Former character commission officer admits taking bribes, indicts chairman

Former character commission officer admits taking bribes, indicts chairman

There was mild drama on Monday when a former Integrated Payroll and Personnel Information System desk officer at the Federal Character Commission, Haruna Kolo, accused of collecting bribes from job seekers in exchange for employment, owned up to the allegation.

This was just as he admitted to having received over N75m from desperate jobseekers on the instructions of the Chairman of the FCC.

Not done, Kolo claimed that the FCC boss instructed him to transfer the money to his (Kolo) personal account and pay her in cash which he did a couple of times in her house.

Kolo made the revelation at the ongoing investigative hearing by the House of Representatives ad hoc committee investigating federal ministries, departments and agencies, parastatals and tertiary institutions on mismanagement of the IPPIS.

The ex-IPPIS desk officer told the lawmakers that he resigned from FCC on November 2, 2022 to join the Asset Management Corporation of Nigeria but ended up getting salaries twice from FCC.

He added that the anomaly was reported to the Human Resource Officer who told him that the issue would be addressed.

He said, “When she came to FCC as the Executive Chairman, she appointed me as a protocol officer and I carried out my duty diligently.

“On the allegations of job racketeering, the FCC Chairman instructed me to liaise with one Mr Shehu, who is a personal driver and Personal Assistant to the Taraba State Commissioner. As a desk officer, I was responsible to take whoever was employed to IPPIS for capturing. No one could go there without a letter from the Chairman or Human Resource Officer of the FCC.

“When she came, she wrote a letter to the Accountant General of the Federation, instructing that no letter from the FCC should be honoured except she signs the letter. So, whenever there was new employment, she signs, gives to me and I take it to the Accountant General’s office for capturing.

“Shehu is the one that brought those who paid money to my account for job, some paid N1m, others N1.5m, all to my personal account, my Ecobank account. She asked me to give cash to her, which I did through POS. So, there is no evidence of transfer or anything.

“On the allegation of working at seven places, I was never at any time involved in seven jobs. They are making the allegation based on assumption.”

He continued, “The second allegation on my subsequent employment at AMCON was a result of her personal favour to me. We were four in number, and she gave the appointment letter to me, Kadijah, and Olushola. We all proceeded for an interview at AMCON headquarters in Abuja after which we were called upon for training on the 16th January 2023,

“After the training,  Olushola and I were called to Lagos. Unfortunately, Kadijah, who is the chairman’s biological sister, was rejected. The Chairman accused me of being responsible for her rejection.

“I see no reason why (sic) the chairperson would make allegations of such magnitude against me. I have been threatened even at gunpoint and had to leave Abuja.

“Sir, I want this committee to know that after this sitting if anything happens to me,  the FCC chairperson should be held responsible, ” Kolo added. Responding, the chairman of the committee, Yusuf Gagdi, promised to do every possible to unravel the truth and make the same available to Nigerians.

“This committee will not sit down and watch taxpayers’ money being embezzled.

“I know why we were asking Kolo to give us evidence and we know why we were deferring this sitting for other witnesses alleged to have had financial dealings with the FCC.

“Kolo will appear here tomorrow (Tuesday). We are calling the other witnesses. We will allow you to do your work. Whoever is found wanting will answer his father’s name, including Kolo Haruna,” he said.

The committee adjourned sitting till Tuesday (today).

 

 

https://www.instagram.com/p/CvrN7vhqzjV/?igshid=NjFhOGMzYTE3ZQ%3D%3D

Source: Punch

 

 

HUMAN RIGHTS ISSUES RELATING TO CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION AND TRIALS: A NIGERIAN PERSPECTIVE By Chioma Henrietta Okoli

HUMAN RIGHTS ISSUES RELATING TO CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION AND TRIALS: A NIGERIAN PERSPECTIVE By Chioma Henrietta Okoli

Introduction:

Nigeria, the most populous country in Africa, is a constitutional democracy with a diverse population and complex legal system. The country has made significant strides in promoting human rights, as evidenced by the ratification of various international human rights treaties. Nigeria, as a democratic nation, places significant importance on upholding human rights within its constitution and legal framework. The criminal investigation and trial processes play a critical role in protecting these rights and ensuring justice for all citizens. However, the criminal investigation and trial processes in Nigeria face numerous human rights challenges, impacting the fairness and effectiveness of the justice system.

