A Review on the US Foreign Extortion Prevention Act 2023: Its effects on the Anti-Corruption War in Nigeria by Queenetta Bassey, Esq.

A Review on the US Foreign Extortion Prevention Act 2023: Its effects on the Anti-Corruption War in Nigeria by Queenetta Bassey, Esq.

Abstract:

This review examines the US Foreign Extortion Prevention Act (FEPA) Act 2023 and its potential impact on the anti-corruption war in Nigeria. The FEPA Act aims to combat corruption and promote transparency in international business transactions. This review analyses the key provisions of the act, its relevance to Nigeria, and the potential implications for the country’s anti-corruption efforts. Additionally, it explores the importance of international cooperation in the fight against corruption and highlights the role of the Nigerian government in enforcing anti-corruption measures. The review concludes by emphasizing the need for a strong political will, robust institutions, and a functioning judiciary to effectively combat corruption in Nigeria.

 

  1. Introduction:

Corruption has long been a pervasive issue in Nigeria, hindering economic growth, undermining public trust, and impeding development. The US Foreign Extortion Prevention Act (FEPA) Act 2023 presents a significant opportunity to strengthen the on-going anti-corruption war in Nigeria. This review critically examines the provisions of the FEPA Act, its relevance to Nigeria, and the potential impact on the country’s anti-corruption efforts.

 

  1. Overview of the FEPA Act 2023:

The FEPA Act criminalizes foreign corruption, prohibiting foreign individuals and entities from engaging in corrupt practices to gain an unfair advantage in international business dealings. The FEPA Act also establishes stringent reporting requirements for companies operating in the United States. It mandates that companies must implement robust anti-corruption compliance programs and report any suspected violations to the US Department of Justice. This provision is crucial as it encourages multinational corporations operating in the country to adopt stricter anti-corruption measures.

 

Furthermore the FEPA Act empowers the US government to impose severe penalties on individuals and companies found guilty of foreign corruption. Unlike previous US anti-corruption laws that only criminalize and punish corrupt US officials who are involved in corrupt practices, the FEPA Act provides further deterrence by punishing foreign persons who offer bribes and are involved in other corrupt practices with US officials, these penalties include hefty fines, imprisonment, and even exclusion from participating in US government contracts. Such stringent measures serve as a deterrent to corrupt practices by foreign persons.

 

  1. Relevance to Nigeria’s Anti-Corruption War:

Nigeria has made significant efforts to combat corruption, including the enactment of legislations such as the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) Act 2004 and the Corrupt Practices and Other Related Offences Act 2000. The FEPA Act complements these existing legislations by providing an additional legal framework to address foreign corruption and promote transparency in international business transactions. It encourages multinational corporations operating in Nigeria to adopt stricter anti-corruption measures, thereby enhancing the effectiveness of Nigeria’s anti-corruption efforts.

 

  1. Implications for Nigeria:

The FEPA Act empowers the US government to impose severe penalties on individuals and companies found guilty of foreign corruption, including hefty fines, imprisonment, and exclusion from US government contracts. These penalties serve as a deterrent to corrupt practices and can significantly impact the anti-corruption war in Nigeria. The Act also fosters international cooperation by requiring the US government to collaborate with foreign governments, including Nigeria, in investigating and prosecuting cases of foreign corruption. This provision opens up avenues for knowledge sharing, capacity building, and joint efforts in combating corruption.

 

  1. Enforcing Anti-Corruption Measures in Nigeria:

While the FEPA Act presents an opportunity for Nigeria to strengthen its anti-corruption war, its effectiveness depends on the commitment and willingness of the Nigerian government to enforce anti-corruption measures. These include building strong institutions, enhancing the capacity of anti-corruption agencies, and ensuring an independent and functioning judiciary. The Nigerian government must demonstrate a strong political will to combat corruption and create an enabling environment for the effective co- implementation of the FEPA Act.

 

  1. Conclusion:

The US FEPA Act 2023 offers significant aid for the anti-corruption war in Nigeria. By criminalizing foreign corruption, imposing stringent reporting requirements, and encouraging international cooperation, this Act has the potential to enhance Nigeria’s anti-corruption efforts. However, its true impact will depend on the Nigerian government’s commitment to enforcing anti-corruption measures, building robust institutions, and ensuring a functioning judiciary.

