, except under particular circumstances, such as national security or crime prevention, as specified by the Commission. The 2016 Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) Consumer Protection Framework ensures the confidentiality of customer information but allows disclosure in certain situations required by the CBN or other regulatory bodies. The Credit Reporting Act of 2017 safeguards credit information with consent requirements but permits disclosure for credit-related purposes or compliance with court orders or regulatory requirements.
Additionally, the Child Rights Act of 2003 guarantees children’s privacy rights, with provisions for parental supervision. The National Health Act of 2014 upholds healthcare users’ information confidentiality, laying down specific conditions for disclosure and measures to prevent unauthorized changes or copying of health records.
Primarily however, Data Protection Act 2023 was signed into law in Nigeria on June 12, 2023, marking an important step towards comprehensive data protection legislation. The Act introduces principles common to international data protection frameworks and includes special provisions. It establishes a new category of “data controllers and processors of major importance” and emphasizes a “duty of care.” The Act has extraterritorial reach, limits legitimate interest as a legal basis for data processing, and strengthens data subject rights. It also brings structural changes to the data protection authority and co-exists with the existing Nigeria Data Protection Regulation.
In all, individuals must control their data through informed consent, purpose limitations, protection obligations, and data subject rights. Organizations must obtain explicit consent before collecting and processing data and individuals should be allowed to withdraw consent.
CHALLENGES TO DATA PRIVACY IN NIGERIA
Misuse of “Valid Interests”: The Data Protection Act 2023 allows data processing based on “valid interests.” This provision might be exploited by some data controllers and processors to evade their responsibilities as outlined in the Act.
- No Definite Timeframe for Rights Requests: The Act does not specify a clear and defined period within which data controllers are required to address rights requests from data subjects. This lack of a timeframe has the potential to hinder transparency and accountability in data processing.
- Concerns over Commission’s Autonomy: There are concerns about the autonomy of the Nigeria Data Protection Commission due to the President’s authority to appoint and remove key members. This power dynamic could potentially influence the Commission’s decisions and compromise its independence.
- Data Breaches: Data breaches pose a significant challenge in terms of threatening data privacy, exposing personal information to unauthorized access and misuse, potentially leading to identity theft and financial fraud.
- Lack of Awareness: Many individuals lack awareness about their data privacy rights and responsibilities. This lack of awareness makes them vulnerable to privacy infringements and hinders their ability to effectively exercise their rights.
- Inadequate Enforcement and Penalties: Inadequate enforcement mechanisms and penalties can weaken data privacy protection. Without strong enforcement, organizations may not have sufficient incentives to comply with data protection regulations, potentially leaving individuals’ data vulnerable to misuse.
RECOMMENDATIONS TO THE CHALLENGES
To comprehensively address these identified challenges and contribute to strengthening data privacy protection in Nigeria, the following recommendations are made:
- The Act is amended to provide a clear and comprehensive definition of what constitutes “valid interests” to prevent its misuse and oversight mechanisms be implemented to monitor and review data processing activities based on “valid interests” to ensure compliance with the Act.
- The Act should specify a reasonable timeframe within which data controllers must address rights requests from data subjects, promoting transparency and accountability. Implement penalties for data controllers who fail to respond within the stipulated timeframe to incentivize timely responses.
- Options are explored to enhance the independence of the Nigeria Data Protection Commission, such as limiting the President’s authority to appoint and remove key members and implementing mechanisms for external oversight of the Commission’s decisions and actions to ensure checks and balances.
- Enforcement of stringent cybersecurity measures to prevent data breaches, including encryption, regular security audits, and regular employee training.
- Prompt mandatory organisation report of data breaches to the Commission and affected individuals to facilitate timely action.
- Launch comprehensive public awareness campaigns to educate individuals about their data privacy rights and responsibilities, the inclusion of data privacy education in school curricula and workplace training programs.
- Review and increase penalties for non-compliance with data protection regulations to create stronger deterrents.
- Allocate more resources and personnel to the Commission for effective enforcement and monitoring of data protection compliance.
CONCLUSION
Data privacy is paramount in Nigeria to protect individuals’ rights and foster trust in the digital ecosystem. The legal framework, including constitutional provisions and statutory laws such as the NDPR, provides a foundation for data privacy protection. However, technological advancements, data breaches, lack of awareness, and enforcement gaps must be addressed. Strengthening the legal framework, enhancing enforcement mechanisms, and promoting education are essential for adequate data privacy protection. By prioritizing data privacy, Nigeria can ensure the right to personal privacy and establish a secure and trustworthy digital environment for its citizens.
NOTE: The section on legal Briefs is a forum for frank and open scholarly notes by research staff and guest contributors. Views expressed in these notes are personal to the authors and are not to be attributed to the Centre.
DO YOU WANT TO SHARE YOUR VIEWS ON OUR BLOG?
JURITRUST Centre for Socio Legal Research and Documentation invites submission of short articles from VOLUNTEER CONTRIBUTORS who are interested in sharing their perspectives on salient issues in the administration and development of the Nigerian Criminal Justice System, comparative systems and related issues. CLICK HERE find out how to send us your articles. Thank you
by juritrustlaw | Aug 31, 2023 |
In the world today, many business outfits have an online platform – several exclusively. This was a significant change introduced to the world by the pandemic era, as we saw a hasty and steady rise in the digital transformation of businesses across various sectors.The creation of digital platforms as part of the product and processes of engineering a digital transformation for businesses should be done with due consideration to the provisions of the laws governing the territory where such a digital platform hopes to be operational.