This paper examines the key human rights issues within the Nigerian criminal justice system, analyzes their implications, and proposes potential solutions to strengthen human rights protection and ensure fair and just criminal proceedings.

 

The Right to a Fair Trial:

The right to a fair trial is a cornerstone of the criminal justice system and is protected under section 36 of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1999 (as amended); the Administration of Criminal Justice Act, 2015 and other relevant Nigerian laws. It is also protected under regional and international human rights instruments such as the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights; the Universal Declaration on Human Rights; and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. However, several factors impede the realization of this right in practice.

 

 Prolonged Pre-Trial Detention:

One of the major human rights challenges in Nigeria is the excessive use of pre-trial detention. Many individuals, particularly those from marginalized communities, experience prolonged detention without trial, violating their right to liberty and the presumption of innocence. The Nigerian criminal justice system often faces delays in processing cases, leading to overburdened courts and backlogs.

To address this issue, the Nigerian government should invest in alternatives to pre-trial detention, such as bail reform and diversion programs. Implementing legal reforms to streamline the judicial process and provide timely trials can help reduce the backlog of cases and alleviate pre-trial detention pressures.

 

  Access to Legal Representation:

The right to legal representation is a crucial aspect of a fair trial. However, many accused individuals, especially in rural areas, face difficulties in securing competent legal counsel, leading to an imbalance within the adversarial system.

To address this issue, Nigeria must enhance legal aid services to ensure that all citizens, regardless of their financial status, have access to qualified legal representation. Awareness campaigns can be conducted to inform citizens of their right to legal representation and the avenues available to access legal aid.

 

Trial Delays and Backlogs:

Trial delays are a common issue in the Nigerian criminal justice system, affecting both victims and accused individuals. Lengthy trials can undermine the right to a speedy trial, impacting the lives of those involved and impeding justice.

To tackle trial delays, the Nigerian government should invest in modernizing court infrastructure and adopting case management systems. Additionally, the judiciary should employ case management techniques to ensure the timely resolution of cases. Adequate training and resources for judges and judicial staff are essential to expedite proceedings.

 

Police Misconduct and Brutality:

Instances of police misconduct and brutality have been a significant concern in Nigeria. The excessive use of force during arrests and interrogations, arbitrary arrests, and torture have been reported, particularly in vulnerable communities. These actions not only violate the right to life and liberty but also erode public trust in law enforcement and the criminal justice system.

 

Excessive Use of Force:

The use of excessive force by law enforcement is a recurring problem in Nigeria. Often, confrontations between security forces and civilians result in unnecessary violence, leading to injuries and loss of life.

To address this issue, Nigeria should establish robust mechanisms for independent oversight and accountability. Independent bodies responsible for investigating allegations of police misconduct should be empowered and adequately resourced. Moreover, comprehensive training on human rights and the use of force should be mandatory for all law enforcement personnel.

 

Torture and Extrajudicial Killings:

Torture and extrajudicial killings are grave human rights violations that have been reported in Nigeria. Victims of torture often suffer physical and psychological trauma, and extrajudicial killings deny individuals their right to life and due process.

To combat torture and extrajudicial killings, Nigeria must prioritize the investigation and prosecution of security personnel involved in such acts. Establishing specialized units within the police force and judicial system to handle cases of police misconduct can enhance accountability and deter future abuses.

 

Lack of Accountability:

The lack of accountability for police misconduct and brutality remains a significant barrier to justice in Nigeria. Cases involving security personnel often face challenges in the prosecution and conviction of the perpetrators.

To promote accountability, Nigeria should ensure that investigations are transparent and impartial. Independent bodies, such as civilian oversight commissions, should be tasked with overseeing investigations and holding law enforcement personnel accountable for their actions.

 

Right to Privacy and Surveillance:

Advancements in technology have expanded the capabilities of criminal investigations in Nigeria, but they have also raised concerns about violations of the right to privacy. The use of surveillance technologies, such as mass data collection and electronic monitoring, may infringe upon individual privacy rights.