 

The impact of the FEPA Act on the anti-corruption war in Nigeria is likely to be substantial, as it sends a clear message that corrupt practices will no longer be tolerated, regardless of the jurisdiction in which they occur. Effective execution of this Act will serve as a wake-up call for Nigerian officials and businesses, urging them to adopt more transparent and ethical practices in all their international business dealings.

 

 

 


 

NOTE: The section on legal Briefs is a forum for frank and open scholarly notes by research staff and guest contributors. Views expressed in these notes are personal to the authors and are not to be attributed to the Centre.

DO YOU WANT TO SHARE YOUR VIEWS ON OUR BLOG?

JURITRUST Centre for Socio Legal Research and Documentation invites submission of short articles from VOLUNTEER CONTRIBUTORS who are interested in sharing their perspectives on salient issues in the administration and development of the Nigerian Criminal Justice System, comparative systems and related issues. CLICK HERE find out how to send us your articles. Thank you

EU court rules gender-based violence ground for asylum

EU court rules gender-based violence ground for asylum

The European Court of Justice has ruled that women, as a whole, can be regarded as belonging to a social group and thus entitled to asylum if subjected to domestic or sexual violence. NGOs have welcomed the decision.

The Luxemburg-based European Court of Justice (ECJ) ruled that women who suffer or are at risk of “physical or mental violence, including sexual violence and domestic violence” on account of their gender in their country of origin could apply for protection and be granted refugee status.

The original case in the ECJ concerned a Turkish Muslim national of Kurdish origin. She claimed that her family had forced her into marriage, and she had been threatened and beaten by her husband, from whom she is now divorced.

She escaped to Bulgaria after leaving him and said that her life would be at risk if she returned to Turkey. That is why she applied for international protection in Bulgaria, which turned to the ECJ for a ruling on what is essentially a case concerning a potential so-called “honor killing.”

 

‘Women are a social group’

The ECJ stated on Tuesday that refugee status was “to be granted in cases where a third-country national is persecuted for reasons of race, religion, nationality, political opinion or membership a particular social group.”

It then ruled that “women, as a whole, may be regarded as belonging to a social group,” and that refugee status could be granted if certain conditions applied. “This will be the case where, in their country of origin, they are exposed, on account of their gender, to physical or mental violence, including sexual violence and domestic violence.”

The court added that if the conditions for granting refugee status were not satisfied, women “may qualify for subsidiary protection status, in particular where they run a real risk of being killed or subjected to violence,” all the more so if there was a risk of this being “inflicted by a member of their family or community due to the alleged transgression of cultural, religious or traditional norms.”

 

‘Important ruling for protection of women from domestic and sexual violence’

Terry Reintke, a German MEP and co-president of the Greens group in the European Parliament, told DW that it was a “very important ruling for the protection of women from domestic and sexual violence.” She said it made clear that the EU also had to protect women without EU passports from domestic violence in their countries of origin.

Polish MEP Robert Biedron, who chairs the women’s rights and gender equality committee in the European Parliament, said it was an “important step towards promoting an inclusive and compassionate approach to asylum policy.”

Germany’s largest pro-immigration advocacy group, Pro Asyl, and the German non-profit organization Terre des Femmes also welcomed the ruling. Karl Kopp, the head of Pro Asyl’s European department, said it would strengthen women’s legal position. Stephanie Walter from Terre des Femmes said it would improve the chances of women who are victims of domestic violence.

But Walter said she doubted that the ruling would make a major difference to German practice. She told DW that many cases in German courts had already been decided according to the standards set out by the ECJ ruling and pointed out that the “crux of the matter” lay elsewhere. She said that for women to be able to apply for asylum and make their case, a specific framework was needed, such as safe accommodation and access to specialist consultation centers.

She explained that women were often unaware when first asked to give their reasons for escaping their home country by authorities that genital mutilation, forced marriage and domestic violence were considered to be acceptable grounds.

 

Significance of the Istanbul Convention

Kopp said it was important to see how the ruling was implemented in the different member states of the EU but that, fundamentally, its effect would be positive.

He said if it were properly implemented, it could be assumed more women would receive protection in the future and that the “achievements of the Istanbul Convention” would once again be “fully reflected in the asylum procedure.”

The European treaty, which the EU ratified in June 2023, aims to prevent violence and protect victims and binds its signatories to a series of measures to this effect.

Though all EU states have signed it, it has yet to be ratified by Bulgaria, Czechia, Hungary, Lithuania and Slovakia.

