Justice Must be Rooted in Truth and Not Fantasy and Arid Legal Technicalities   By J.S. Okutepa

Justice Must be Rooted in Truth and Not Fantasy and Arid Legal Technicalities By J.S. Okutepa

 

Not too long ago, seventeen senior advocates of Nigeria, SANs, of Kogi State extraction wrote and protested to NJC and the Hon Chief Judge of Kogi State about the appointments of additional judges for Kogi State.

The protest was based on the lopsided proposals to appoint some persons as additional judicial officers for the state and the lack of infrastructures to accommodate such appointments given the terrible unhygienic judicial environments that judges in the state are currently subjected to.

Given our vintage positions and the privilege we enjoyed under the law, we had thought that we would at least be heard by the relevant authorities and a reply done to our protest letter. Nothing of such was done.

We then thought and reasonably too that there were justifiable causes to complain, and in the process we decided to approach the court where we felt we can be given level playing ground of hearing that would be just and fair. Seven of us sued. I was among the seven eminent senior advocates of Nigeria that went to court.

That is the case of YUNUS USTAZ USMAN, SAN & 6 ORS vs NATIONAL JUDICIAL COUNCIL & 3 ORS suit No FHC/ ABJ/ CS/ 05/2024. It was filed on 8th of January 2024. On the 18th of April 2024, the Federal High Court sitting in Abuja delivered a judgment in that case in which that court found no merits in the case and dismissed it.

Before judgment, the court formulated two issues for determination.These are: Whether the court has jurisdiction to determine the suit filed by the plaintiffs and whether the plaintiffs are entitled to the reliefs sought. These said issues were resolved against the Plaintiffs in favour of the Defendants on the grounds of lack of locus standi.

It was the view of the court that as plaintiffs, we failed to demonstrate infringement of our rights by the Defendants, and the suit was dismissed on this ground. The court held further that the plaintiffs’ failure to establish interest rendered the suit academic.

The court then held that by the failure to establish locus standi, the plaintiffs were deemed to be busybodies, resulting in dismissal of the matter.

The court went further to hold that assuming we the Plaintiffs had Locus standi, our reliefs were dismissed on the grounds of failure to exhaust administrative remedies of doctrines of rightness and exhaustion. The Plaintiffs it held did not pursue administrative remedies, rendering the suit unripe for adjudication for what the court called failure to give NBA due notice.

The court further held that there were procedural omissions: The plaintiffs, according to court, neglected essential procedural steps outlined under the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria as amended. The court also held that by virtue of section 271 of the 1999 constitution of Federal Republic of Nigeria as amended, the first defendant has discretion in judges’ appointments. Consequently, the suit was dismissed accordingly for having no leg to stand.

The court also expunged the DVD video, and photos tendered through my humble self for having not been tendered by the maker and that it amounts to documentary hearsay, amongst other reasons. The dismissal of this case is as unfortunate and unfair as the fact that the court closed its eyes to obvious truth on the arid legal technicalities in sabotage of a just cause.

I have always wondered the sense of justice we see in our courts. Justice must be rooted in truth and not fantasy and arid legal technicalities that fail to see truth where truth is visible. The photos and videos I attached to my affidavit were downloaded from the Internet. There was a certificate of compliance. The court watched and viewed these videos and saw the horrible state of dilapidation of the courts in Kogi State. The court did not hide its lamentations on the state of the courts in Kogi State on the day it watched these videos in open court.

The way courts decide cases and have the mind to close eyes to obvious truth before them in abuse of the sacred duties bestowed on them by law makes me wonder why they do so. It appears the courts appear ready to do the bidding of the system and pandered to the dictate of unjust system to the prejudices of the progress of the judiciary and appointing process.
I have come to think that as a system, some of courts enjoyed the rotten processes in judicial appointments.

Anyone who labours to ensure that the right things are done are branded as busy bodies and persons with no interest in the matter. Nigeria is ours to make or destroy by the kind of justice system we operate.The kind of appointments we make to the bench have ripple and multiple effects on the justice we get and the morals we boosted.

When the system and power that be decided to recommend appointments to the bench based on persons who may be and who appear morally and intellectually inept and those who know somebody and connected to power that be and not based on moral uprightness and intellectually sound knowledge of the law, those who have reasons to approach the courts should not be turned away on arid legal technicalities of Locus Standi.

By this decision, the judiciary and those who are responsible for appointments have wittingly and / or unwittingly laid and solidified the foundation for destruction of the judiciary.