 

Mass Data Collection:

Mass data collection by government agencies and private entities can compromise individual privacy rights in Nigeria. The extensive gathering and storage of personal data without proper safeguards can lead to abuse and unauthorized access.

To safeguard privacy rights, Nigeria needs to enact comprehensive legislation to regulate the use of surveillance technologies. Legal frameworks must be established to ensure that surveillance practices are subject to judicial oversight, strict adherence to proportionality tests, and respect for individual rights. Additionally, independent bodies, such as data protection agencies, should be tasked with overseeing and enforcing data protection laws.

 

 Electronic Monitoring and Phone Tapping:

The use of electronic monitoring and phone tapping by law enforcement agencies has raised concerns about the violation of privacy in Nigeria. Surveillance without proper authorization and oversight can lead to unwarranted intrusions into the lives of individuals.

To prevent abuses, Nigeria must establish clear legal procedures for obtaining and using electronic surveillance evidence in criminal investigations. Judicial warrants should be required for surveillance, and access to such evidence should be restricted to authorized personnel.

 

Safeguarding Privacy Rights:

Nigeria must prioritize the safeguarding of privacy rights in the digital age. Public awareness campaigns can be instrumental in educating citizens about their rights and raising awareness about potential privacy violations. Additionally, the Nigerian government should collaborate with international organizations and privacy experts to develop best practices for data protection and surveillance.

 

Impartiality and Independence in Investigations:

The impartiality and independence of criminal investigations are vital to ensuring fair and just criminal proceedings in Nigeria. However, challenges related to political interference and inadequate resources can undermine the integrity of investigations.

 

 Political Interference:

Political interference in criminal investigations remains a significant concern in Nigeria. The influence of politicians and powerful individuals on law enforcement agencies and prosecutorial bodies can compromise the objectivity of investigations.

To bolster impartiality and independence, Nigeria should strengthen the role of independent prosecutorial bodies, such as the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) and the Independent Corrupt Practices and Other Related Offenses Commission (ICPC). These bodies should be insulated from political influence, and their leadership should be appointed through transparent and merit-based processes.

 

Independent Prosecutorial Bodies:

The effectiveness of independent prosecutorial bodies in Nigeria depends on their autonomy and capacity. Adequate resources should be allocated to these bodies to ensure effective and efficient investigations. Moreover, coordination and collaboration between different law enforcement agencies and prosecutorial bodies are crucial to avoid conflicts of interest and promote comprehensive investigations.

 

Adequate Resources for Investigations:

Nigeria should invest in the capacity-building of law enforcement agencies and investigators to ensure that they have the necessary resources and training to conduct thorough and impartial investigations. The recruitment and training of specialized investigators can enhance the quality and effectiveness of criminal investigations.

 

 Juvenile Justice:

The treatment of juveniles within the criminal justice system remains a pressing human rights issue in Nigeria. Despite legal protections for children, many young offenders find themselves subjected to the same punitive measures as adult criminals.

 

Detention of Juveniles:

Detention of juveniles should be a measure of last resort, according to international human rights standards. However, overcrowded juvenile detention centers and a lack of rehabilitation programs continue to be challenges in Nigeria.

To promote juvenile justice, Nigeria should prioritize diversion programs and restorative justice practices to keep young offenders out of the formal criminal justice system. Specialized courts and detention centers that cater to the needs of juveniles should be established, focusing on rehabilitation and reintegration rather than punishment.

 

 Lack of Rehabilitation Programs:

Rehabilitation programs for juvenile offenders are essential in breaking the cycle of criminal behavior and reintegrating them into society. Nigeria should invest in education, vocational training, and counseling programs for juvenile offenders to facilitate their successful reintegration into the community.

 

Diversion and Restorative Justice:

Diversion programs that divert young offenders away from the formal criminal justice system can be effective in promoting juvenile justice. Restorative justice practices, which involve dialogue and reconciliation between offenders and victims, can also contribute to reducing recidivism among juvenile offenders.