EU parliamentarian Reintke said that, in her view, the ECJ ruling was only made possible by the EU’s accession to the Istanbul Convention, which was mentioned explicitly by the court. She called on those EU member states that had not yet ratified the convention to do so.

Polish MEP Biedron said the EU’s accession to the Istanbul Convention was “a symbol of the EU’s willingness to eliminate violence against women.”

 

CREDIT: DW.com

ICC MATERIALS

International Criminal Court CORE TEXTS

 

 

Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court (Statute)

The international treaty establishing the International Criminal Court is the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court. It sets out the administrative framework for the court and consists of a preamble and 13 parts. This law was adopted by the Rome Conference on July 17, 1998 and entered into force on July 1, 2002, thereby establishing the International Criminal Court.

Download

 

 

 

 

Rules of Procedure and Evidence (Rules)T

They are subordinate to statutes and regulate the composition and operation of courts.

Download

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Elements of Crimes

The Elements of Crimes were developed to assist the Court in interpreting and applying the crimes outlined in articles 6-8bis of the Statute. These elements establish the necessary conditions for someone to be held criminally responsible and liable for punishment. They cover jurisdiction, material aspects, and the mental state required for each crime.

Download

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Regulations of the Court

The Court Regulations outline the court’s structure, administration, proceedings, legal assistance, victim participation, detention, cooperation, enforcement, removal, and disciplinary measures.

Downloads

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Regulations of the Office of the Prosecutor

 

The Regulations of the Office of the Prosecutor, like the Registry’s Regulations, are governed by the Statute, Rules, and Court Regulations, governing its management, administration, handling of information, and investigations.

Download 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Regulations of the Registry

The Registry’s Regulations, governed by the Statute, Rules, and Court Regulations, outline its organization and management, administrative duties, legal representation, assistance, victim and witness matters, and detention matters, subject to the Statute, Rules, and Court Regulations.

Download 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Code of Professional Conduct for counsel

The Code of Professional Conduct for counsel, adopted by the Assembly of States Parties, governs the conduct of counsel in their representation of clients, relations with the Court, other counsel, unrepresented individuals, and victims and witnesses, and establishes a disciplinary regime for misconduct.

Download 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Code of Conduct for the Office of the Prosecutor

Download 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

UNCAC 10th Session of the Conference of State Parties Bolsters Universal Action on Whistleblower Protection.

UNCAC 10th Session of the Conference of State Parties Bolsters Universal Action on Whistleblower Protection.

By Prof. Deji Adekunle, SAN

Research Lead

Juritrust Centre for Socio Legal Research and Documentation

 

One of the main outcomes of the 10th Session of the Conference of State Parties of the UN Convention Against Corruption is a Resolution CAC/COSP/2023/Rev.1 calling for increased protection of reporting persons (whistle blowers) and their relatives. Whistle blower protection, what it means and how to go about it in a legal system present daunting challenges especially in legal traditions steeped in official secrecy, confidentiality and employee fidelity.  Despite derogations in these hallowed concepts in favour of exposure of illegality or crime, drawing the line in many cases can be problematic. For example should whistle blowers be protected from retaliation or should they be rewarded or incentivised; what difference does it make if the whistle blower is an accessory or conspirator who fell out with his colleagues or perhaps acted in reaction to his being cheated in the distribution of the loot? Should good faith or motives matter or is it just a question of results.

 

Whistle-blowing is the disclosure of information about perceived wrongdoing in an organisation, or the risk thereof, to individuals or entities believed to be able to effect action. Such wrongdoing could be a violation of a law or regulation, a miscarriage of justice, gross waste of public funds or gross mismanagement. It could be deployed as an early warning tool to avert possible risks by necessary corrective action or as a valuable clue to the unravelling of complex and secretive crimes like corrupt enrichment. Nigerian law has not really kept pace with the UNCAC provisions particularly Article 33 which requires that States parties consider incorporating into their domestic legal systems appropriate measures to provide protection against any unjustified treatment for any person who reports in good faith and on reasonable grounds to the competent authorities any facts concerning an offence of corruption. Some of the salient aspects of the Resolution are examined next

 

Blowing the Whistle or Reporting a wrong

The term “whistle blower” is avoided by the Resolution instead it employs the word that in the ordinary sense captures what whistle blowing or whistle blower entail and that is simply reporting a wrong. All through the Resolution the verb “report”, and the noun “reporter” are preferred by the Resolution. The term “reporter” however is not used in the same sense as a news reporter Many see nothing wrong with the term “whistle blower” but in climes like Nigeria where reporting wrongs has become the exception rather than the norm the suggestion of affinity between a whistle blower and a meddlesome snitch should best be avoided. To blow the whistle on corruption is simply to report wrongdoing and while employees or insiders in an organisation are more vulnerable to retaliatory measures there is nothing in the term that restricts it to insiders exclusively.