To describe seven eminent Senior Advocates of Nigeria who raised genuine and real concerns about the rotteness of the infrastructures of Kogi judiciary and the breaches of the Nigerian constitution in the processes for the proposed appointments of judicial officers in that state as busybodies is uncharitable and laughable to say the least. It is an abuse of judicial knowledge and language.

But let it be known that when slaves are comfortable in their slavery they see every effort at giving them freedom as obstacles. For me, posterity will decide tomorrow who has destroyed justice and the judiciary in Nigeria. No legal practitioner is a medlesome interloper in the affairs of justice and administration of justice, including appointments to the bench.

The bar fights for the welfare and interests of the legal profession and to hold any members of the noble profession as being a busybody in the affiairs of justice is to say the least sad and unfortunate generalization of the phrase busybody.

For me and the rest of us, we are not busybodies. We are reasonable legal practitioners with sincere concerns for the welfare and interests of judiciary and judicial officers, both serving, retiring, retired and those yet to be appointed. The suit we filed was in furtherance of our concerns for the good of the judiciary and our fidelity to the oaths we took both when we became lawyers and as senior Advocates of Nigeria.

We sworn to defend and uphold the constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria. To describe the suit filed by seven eminent silks in furtherance of the oaths we took as been suit filed by busybodies is not only sad, it is unfortunately uncomplimentary and uncharitable. It’s sad, to say the least. We leave the rest for posterity to judge. That is my stand on this matter and I wish the judiciary well in Nigeria.

 

 


NOTE: The section on legal Briefs is a forum for frank and open scholarly notes by research staff and guest contributors. Views expressed in these notes are personal to the authors and are not to be attributed to the Centre.

DO YOU WANT TO SHARE YOUR VIEWS ON OUR BLOG?

JURITRUST Centre for Socio Legal Research and Documentation invites submission of short articles from VOLUNTEER CONTRIBUTORS who are interested in sharing their perspectives on salient issues in the administration and development of the Nigerian Criminal Justice System, comparative systems and related issues. CLICK HERE find out how to send us your articles. Thank you

Breaking News: Nigerian court orders INEC to publish audited election expenditure for political parties.

Breaking News: Nigerian court orders INEC to publish audited election expenditure for political parties.

A Federal High Court in Akure, Ondo State capital, on Thursday, granted an Order of Mandamus compelling the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) to publish the 2021 and 2022 Audited Financial Statements.

The court also granted an Order of Mandamus to publish the Audited 2023 election-related incomes and expenses of all the registered political parties in Nigeria.

The presiding judge, Hon. Justice T.B. Adegoke gave the order while delivering judgment in Suit FHC//AK/CS/72/2023 – Femi Emmanuel Emodamori v. INEC.

In the judgment, the Court also directed INEC to provide the Applicant (Mr. Femi Emmanuel emodamori), a certified true copy of the audited financial statements for 2021 and 2022, and separate Audited financial statements for the election-related revenue and expenditure of all registered political parties of Nigeria for the financial year 2023 within 14 days of the judgement date.

Justice Adegoke held that the decision was in line with Section 225(1)-(2) and Paragraph 15(d) of Part 1 of the Third Schedule to the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1999 (as amended), Section 89 (3), (4), (5) and (8) of the Electoral Act, 2022, and Section 1(3) of the Freedom of Information Act, 2011.

In September 2023, a legal counselor, Emodamori, had sued the INEC for its refusal to comply with the 14-day final proposal issued to distribute the 2021 and 2022 Examined Yearly Monetary Explanations as well as the Examined 2023 Race Costs of all the political parties. 

Emodamori said on August 24, 2023, he gave the electoral umpire 14 days to publish and avail him the certified true copies of the 2021 and 2022 Audited Annual Financial Statements as well as the Audited 2023 Election Expenses of all the political parties in Nigeria, in line with Section 225(1)-(2) and Paragraph 15(d) of Part 1 of the Third Schedule to the 1999 Constitution, Section 89 (3)-(8) of the Electoral Act, 2022, and Section 1(1) of the Freedom of Information Act, 2011 but that it failed to do so.

He explained that the suit he instituted through a team of seven lawyers, led by A. Olu Ogidan, was seeking an Order of Mandamus to compel INEC to perform its statutory duties.

Emodamori said, “Following the failure of INEC to comply with the 14-day ultimatum I gave  her on 24th August, 2023 to publish and avail me the certified true copies of the 2021 and 2022 Audited Annual Financial Statements as well as the Audited 2023 Election Expenses of all the political parties in Nigeria, in line with Section 225(1)-(2) and Paragraph 15(d) of Part 1 of the Third Schedule to the 1999 Constitution, Section 89 (3)-(8) of the Electoral Act, 2022, and Section 1(1) of the Freedom of Information Act, 2011, I have instituted a Suit at the Federal High Court against INEC, praying for an Order of Mandamus to compel her to perform her statutory duties in that regard.