 

Discrimination and Disparities:

Discrimination based on ethnicity, religion, and socioeconomic status remains a persistent challenge in Nigeria’s criminal justice system. Racial profiling and targeting of certain communities by law enforcement agencies raise concerns about systemic bias and disparate treatment.

 

 Ethnic and Religious Bias:

Ethnic and religious biases can influence police conduct, investigations, and trial outcomes in Nigeria. Prejudices based on ethnicity and religion can lead to targeted arrests and unfair treatment of certain groups.

To address these disparities, Nigeria must invest in cultural competency training for law enforcement personnel. Data collection and analysis should be used to identify disparities and inform evidence-based policy changes to eliminate systemic bias.

 

Socioeconomic Disparities:

Socioeconomic disparities can also impact access to justice and the treatment of individuals within the criminal justice system. Individuals from lower socioeconomic backgrounds may face challenges in accessing legal representation and obtaining a fair trial.

To mitigate socioeconomic disparities, Nigeria should invest in legal aid services to ensure that all citizens, regardless of their financial status, have access to competent legal representation. Awareness campaigns can also be conducted to inform citizens of their rights and the avenues available to access legal aid.

 

 Addressing Systemic Bias:

Addressing systemic bias in Nigeria’s criminal justice system requires comprehensive reforms and a commitment to promoting equality before the law. The Nigerian government should engage with civil society organizations and international partners to identify and address areas of systemic bias within the justice system.

 

Challenges in the Criminal Justice System:

In addition to specific human rights issues, Nigeria’s criminal justice system faces broader challenges that impact human rights protection and the rule of law.

 

Overcrowded Prisons:

Overcrowded prisons are a persistent problem in Nigeria, leading to unsanitary conditions, human rights abuses, and increased risk of disease outbreaks.

To address this issue, Nigeria should explore alternatives to incarceration, such as community service and probation, for non-violent offenders. Investing in prison infrastructure and enhancing rehabilitation programs can also alleviate prison overcrowding. 

 

Corruption in the Justice System:

Corruption within the criminal justice system undermines the integrity of investigations and trials, eroding public trust in the rule of law.

To combat corruption, Nigeria must prioritize the enforcement of anti-corruption laws and establish independent oversight bodies to investigate and prosecute corrupt practices within the justice system. Strengthening internal accountability mechanisms within law enforcement agencies can also deter corrupt behaviour.

 

Inadequate Training for Criminal Justice Personnel:

The effectiveness of Nigeria’s criminal justice system depends on the competence and professionalism of its personnel. Inadequate training can impede the quality of investigations, trials, and victim support.

To address this challenge, Nigeria should invest in continuous training programs for law enforcement officers, prosecutors, and judicial staff. Training should focus on human rights principles, legal procedures, and best practices for handling criminal cases.

 

Strengthening Human Rights Protections:

To ensure fair and just criminal proceedings and protect human rights, Nigeria should adopt a holistic approach that encompasses legal reforms, awareness campaigns, and collaboration with civil society and international organizations.

 

Legal Reforms and Policy Changes:

Nigeria should undertake comprehensive legal reforms to address the human rights issues identified in this paper. Reform efforts should prioritize protecting the right to a fair trial, curbing police misconduct and brutality, safeguarding privacy rights, and promoting impartiality and independence in investigations.

 

Awareness and Sensitization Programs:

Public awareness campaigns are essential in educating citizens about their rights and raising awareness about potential human rights violations. Government agencies, civil society organizations, and the media can collaborate on educational programs aimed at promoting human rights within the criminal justice system.

 

Collaboration with Civil Society and International Organizations:

Collaboration with civil society organizations and international partners can enhance Nigeria’s efforts in protecting human rights within its criminal justice system. Civil society organizations can serve as watchdogs, advocating for human rights, and providing support to victims. International organizations can offer technical assistance, expertise, and financial support for human rights initiatives.

 

Conclusion:

Protecting human rights within criminal investigations and trials is crucial to upholding the rule of law and ensuring justice for all citizens in Nigeria. The right to a fair trial, addressing police misconduct and brutality, safeguarding privacy rights, promoting impartiality in investigations, ensuring juvenile justice, eliminating discrimination and disparities, and overcoming broader challenges within the criminal justice system are essential steps toward creating a fair, just, and human rights-respecting criminal justice system in Nigeria.