 

Protection of Reporter and Relatives Against Unjustified Treatment

In urging states to continue to have regard to the application of Article 33 and to continue to develop appropriate measures to fully and effectively provide protection against unjustified treatment for all persons (and their relatives) who, on reasonable grounds, expose or report corruption and related offences to competent authorities the COSP has clarified that protection is not merely against civil or criminal proceedings but against unfairness or injustice. There are many ways in which a reporter can suffer injustice without necessarily being proceeded against in civil or criminal trial. Punitive postings, exclusion from privileges or perquisites, denial of promotion or benefits, withdrawing or limiting the reporters job schedule to the point of redundancy are examples of administrative injustices that can be meted on the whistle blower. Nigeria clearly needs to improve on the current legislative framework for the protection of whistle blowers.

 

Whistleblower Protection For Public officers under the Freedom of Information Act 2011

The existing framework is quite inadequate as it is primarily concerned with limited protection in favour of public officers who disclose information pursuant to the Freedom of information Act (FOIA) or protection against criminal proceedings where information is with a view to exposing corruption. (section 27 FOIA). The FOIA however does not outline a procedure or channel for disclosure of information neither does it prescribe redress or consequences where the whistle-blower is victimised or subjected to unjust treatment. Despite the resolution of some of these cases in favour of the whistle blower, the lack of a formal mechanism for redress was the source of delay and hardship.

 

The COSP Resolution touches on the importance of institutional mechanisms for the safe reporting of wrongs and an equally safe and effective redress mechanism. It urges state parties to increase public awareness of means for reporting instances of corruption, including by disseminating information regarding the rights and responsibilities of reporting persons in accordance with domestic legislation. States are also enjoined to establish and strengthen confidential complaint systems and protected internal reporting systems that are accessible, diversified and inclusive to facilitate timely reporting of corruption and to ensure the confidentiality of the reporting persons’ identities and personal information, including, where appropriate, allowing for anonymous reporting, and utilize innovative and digital technology in these efforts, with due regard for data protection and privacy rights.

One of the greatest fears of informers or reporters is the possibility that the those who are charged to uphold the law will not only reveal their identities to suspects but the informer may quite strangely become the suspect in a bizarre display of impunity. It is of course possible as happens in some cases that the informer is also an accomplice. However this does not make evidence or intelligence from such sources valueless; on the contrary it is this kind of evidence that has sent many kingpins of fraud, extortion or racketeering ring to jail. Safe secure and confidential channels of communication are therefore important prerequisites for a Whistle blower Protection Law.

 

The Whistle-blower Policy

Some of these conditions are captured in the Whistle-blower policy developed in 2016 by the Federal Government through the Ministry of Finance. The policy outlines a 2.5% – 5% reward band incentive for a person who discloses information bordering on violation of financial regulations, mismanagement of public funds and assets, financial malpractice or fraud and theft that is deemed to be in the interest of the public that directly leads to the voluntary return of stolen or concealed public funds or assets. The the major underpinnings of this policy are that:

    • The actual recovery must also be on account of the information provided by the whistle blower;
    • Information must be provided through anyone of three secure channels that guarantees anonymity – the portal, via email, telephone.
    • Any Stakeholder who whistle blows in public-spirit and in good faith will be protected, regardless of whether or not the issue raised is upheld against any Party.
    • Where reasonable grounds exist from which it can be inferred that an informer has been victimized, the onus is on the Party against whom the complaint of adverse treatment has been made to show that the actions complained of were not taken in retaliation for the disclosure.
    • Where a prima facie case established that a Whistle blower has suffered adverse treatment (harassment, intimidation or victimization) for sharing his\her concerns with the Ministry, a further investigation may be instituted and disciplinary action may be taken against the perpetrator in accordance with the public service rules/other extant rules and a restitution shall be made to the Whistle blower for any loss suffered.