“I instituted the Suit through a team of seven lawyers, led by A. Olu Ogidan. We cannot sincerely talk about fighting corruption, until we first beam our searchlights on how political parties and elections are funded in Nigerian, and the reciprocal patronage, access to national treasury or ‘dividends’ granted or paid to such political ‘investors’, usually at the expense of our collective national interests.

“INEC can also not claim to be above board, when it lacks the courage to investigate and publish the accounts of such parties for public information as expressly required under our laws.”

 

Legal Measures to Combat Female Genital Mutilation in Nigeria:  by Queenetta Bassey, Esq

Legal Measures to Combat Female Genital Mutilation in Nigeria: by Queenetta Bassey, Esq

 

Introduction

Female Genital Mutilation (FGM), also known as female circumcision or female genital cutting, refers to the partial or total removal of external female genitalia or other injury to the female genital organs for non-medical reasons. FGM is recognized internationally as a violation of the human rights of girls and women. It reflects deep-rooted gender inequality and constitutes an extreme form of discrimination against women. Despite efforts to eradicate the practice, FGM continues to be prevalent in Nigeria, affecting the fundamental human rights of women across the country.

The Practice of Female Genital Mutilation in Nigeria

Female Genital Mutilation is a deeply ingrained cultural practice in Nigeria, particularly among certain ethnic groups. According to the World Health Organization (WHO), Nigeria has one of the highest prevalence rates of FGM in the world, with an estimated 20 million Nigerian women and girls having undergone the procedure. The practice is often justified on cultural, religious, and social grounds, and is believed to control women’s sexuality, ensure their chastity, and prepare them for marriage.

 

Impact on Fundamental Human Rights of Women

The practice of female genital mutilation (FGM) has far-reaching implications for the fundamental human rights of women in Nigeria. Female genital mutilation violates the rights to health, security, physical integrity, and freedom from discrimination and violence of women and young girls. It can lead to a range of physical, psychological, and sexual complications, including severe pain, hemorrhage, infection, infertility, psychological trauma and in very extreme cases death. Furthermore, FGM perpetuates gender inequality and reinforces harmful gender stereotypes, depriving women of their autonomy and decision-making power over their own bodies.

 

Existing Legal Provisions

  1. 1999 Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria

Section 34 (1)(a) of the Nigerian Constitution states that “Every individual is entitled to respect for the dignity of his person, and accordingly – (a) no person shall be subjected to torture or to inhuman or degrading treatment.”

The above provision of law although not explicitly referring to the act of Female Genital Mutilation, however covers every act that subjects a person to inhuman or other degrading treatment which gives a clear description of what a victim of FGM is put under while going through the crude procedure involved in FGM.

  1. Child Rights Act (CRA) 2003

Section 11(b) of this Act provides that “no child shall be subjected to any form of torture, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment”

This Act, applicable only in 35 States of Nigeria including the FCT with the exclusion of Gombe State, prohibits degrading acts against children and provides for the protection of children’s rights. It imposes penalties on offenders and emphasizes the importance of education and awareness programs against actions that are detrimental to a child’s welfare. Notwithstanding the umbrella protection contained in the proviso above, the Act just like the 1999 CFRN did not expressly refer or mention Female genital mutilation (FGM) thereby limiting the prosecutorial power of the law in cases of FGM under this Act.

 

  1. Violence Against Persons (Prohibition) Act 2015

Section 6 (1), (2) , (3) and (4) of the Violence Against Persons (Prohibition) Act 2015 provides that;

  1. (1) The circumcision or genital mutilation of the girl child or woman is hereby prohibited.

(2) A person who performs female circumcision or genital mutilation or engages another to carry out such circumcision or mutilation commits an offence and is liable on conviction to a term of imprisonment not exceeding 4 years or to a fine not exceeding N200,000.00 or both.

(3) A person who attempts to commit the offence provided for in subsection (2) of this section commits an offence and is liable on conviction to a term of imprisonment not exceeding 2 years or to a fine not exceeding N100,000.00 or both.

(4) A person who incites, aids, abets, or counsels another person to commit the offence provided for in subsection (2) of this section commits an offence and is liable on conviction to a term of imprisonment not exceeding 2 years or to a fine not exceeding N100,000.00 or both.