By prioritizing legal reforms, awareness campaigns, and collaboration with civil society and international partners, Nigeria can strengthen human rights protections and enhance public trust in its criminal justice system. A comprehensive and multifaceted approach is essential to promoting justice, fairness, and respect for human rights within Nigeria’s criminal investigations and trials.

 

About the author

Chioma Henrietta Okoli is a Senior Legal Officer at National Human Rights Commission, Nigeria where she promotes and protects human rights policies. She is also currently enrolled as a PG student at the Centre for Human Rights, University of Pretoria, South Africa.

 

DO YOU WANT TO SHARE YOUR VIEWS ON OUR BLOG?

JURITRUST Centre for Socio Legal Research and Documentation invites submission of short articles from VOLUNTEER CONTRIBUTORS who are interested in sharing their perspectives on salient issues in the administration and development of the Nigerian Criminal Justice System, comparative systems and related issues. CLICK HERE find out how to send us your articles. Thank you

 

 

MACARTHUR FOUNDATION ON NIGERIA BI-ANNUAL COHORT MEETING HOLDS IN ABUJA

 

 

 

More than 85 organisations – grantees of the MacArthur Foundation On Nigeria initiative converged on the 27th of July at the Exclusive Serene Hotel, Wuye, Abuja for this year’s Biannual Cohort Meeting to exchange notes and share with Foundation staff results and outcomes of their work. The meeting was preceded on the 26th of July by a training workshop on Communications Strategy for Media and communications officers of grantees.

Also this year Grantees were encouraged to exhibit their outputs such as publications, audio visual works and cultural artworks. Juritrust Centre for Socio legal Research and Documentation showcased two recent publications – Vol One of ACJA learning Tools – The Workbook On ACJA For Investigators And Prosecutors (a training manual for facilitators and Participants) and The Compendium of Law Notes Vol,1

Workbook for investigators and Prosecutors

Compendium of law Notes

The meeting which was hybrid in nature commenced about 10:00 am with welcome and introductions by Dr. Kole Shettima, Africa Director. More introductory remarks were made by Kenneth Jones, Senior Vice President & Chief Operating Officer/Chief Equity Officer. During the first session, each of the On Nigeria cohorts  shared project results, anticipated legacy, and contributions to the On Nigeria strategy with Foundation staff. The Cohorts – Behavioral Change, Criminal Justice, Joinbodi and Media and Journalism made presentations on work done so far, highlighting achievements, challenges, legacies and gaps yet unfilled. The presenters for each Cohort were pre-selected. PWAN and CLEEN Foundation represented the Criminal Justice Cohort at the presentation session.

The second session kicked off with Josh Mintz, Vice President Legal, who elaborated via zoom, the legal requirements and obligations of the Foundation which impact the guidelines to grantees on financial reporting, use of foreign exchange gain, and re-granting. His Presentation was followed by that of Phillis Hill who gave more insights into the approval process for re-purposing grants.

Stephanie Platz, Managing Director, On Nigeria Program gave the closing remarks, appreciated the great work done by grantees and looked forward to the October Grantees conference.

Visitors at the exhibition stands

Visitors at the Juritrust Centre Stand

At the Juritrust Centre Stand

 

BAIL AND TERRORISM CHARGES – WHAT IS THE LAW? by LUQMAN HASSAN, Esq

Introduction
Bail is a concept of liberty in criminal justice administration. It follows the constitutional presumption of innocence enshrined under section 36 (5) of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1999 as amended. Bail is basic, common place and do not require scholarly definition. However, in order to drive home the point, it is important to allude to the pronouncement of the Court of Appeal in the case of Ojo v. F.R.N. (2006) 9 NWLR (Pt. 984) 103, where it was stated that:

Bail is the freeing or setting at liberty one arrested or imprisoned, upon others becoming sureties by recognizance for his appearance at a day and place certainly assigned, he also entering into self-recognizance. The accused/convict is delivered into the hands of sureties, and is accounted by law to be in their custody, though they may free themselves from further responsibility if they surrender him to the court before the date assigned. (Pg 115, paras. E-F)
Bail is mainly of two types- bail pending trial and bail pending appeal. The two types of bail have been aptly described by the court as follows: “In bail pending trial, a court of trial, pursuant to provisions made by the enabling law or other statutes which create the offence(s) charged, may admit to bail any person to be tried before it, while he is awaiting trial or during his trial. In bail pending appeal, the convict who has lodged an appeal may be admitted to bail pending the determination of the appeal. The circumstances for bail vary in both situations. This is largely due to the fact that before conviction there is a presumption of innocence. After conviction, the convict, save under exceptional circumstances, has no right at all to bail.” (see Ojo v. F.R.N. (supra) Pp. 115-116, paras. F-A)

Bail and Judicial discretion
It is imperative to state that bail pending trial is mostly as of right which is often granted at the discretion of the Court; the discretion must be exercised judicially and judiciously. There are three circumstances under which the Court may consider bail pending trial. These are adequately captured by sections 161, 162 and 163 of the Administration of Criminal Justice Act (ACJA), 2015. The first circumstance is provided under Section 161 of the ACJA and it deals with bail when the defendant is charged with an offence punishable with death. In this case, bail will only be granted under exceptional circumstances which include ill health, extraordinary delay in investigation or prosecution or any other circumstances the judge may consider exceptional (see sections 161 (1) and (2) of the ACJA).
Another circumstance for granting bail pending trial is where the offence is punishable with imprisonment for a term exceeding three years. This is provided under Section 162 of the ACJA. Here, the defendant will be released on bail as of right except where there is evidence that the defendant if released on bail will:
a. commit another offence;
b. attempt to evade trial;
c. attempt to interfere with witness or investigation;
d. attempt to conceal or destroy evidence;
e. prejudice proper investigation; or
f. undermine or jeopardize the objective of criminal justice administration.

From the foregoing, it is clear that the duty is on the prosecution to show that the defendant will do any of the above before the court will deny bail; otherwise, the court will grant bail the moment it is satisfied that the defendant has shown reasons to be granted bail. In Ibrahim v. F.R.N (2017) 15 NWLR (Pt. 1589) 499, Okoronkwo, J. C. A. clearly explained this position when he held as follows:
Section 162 of the Criminal Justice Administration Act did not merely codify principles relating to bail as learned counsel for the respondent argued in 4.08 and 4.09 of his brief. The section i.e. 162 ACJA properly placed the burden of proof where it customarily should be – on the prosecution. (See page 516 paras F – G)
Further to the above stated two sections of the ACJA, Section 163 also states: “In any other circumstances other than those referred to in section 161 and 162 of this Act, the defendant shall be entitled to bail, unless the court sees reasons to the contrary”. This simply implies that where the offence is not punishable with death and does not attract terms of imprisonment exceeding three years, the court would ordinarily grant bail. The conditions for bail under this provision, although discretionary, are mostly simple and very liberal.

Bail Pending Appeal
Bail pending appeal is governed by the Court of Appeal Act, the Supreme Court Act, Court of Appeal Rules, 2021 and the Supreme Court Rules. For instance, section 28(1) of the Court of Appeal Act provides: “The Court of Appeal may if it thinks fit on the application of an appellant admit the appellant to bail pending the determination of the appeal”.
The clear text of the section shows that the constitutional right to bail is lost at the moment of conviction. The Court of Appeal can only grant bail where the applicant applies and the Court “thinks fit”. Therefore, the appellant must show exceptional circumstances which will entitle him to bail. Those circumstances are not exhaustive but have been alluded to in many judicial pronouncements. For instance, it was held in George v. F.R.N. (2010) 11 NWLR (Pt. 1206) 531:
The Court of Appeal will not as a rule grant bail to a prisoner pending the determination of his appeal unless there are exceptional and unusual reasons why bail ought to be granted to him. It is the duty of every applicant for bail to present the necessary materials before the court in support of his application to enable the court exercise its discretion in his favour. The exercise of the discretion must be judicial and judicious. (P. 555, paras. E-G)