 

This policy when read together with the opaque and inchoate provisions of section 27 of the FOIA, offers prospects for a progressive leap forward in the institutionalisation of whistle blower protection mechanisms in the public sector. Little has however been heard of it in recent times; the portal itself is suspect as it may have been hacked and labelled “unsafe.” Besides it is an inadequate basis for a legally binding obligation. Had the policy been sustained it would at least have led to the development of institutional capacity in the public sector and the design of effective procedures pending when these are eventually enacted as law.

 

 


NOTE: The section on legal Briefs is a forum for frank and open scholarly notes by research staff and guest contributors. Views expressed in these notes are personal to the authors and are not to be attributed to the Centre.

DO YOU WANT TO SHARE YOUR VIEWS ON OUR BLOG?

JURITRUST Centre for Socio Legal Research and Documentation invites submission of short articles from VOLUNTEER CONTRIBUTORS who are interested in sharing their perspectives on salient issues in the administration and development of the Nigerian Criminal Justice System, comparative systems and related issues. CLICK HERE find out how to send us your articles. Thank you

Legal Analysis of the P&ID Judgment: The Good, the Bad and the Ugly

Legal Analysis of the P&ID Judgment: The Good, the Bad and the Ugly

By Dr. Gbenga Oduntan,

Associate Professor of International Commercial law

University of Kent, Canterbury UK

 

On the 23rd of October, the international legal community and the Nigerian public received the news of the delivery of the judgement in the celebrated case before the Hon Mr Justice Robin Knowles, CBE between: The Federal Republic of Nigeria (Claimant) and Process & Industrial Developments Limited (P&ID) (Defendant). This case will, no doubt, in time come to stand as locus classicus on many significant points of law especially because of its relevance to international arbitration, commercial agreements, contract law, government procurements, corruption in arbitration and dispute settlement, anticorruption law and transparency in international business transactions among others. The P & ID case is a caution tale for every developing country, particularly Nigeria, on their multispectral vulnerability in the field of international business transaction, international trade, dispute resolution mechanisms, particularly arbitration and mediation. It is also a significant wake up call for all professionals and government departments that work on long term contracts, foreign investments, oil and gas transactions and international financial institutions. The case also exposed, the underbelly of the highly closed world of arbitration and alternative dispute resolution. It is also clear that there are also lessons for developed States and their courts and tribunals, about their imperfections and exposures in international commercial law and relations.

 

Background of the Case

The background of this highly interesting case, rests on a complex commercial arrangement that dates to the first decade of this century. There was a near catastrophic Award of $7 billion against Nigeria and of course, a challenge under Section 68 of the English Arbitration Act 1996. It is perhaps, important to recap some of the issues underlying the dispute. 

The underlying contract was based on a “Gas Supply and Processing Agreement for Accelerated Gas Development” (“the GSPA”) signed on 11 January, 2010 between two parties. In the event Nigeria did almost nothing to perform the GSPA after signing it, but, as Nigeria strenuously pointed out, neither did the other party. Yet, after a long drawn out high profile arbitration, the arbitral tribunal decided in 2017, that Nigeria owed P & ID US$6.6 billion. This sum is so vast, that it is material to Nigeria’s entire federal budget. With interest at the rate awarded by the Tribunal, the amount as at judgement day, if it had gone against Nigeria, would exceed US$11 billion (Paragraph 4).

Despite huge mineral resources, especially in the hydrocarbon sector, Nigeria notoriously has a huge problem of energy insecurity. The country has for a long time, been seeking innovative means to address this challenge. Under the GSPA, Nigeria was to supply specified quantities of “wet” gas to Gas Processing Facilities (GPFs) constructed by P & ID. P & ID was to strip the wet gas into “lean” gas, to be delivered to Nigeria to be used for power generation. The remaining natural gas liquids were to be retained by P & ID for onward sale, either domestically or by export. The stated duration of the GSPA was 20 years (or more, under one scenario). It is common ground that, in the event Nigeria did not in fact supply any wet gas to P & ID, and nor did P & ID construct any Gas Processing Facilities (Paragraph 8).

Needless to say, the contract as a commercial conceptual arrangement is exactly the kind of thing that Nigeria needs to further kickstart its development, especially in the very ambitious era of the new century when the country’s economy was raging and the governments of the period were bullish and audacious in their plans. It will perhaps, never be found out precisely why nothing moved on this arrangement, but red flags were abound.