 

The provision of this Act unlike other previously mentioned legislations directly criminalizes female genital mutilation and provides for punishment, including imprisonment and fines, for offenders. The National Agency for the Prohibition of Trafficking in Persons (NAPTIP) established for the implementation of the VAPPA, upgraded the Sexual and Gender Based Violence Unit to the Violence Against Persons Prohibitions Department to ensure the effective implementation of the Act.

Enforcement Challenges

Despite the existence of the above mentioned legislations, criminalizing the commission and enabling of female genital mutilation in Nigeria, the prosecution of these cases still faces significant challenges and limitations. One major challenge is the deep-seated cultural acceptance of FGM, which makes it difficult for survivors and witnesses to come forward and report cases. Additionally, limited awareness of the legal provisions and inadequate enforcement of the laws contribute to the under-reporting and impunity surrounding FGM cases. Furthermore, the lack of specialized training for law enforcement officials and judicial personnel hinders the effective investigation and prosecution of FGM cases.

 

Reform Measures

To combat the practice of FGM in Nigeria and protect the fundamental human rights of women, here are some reformative and legal recommendations:

  1. Implementation of Legislation Against FGM: there is need for proper Implementation of existing legislations that specifically criminalizes all forms of FGM in Nigeria.
  2. Legal Protection for Victims: there is need to strengthen and widen legal protections available for victims of FGM, including provisions for restraining orders and emergency shelters for those at risk of undergoing the procedure. Also, it is important to ensure that victims have access to legal aid and support services to seek justice and protection from further harm.
  3. Institutional Capacity Building: Government must build the capacity of law enforcement agencies, judiciary, and healthcare professionals to effectively respond to cases of FGM. Provide training on identifying, investigating, and prosecuting FGM cases, as well as sensitization on the rights of women and girls.
  4. Education and Awareness Programs: stakeholders including State actors should introduce and fund educational programs targeting communities where FGM is prevalent. These programs should focus on raising awareness about the harmful physical, psychological, and social consequences of FGM. They should also emphasize the importance of gender equality and human rights.
  5. Community Engagement and Empowerment: there is need for State and non-state actors to engage with community leaders, religious authorities, and traditional practitioners to gain their support in abandoning the horrific practice of FGM. While empowering local leaders to champion the cause and promote alternative rites of passage that respect cultural traditions without harming girls and women.
  6. Healthcare Support and Counselling Services: Government along with other state actors must ensure the provision of adequate access to healthcare services, including counselling and medical treatment, for survivors of FGM. Establish specialized clinics and support centres equipped to provide medical and psychological care to survivors. These services should be sensitive to cultural norms and provide support without stigmatizing survivors.
  7. Data Collection and Research: State and non-State actors involved in FGM campaigns must invest in comprehensive data collection and research to understand the prevalence and root causes of FGM in different regions of Nigeria. This information is essential for developing targeted interventions and evaluating the effectiveness of existing strategies.
  8. International Collaboration: all relevant agencies including government and non-governmental organizations must collaborate with international organizations, such as the United Nations and World Health Organization, to leverage resources and expertise in the fight against FGM. Participate in regional and global initiatives aimed at ending FGM and share best practices with other countries facing similar challenges.

 

CONCLUSION

While it seems that there are proper legislations put in place to prosecute cases of FGM in Nigeria, it still remains a wonder that there are no judicial precedents available to show that a competent court of law in Nigeria has tried a case of FGM. With this being the case, there is little or no doubt that perpetrators of these inhuman acts will continue unabated. There is therefore a need for the swift prosecution of FGM cases by Law enforcement agencies in other to serve as a deterrence to others against future commission. There is also, an urgent need for government both in the State and Federal level to set up supervisory committees, to ensure that proper implementation and revised standards are put in place to tackle the menace of FGM in the country. This will go to show that the country has moved past lip service in its war to end FGM.

 


NOTE: The section on legal Briefs is a forum for frank and open scholarly notes by research staff and guest contributors. Views expressed in these notes are personal to the authors and are not to be attributed to the Centre.

DO YOU WANT TO SHARE YOUR VIEWS ON OUR BLOG?

JURITRUST Centre for Socio Legal Research and Documentation invites submission of short articles from VOLUNTEER CONTRIBUTORS who are interested in sharing their perspectives on salient issues in the administration and development of the Nigerian Criminal Justice System, comparative systems and related issues. CLICK HERE find out how to send us your articles. Thank you

Research papers on gender and corruption

In each article, the goal is to illustrate potential paths for reformers to take in each policy area: legislative proposals, policy campaigns, monitoring, reporting, and a shift from gender-sensitive program design to gender-transitioned program design.

 

 

 

CREDIT; Transparency International