Introduction
The Proceeds of Crime (Recovery and Management) Act (POCA) was passed into law in Nigeria in 2022. The Act was enacted to make comprehensive provisions for the seizure, confiscation, forfeiture, and management of properties reasonably suspected to have been derived from unlawful activities. The enactment of POCA was well received in view of the fact that corruption is a huge problem in the Nigerian public sector. The Act has provisions that target the receipt and management of proceeds of crimes including stolen public funds which may have been stashed in offshore banks or used to acquire assets in foreign countries.
POCA provides for non-conviction based recovery and conviction based recovery of the proceeds of crime. In conviction based recovery, an order of confiscation is made by the court only if the defendant has been convicted of the crime. Confiscation is defined in section 82 of POCA to mean “the permanent deprivation of funds or other assets by order of a competent authority or a Court”. The recovery of proceeds of crime is important for the following reasons: to compensate the victim of the crime, to prevent the proceeds from being employed to commit further crimes and to deter others from committing the same crime.
In the News
Recently, a British court in the United Kingdom issued an order directing Mr James Ibori, a former Governor of Delta State, Nigeria to immediately pay 101.5 million pounds or face an eight-year jail sentence. The confiscation order of the court directing Ibori to pay 101.5 million pounds was made pursuant to the conviction of Ibori in a British court in 2012. While facing trial before the British court, Ibori pleaded guilty to money laundering and related offences of fraud to the tune of 50 million pounds which he committed during his tenure as the Governor of Delta State. He was sentenced to 13 years of imprisonment and after serving the minimum term of imprisonment, he was released from jail. In the confiscation proceedings which were held years after his release from jail, the Judge formally declared that Ibori had benefited from criminal conduct in the sum of 101.5 million pounds and made an order for Ibori to pay that amount.In response to the confiscation order, Ibori stated that he would file an appeal and he also raised issues of his properties being the subject of a restraint order and that his assets are below the amount of the confiscation order. Although Ibori’s case was tried in a British court and the court’s orders were made under the United Kingdom’s Proceeds of Crime Act 2002, the issues raised in his case are still relevant to a discussion on the Nigeria Proceeds of Crime Act, 2022.
Implementation of a Confiscation Order
Section 45 (1) of POCA provides that the Court may make a confiscation order requiring a person to pay to the relevant organisation for deposit into the designated account, an amount equal to the total proceeds of a person’s criminal activities. As seen in Ibori’s case, certain issues may arise from the implementation of a confiscation order. These sorts of issues will be outlined below with a note on how Nigeria POCA addresses those issues.
- Issue of how the assets of the defendant are ascertained
In the investigation and seizure of assets pursuant to restraint or confiscation orders, there are cases where the assets and properties of other persons who are not parties to the case are lumped together with those of the defendant. The question then arises as to the proper way of ascertaining that certain assets are owned by the defendant and not third parties.
Section 48 (1) of POCA lists properties of the defendant which may be realized to satisfy a confiscation order. They are-
- Property held by the defendant.
- Property held by a person to whom that defendant has directly or indirectly made any affected gift.
- Property that is subject to the effective control of the defendant.
Section 50 (3) defines “affected gift” to mean any gift made by the convicted person concerned, where it was a gift of property received by that convicted person in connection with an offence committed or any part which directly or indirectly represented in that convicted person’s hands property received by him in connection with an offence committed by him or any other person.The relevant organisations are expected to follow the provisions of POCA in identifying properties that are realizable for the satisfaction of court orders against the defendant. Where there are third-party claims to such properties, it is expected that those third parties apply to the court to prove their ownership of those properties as well as to prove that the properties are not proceeds of criminal activity.
2. Issue of the defendant’s assets being subject to a restraint order
A confiscation order is made after the defendant is convicted of the crime. While the trial is ongoing, restraint orders are usually made on the assets of the defendant to prevent the defendant from disposing of those assets before the conclusion of the criminal case. Restraint orders do not automatically expire when a confiscation order is made and remain in force until the confiscation order is satisfied. The issue that arises is the inability of the defendant to satisfy the confiscation order because he cannot sell his assets due to the existence of a restraint order on those assets.