An English court in 2020 ([2020] EWHC 2379 (Comm) Case No: CL-2019-0007), noted that the company as at the time it won the contract had “no assets, only a handful of employees, and was without a website or other presence”. The contract was given to P & ID without competitive tender, and this was despite several existing contractual disputes between other companies belonging to the very same directors and other Nigerian government departments.

It is fair to say that the required robust due diligence Nigeria ought to have done before entering this contract, was perhaps, only done eight years later in June 2018 when former President Buhari directed that Ministries should make available all relevant documentation and hand them over to the country’s Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC), so it could investigate the contract given to P & ID. Nigeria’s National Intelligence Agency was then involved, to investigate P & ID. The Nigeria Police and Federal Inland Revenue Service, eventually opened separate investigations into P & ID. 

Criminal proceedings then commenced against P & ID, and other principal actors. P & ID in Nigeria, thereafter, pleaded guilty to conspiracy to defraud Nigeria, money laundering, tax evasion and trading without authorisation.

 

The Major Grounds of Contention

In its challenge (of the arbitral award), Nigeria made allegations of bribery, corruption and perjury in several respects. The allegations extend to the GSPA, but they then extend further across the arbitral process from the Arbitration Agreement to Final Award. The allegations by Nigeria include allegations of bribery and corruption by P&ID before, at and after the time the parties entered into the GSPA. Nigeria alleged that some of its own Lawyers at the time of the arbitration, including two Leading Counsel, were corrupted by P & ID. The allegations extended, even to the early stages of the challenge before the Court. In turn, for its part, P & ID expressly refuted Nigeria’s main arguments, and described Nigeria’s case against it as “false and dishonest” (Paragraphs 12, 471).

 

A Cacophony of Illegal Actors Within Nigeria

It may be predicted that one of the enduring usefulness of this case is that it forced into the bright sunlight of national and international scrutiny the massive problem of corruption in Nigeria. The facts and unsavoury practices unearthed during the case and contained in the judgment indict for all to see named individuals and institutions. Without passing any particular judgment on guilt because that is not what the judgment itself did or even sought to do there is a balance of probability that shameful conducts and improper behaviour abound in Nigerian officialdom over the decades and perhaps till present.

The list is rich, and there can only be space and time to highlight a few. The facts revealed included previous deals the court considered indicative of a corrupt operation of Mr Michael Quinn and Mr Brendan Cahill, the businessmen operating as P & ID. For instance, multiple sets of murky transactions were highlighted at Nigeria’s Ministry of Police Affairs, Ministry of Defence, Nigerian National Petroleum Corporation (NNPC), among others.

(Whereby) An erstwhile Minister of Police Affairs, around 2003 and 2007 received several high sums of payments in Pounds Sterling ostensibly for medical treatment in a London Clinic, of which the Honourable Judge concluded as suspicious and indicative of money-laundering, and which probably explains the background of a 2007 contract for the supply of ammunition and bulletproof vests signed by a company and the Ministry of Police Affairs to a stated value of US$3,173,354.08. Other contracts laying the tone for the corruption that led to he debacle Nigeria found itself, date back to a Ministry of Defence contract in May 2002. This was for a contract for the refurbishment of 36 Scorpion tanks (the Scorpion Contract). Following a set of dodgy payments between highly placed workers in the Ministry of Defence, facts establishing grounds for a finding of grand-corruption were exposed.

 

The Temple of Arbitration on Trial

As the Honourable Judge correctly wrote “… this is a highly unusual case, although one that draws attention to matters of wider importance. Quite apart from the consequences for the parties, the matter touches the reputation of arbitration as a dispute resolution process”. At the arbitration stage, several clearly terrible things happened to provide the fertile and fortunate ground for challenge. There are allegations, and some were persuasive to the Court, showing a pattern of bribery of Nigerian officials.

The facts traversed throughout the long judgement, do establish serious grounds of impropriety on the part of Mr Shasore, SAN, Nigeria’s Leading Counsel at the Arbitration. These include 2019 admissions by Mr Shasore, SAN to the EFCC that he made personal gifts of US$100,000 each to a certain Ms Adelore (former Director of Legal Services at the Ministry of Petroleum Resources) and Mr Ikechukwu Oguine, General Counsel, Coordinator of Legal Services and Secretary to the NNPC. On 13 September, 2019, Mr Oguine equally gave a statement in which he said that he received US$100,000 from Mr Shasore, SAN.