In this article, I discuss aspects of Nigerian law that anyone intending to establish a digital platform targeted at the Nigerian market should consider ensuring compliance with in order to protect users’ rights and mitigate potential risks. A digital platform is a set of systems and interfaces that form a commercial network or market for facilitating business-to-business (B2B), business-to-consumer (B2C), or even customer-to-consumer (C2C) transactions. In simpler terms, a digital platform is a virtual location for producers and consumers to exchange information, goods, or services, as well as the community that interacts with that platform.
Some examples of digital platforms include:
E-commerce Platforms: Jumia, Konga
Social Media Platforms: Facebook, Instagram, and X (formerly known as Twitter)
Ride-Sharing Platforms: Uber, Bolt, and Indriver
Food Delivery Platforms: Jumiafood, Glovo, Boltfood
Freelance and gig platforms: Upwork, Fiverr
Content Sharing Platforms: YouTube, TikTok
Financial Platforms: Flutterwave, Moniepoint
Establishing a digital platform in any country involves a range of legal considerations to ensure compliance with local regulations, protect users’ rights, and mitigate potential risks. Below are some legal considerations peculiar to the Nigerian business environment:
Business Structure
At the outset of any business venture is a determination on the type of structure the business should adopt. In Nigeria, the Companies and Allied Matters Act 2020 (CAMA) is the principal law governing the establishment of business structures. It provides for a variety of business structures that a digital platform can adopt and register with the nation’s Corporate Affairs Commission (CAC). CAMA provides for business structures like a private company limited by shares, a public company limited by shares, a limited liability partnership, a company limited by guarantee, a business name, and an incorporated trustee, along with their legal responsibilities and liabilities. Recourse must be had to the type of solutions provided by a digital platform and its long-term objectives to decide which of these structures are most suitable for a digital platform.
Compliance with sector-specific standards
A sector is an area of the economy in which businesses share the same or related business activity, product, or service. Sector-specific standards are guidelines and specifications developed by regulatory bodies or industry organizations to ensure compliance, consistency, and best practices within a particular field or sector. These standards define the requirements, processes, and expectations for companies in that industry. Owners of digital platforms are expected to comply with sector-specific requirements associated with their primary industrial activity and any co-located industrial activities. These requirements are to ensure monitoring and control of businesses in a sector in order to protect consumers against monopoly abuse, protect investors, monitor the performance of the digital platforms, and ensure the government of the operating state is kept updated about the activities of the owners of the digital platforms.
In Nigeria, the Central Bank of Nigeria Act of 2007 charges the CBN with the overall control and administration of the monetary and financial sector policies of the Federal Government. As a result, all digital finance platforms and providers of digital finance solutions will need to carefully look through the CBN’s regulations and guidelines available at https://www.cbn.gov.ng/documents/guidelines.asp to see the requirements that they are meant to comply with.
Also, it is worthy of note that the activities of digital platforms can cause them to be responsible to different sector regulators. An example is a health insurance tech solution that has become popular among employers of labour in Nigeria for its ability to connect employees to hospitals close to their location, affordable provision of healthcare for employees, and speedy delivery of drugs. The National Health Insurance Authority established by the National Health Insurance Authority Act 2022 is the statutory agency of the Federal Government of Nigeria established by the law to regulate health insurance for all residents in Nigeria. The platform will also be partly regulated by the National Agency for Food and Drug Administration and Control (NAFDAC), which is the statutory entity responsible for the regulation and control of the manufacture, importation, exportation, distribution, advertisement, sale, and use of drugs in Nigeria.
Intellectual Property Rights:
Closely associated with operating a digital platform are the inevitable incidences of intellectual property theft through several technologically sophisticated means. Digital platforms are a combination of software programs, source codes, and a unique user interface to enable the collection of data, sale of products, and interaction with users. These elements form the intellectual property of the owners of digital platforms which deserve protection.
Under Nigerian copyright law, computer programs (also known as software) are considered literary works and are eligible for copyright protection if they are the author’s original work and have been fixed in a specific medium of expression. Software can also be protected in Nigeria under the Patent and Design Act if it meets the fundamental standards for patentability. Unlike copyright, which protects software codes, a patent protects the innovation, including the method and processes employed in generating the software, once established in a tangible manner. Likewise, a trademark can also be used to protect and secure the exclusive rights to the software’s brand name, logo, and tagline, also known as its titles associated with a digital platform.
In conclusion, the advent of digital platforms has enabled the establishment of strategic business partnerships, a wider reach to customers and potential customers for businesses, and an overall scale in business growth. However, to remain relevant, owners of digital platforms must be prepared to align their operations with the existing legal requirements of their operating region. This is essential to gaining citizens trust in their product and continued patronage.
Nenenwa Godwin is an associate at Lexworth Legal Partners, where she practices law in the areas of business and transaction law, regulatory compliance, and corporate governance. You may also find her earlier article on Compliance Requirements of Nigerian Companies under the new Data Protection Act 2023 interesting.
NOTE: The section on legal Briefs is a forum for frank and open scholarly notes by research staff and guest contributors. Views expressed in these notes are personal to the authors and are not to be attributed to the Centre.
DO YOU WANT TO SHARE YOUR VIEWS ON OUR BLOG?
JURITRUST Centre for Socio Legal Research and Documentation invites submission of short articles from VOLUNTEER CONTRIBUTORS who are interested in sharing their perspectives on salient issues in the administration and development of the Nigerian Criminal Justice System, comparative systems and related issues. CLICK HERE find out how to send us your articles. Thank you