Section 36 (5) (a) of POCA provides that the court making a restraint order shall, at the same time, make an order authorising the relevant organisation or an authorised person acting on its behalf, to take custody or control of any property specified in the order. Under section 33 (c) and (e), the relevant organization is expected to implement confiscation proceedings against a convicted person and the realisable properties are supposed to be preserved and available to satisfy a confiscation order. From the above provisions, it is clear that under POCA, the same organization is tasked with the implementation of restraint and confiscation orders. Where a defendant is unable to satisfy a confiscation order due to the presence of a restraint order on his assets, it is easy for the relevant organization to dispose of the same assets to satisfy the confiscation order since it has custody and control of the assets.
Under the United Kingdom’s POCA, different persons implement restraint and confiscation orders. A management receiver protects properties that are subject to a restraint order while an enforcement receiver disposes properties for the purpose of satisfying a confiscation order. Where a defendant is unable to satisfy a confiscation order within the time specified, it is expected that the enforcement receiver will liaise with the management receiver for the disposal of the defendant’s properties which are subject to the restraint order.
3. Issue of the value of the confiscation order being greater than the value of the assets that are subject to a restraint order
There are instances where the value of the confiscation order is different from either the value of the proceeds of the crime committed or the value of the properties that are subject to a restraint order. This variation of the confiscation order is dependent on the law of the jurisdiction where the case is tried. In Ibori’s case, for example, he was convicted of offences to the tune of 50 million pounds while his confiscation order was set at 101.5 million pounds. This is because, under United Kingdom’s POCA, the confiscation order is calculated based on what the defendant has benefitted from the crime. The calculation therefore goes beyond the financial crime amount but includes the resulting gain from the defendant employing the wealth, resources and property gotten from the commission of the crime.
Under Nigeria’s POCA, section 45 (5) puts an upper limit on the amount the court can ask the defendant to pay in the confiscation order. Section 45 (5) provides that the amount that the court may order a convicted person to pay to the relevant organisation shall not exceed-
(a) the value of the convicted person’s proceeds from the offences or criminal activity, as determined by the court, in accordance with the provisions of the Act; or
(b) an amount, which in the Court’s opinion may be realised, if the Court is satisfied that the amount which might be realised as contemplated under this Act is less than the value referred to in paragraph (a) of this subsection.
From the provision of Nigeria’s POCA, it is not contemplated that the amount in the confiscation order may be greater than the amount of funds derived from the crime. Instead, the court may assess the amount on the confiscation order to be lesser.In both the Nigeria and United Kingdom’s POCA, where the value of the properties of the defendant that are subject to a restraint order is less than the value of the confiscation order, the defendant is expected to make up the balance that may remain on the confiscation order after selling his assets. However, in both jurisdictions, the court also has the discretion to vary the confiscation order to a lesser amount than the amount of the proceeds derived from the criminal activity.
Conclusion
The Nigeria Proceeds of Crime Act 2022 makes extensive provisions for the recovery of proceeds of crime. This is an important law in Nigeria which ought to help in curbing corrupt practices and ensuring that looted funds are recovered and returned to the rightful owners which is the public. The Act makes extensive provisions covering the making of confiscation orders by the court and the implementation of those orders. Some issues that may arise in the implementation of confiscation orders have been highlighted and discussed above.
NOTE: The section on legal Briefs is a forum for frank and open scholarly notes by research staff and guest contributors. Views expressed in these notes are personal to the authors and are not to be attributed to the Centre.
DO YOU WANT TO SHARE YOUR VIEWS ON OUR BLOG?
JURITRUST Centre for Socio Legal Research and Documentation invites submission of short articles from VOLUNTEER CONTRIBUTORS who are interested in sharing their perspectives on salient issues in the administration and development of the Nigerian Criminal Justice System, comparative systems and related issues. CLICK HERE find out how to send us your articles. Thank you