Yet, the Court did not accept all these allegations easily as is true of every robust judgement, such as the one delivered by Mr Justice Robin Knowles. A testimony by Mr Tijani alleging that the Directors of P & ID bribed him with US$50,000 in a “black bag” in April 2009, while he attended a dinner with Mr Michael Quinn and Mr Hitchcock at the “Chopsticks” Restaurant in Abuja and was given a US$50,000 cash ‘gift’ was disputed by P & ID. The Judge was not prepared to rely on it, and he stated, “I am concerned, it cannot be tested satisfactorily.” In relation to a “statement of facts and documents concerning bribery” prepared by Nigeria, where it was alleged that a payment of US$300,000 by Mr Shasore, SAN to Mr Ukiri was a corrupt payment in return for which Mr Ukiri (who did not do any work on the P & ID case) “acted as one of Mr Shasore’s conduits in leaking [Nigeria’s Internal Legal Documents]” (Paragraph 444), the Judge concluded “[t]here is not the evidence before me at this trial, to substantiate this”.

Aside from that, the facts betray a very untidy system of legal instruction in the country. There were attempts to withdraw instruction, addition of co-Counsel, and disappearance of same for inexplicable reasons. Nigeria’s defence strategy as revealed in the judgement, was essentially chaotic in the main. In other words, Nigeria so obviously betrayed an undisciplined system of prosecuting even the most important trials and cases such as this, even though failure will certainly be catastrophic. Could this be why the country has been losing previous high-profile cases? Notably in July 2022, Nigeria unfortunately lost the UK Judgement in FRN v JP Morgan case, which arguably jeopardised international anticorruption works. More specifically, the case may have negatively impacted ongoing and future prosecutions relating to the notorious Oil Prospecting License 245 scandal, some of the indicted characters such as Mohammed Bello Adoke, SAN, a former Attorney-General of the Federation, who also turned up in the P & ID  case too. The 2022 London judgement brought sheer disappointment to anticorruption campaigners, both in Nigeria and abroad, and that experience contrasts very much with the P & ID case, where Nigeria clearly dodged a very dangerous bullet.

 

Murky World of Legal Services in the UK

The judgement revealed that even UK based providers of legal services are not beyond descent into the murky waters of greed and corruption, in the conduct of their services. For instance, Mr Andrew and Mr Burke KC allowed Nigeria’s internal legal documents that were privileged, to enter into the hands of the P & ID, despite knowing that P & ID was not entitled to see these documents. The Judge noted that “Their decision not to put a stop to it, at least, by informing Nigeria or immediately returning the documents they knew were received, was indefensible” (Paragraph 215). The damning conclusion reached by the Judge was that, “The reason Mr Andrew and Mr Burke KC behaved in this way, was because of the money they hoped to make”. There is the suggestion that Mr Andrew may have had a claim for up to £3 billion in the event of P & ID’s success, while Burke may have had a claim for up to £850 million, he said. It is worthy of note that, this is not the first time British Lawyers have been found seriously wanting in their rendering of legal services against Nigeria’s interests, in commercial transactions and during international proceedings. British Lawyer, Bhadresh Gohil received a conviction in 2010 over 13 counts of money laundering and other offences linked to his role helping James Ibori, a former Governor of Delta State from 1999 to 2007, to disguise illicit funds from criminal activities. The fines of around £28 million (around $36 million) was however, forfeited to the British State representing a further loss to Nigeria. It is fast becoming irrefutable that Britain remains a global money-laundering hub for foreign kleptocrats, who rely on a small but damaging crop of professional enablers that make the world of bribery, money laundering and illicit financial flows go round, and against the interests of developing States like Nigeria. This is an area worthy of closer, dedicated and specialist studies from within both countries, and collaboratively too.

Several heads will, of course, roll internationally, because of this judgement. Mr Justice Robin Knowles literally went to town in lambasting certain individuals within the UK’s jurisdiction, who were ‘driven by greed and prepared to use corruption; giving no thought to what their enrichment would mean in terms of harm for others. 

The judgement has been formally referred to the Solicitors Regulation Authority and Bar Standards Board, in relation to the conduct of Solicitor, Seamus Andrew and Barrister, Trevor Burke KC. This is principally in relation to the handling of documents, which came into P & ID’s hands during the arbitration proceedings. As the Judge noted: ‘I trust that these two regulators of the legal profession in England & Wales will consider the professional consequences of the conduct of Mr Burke KC and Mr Andrew, in relation to Nigeria’s internal legal documents’ (Paragraph 593).

 

Recommendations

After all said and done, Nigeria has allowed itself to be played through a national trauma. As stated in Margaret Moses, The Principles and Practice of International Commercial Arbitration (Cambridge CUP, 2017) Page 216 persuasively put it “[a] party that has lost before an arbitral tribunal faces an uphill battle, if it wishes to set aside or vacate the award. Courts rarely overturn an arbitral award. Arbitral awards are considered to be final and binding”. Grounds of a successful challenge to an International arbitral award of this nature, are quite narrow by design. A final and binding award is often the aim of the parties, and rationale of most ICA proceedings. (See UNCITRAL Arb. Rules Art 32 (2) ICC Rules Art 28(6)) See also Section 52 English Arbitration Act, for form of award whereby parties and arbitrators must assist each other to ensure that a valid award emanates from the tribunal that is capable of enforcement internationally. 

Nigeria cannot always count on this kind of near miraculous but quite deserved exemption, from a manifestly unjust award based on illegalities. Thus, the imperatives are clear. A phase of introspection and re-strategising for success, is needed. A quick but effective audit of Nigeria’s Bilateral and Multilateral Investment Treaty commitments, is urgently required. Just as the military engages in periodic exercises and simulations for the country’s defence, so also must the Ministry of Justice carry out dedicated simulations of the country’s commercial vulnerabilities, based on international commitments. Ditto the Ministry of External Affairs, and Ministry of Trade and Investment.

There ought to be an increased capacity shown by bodies like the National Intelligence Agency to reflect the huge sums Nigeria expends on them, by pulling their weight in sniffing out foreign ‘cowboy’ businesses and their dodgy characters like the ones featured in this case. If Nigeria is to emerge as a serious player in this century, it must develop effective means of vetting out unserious and downright criminal operations that are abound in the international system. This is more so, in those areas and sectors of key importance to Nigeria. Businessmen with foreign convictions ought to be at least vetted again before being allowed to venture into business in Nigeria, and only specialist bodies like the NIA and Nigerian Embassies and High Commissions can do this job effectively. 

If this 21st Century is to become Nigeria’s century of accelerated development, it literally cannot be business as usual in terms of how the country interfaces with multinational corporations. Nigeria cannot afford to be a soft touch for crafty tax dodgers, bribe givers and part time crooks. More importantly, internal grand corruption will kill the country if the country does not kill it. The judgement by the Hon. Mr Justice Robin Knowles, is a treasure trove of legal hit list of shady characters of Nigerian civil servants to be investigated by multiple security agencies and brought to book. The judgement is also a good blueprint. to study the anatomy of business and official corruption in Nigeria. The 140 pages of the judgement has detailed the shady and dysfunctional institutions within Nigeria, that have made the country vulnerable to outside predators helping to generate illicit financial flows away from Nigeria. These institutions must be followed up, and indeed, ought to be mandated immediately by the new President H.E Bola Ahmed Tinubu to conduct internal reassessments, considering the revelations and implications of the judgement. 

The international community, including other unsavoury characters, will be watching carefully to see whether Nigeria realises the true importance of what it just went through and will be drawing the correct lessons. Complacency on this type of issues, is not really an option. It is bad for business, and worse for the commercial and economic destiny of the nation. This judgement literally gave Nigeria, a new lease of life. To whom much is given, much is expected.

This piece by Dr Oduntan is the first of a 3-part analysis of the impact of the judgment in  FRN vs Process & Industrial Developments ltd [2019] EWHC 2241 (Comm) Page 13, which struck down an earlier arbitral award against Nigeria as one which was fraudulently procured. The article was first published online by THISDAYLIVE https://www.thisdaylive.com/index.php/2023/10/31/p-id-a-conspiracy-against-nigeria

 


 

NOTE: The section on legal Briefs is a forum for frank and open scholarly notes by research staff and guest contributors. Views expressed in these notes are personal to the authors and are not to be attributed to the Centre.

DO YOU WANT TO SHARE YOUR VIEWS ON OUR BLOG?

JURITRUST Centre for Socio Legal Research and Documentation invites submission of short articles from VOLUNTEER CONTRIBUTORS who are interested in sharing their perspectives on salient issues in the administration and development of the Nigerian Criminal Justice System, comparative systems and related issues. CLICK HERE find out how to send us your articles. Thank you