Bail and Terrorism Charges
From the foregoing, it is clear that bail pending trial has a lot to do with the nature of the offence and its gravity will come to play in considering application for bail by the defendant at that stage. However, bail pending appeal does not necessarily consider the nature of the charge, although it may come to play in considering the exceptional or unusual circumstances to warrant bail or deny same.
Offences of terrorism in the last decade have become common in Nigeria with attendant threats to corporate existence and survival of the country. For a long time, what constitute offences of terrorism was not poignantly defined by Nigerian laws save sparring reference made to it by the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) Act. Nevertheless with the enactment of a law on Terrorism in 2011 the offences became codified in our laws. (Note that the 2011 Act was amended in 2013 and re-enacted in 2022)
Section 2(1) of the Terrorism (Prevention and Prohibition) Act, 2022 prohibits all acts of terrorism and terrorism financing while subsection (3) of the same section gives elaborate definition of what an act of terrorism means. Punishments for different categories of acts of terrorism ranging from death sentence to different terms of imprisonment including life imprisonment are well outlined under the Act. Offence of terrorism is one of the most serious and heinous crimes in Nigeria. This was alluded to by the Supreme Court in the case of Ogwuche v. F.R.N. [2021] 6 NWLR (Pt.1773) 545 – 547. The Apex Court stated in the case that:
The offence of terrorism which creates intense fear and anxiety both physically and psychologically in the minds of members of the public and which in most cases leads to the death of innocent persons should not be trivialized. It must be given the weight it deserves.
In view of the above, courts are usually circumspect when faced with bail application either pending trial or pending appeal in offences bordering on terrorism. This is not unconnected with the seriousness of the offences, the punishments attached to the offences and the national security consequence of the offences. In Dokubo-Asari v. F.R.N. (2007) 12 NWLR (Pt. 1048) 320; the Supreme Court stated it clearly that where national security is threatened, individual liberty is secondary. Taking a cue from the above, it is not surprising that the Courts are weary of granting bail in terrorism related cases. In fact, section 66 of the Terrorism (Prevention and Prohibition) Act, 2022 empowers the Court upon application ex parte to order detention of a suspect for terrorism related offences for 60 days pending investigation. The detention order is renewable for a similar period where there is a justification to so do. This provision, which is in pari materia with the provision of section 27 of the Terrorism (Prevention and Prohibition) Act, 2011 as amended has been held to be a valid derogation from right to personal liberty and it is not contrary to section 35 of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1999 as amended. In the case of Ogwuche v. F.R.N. [supra], the Supreme Court held that:
The provision in section 27(1) of the Terrorism(Prevention) (Amendment) Act 2013, which empowers the trial court to remand a person reasonably suspected of committing terrorist offences pending conclusion of prosecution or trial of the case is not contrary to section 35(4) of the1999 Constitution (as amended). Section 27(1) of the Terrorism (Prevention) (Amendment) Act, 2013 is empowered by section 35(7)(a) of the Constitution. (P. 560, paras. G-H)
In determining whether a defendant facing trial for offences of terrorism is entitled to bail as envisaged under section 35(4) of the Constitution, the Supreme Court stated clearly that the defendant is not entitled to bail especially where the punishment for the offence is death. In the words of the Supreme Court; “… by virtue of section 35(7)(a) of the Constitution, section 35(4) of the Constitution could not apply to the case of the appellant who was arrested and detained upon reasonable suspicion of having committed an act of terrorism, a(b)capital offence”. (Ogwuche v. F.R.N. [supra] P. 560, paras. A-G)
On bail pending appeal in terrorism cases, the Court of Appeal, towing the line of the Apex Court’s decisions held in ACHEM v. FRN (2014) LPELR-23202 (CA), that:
It should be mentioned that the applicant was convicted and sentenced for offences relating to terrorism, which in recent times have grown in intensity and magnitude and have become a threat to our national security. Courts should therefore be very circumspect in granting bail pending appeal to a person convicted for any offence relating thereto. See also Mohammed v. State (2015) 10 NWLR (pt. 1468) 496 at 512

Conclusion
The summation from the above decisions of both the Court of Appeal and Supreme Court is that despite the provision of right to bail in some circumstances, the right does not inure in a defendant charged with offences of terrorism. The seriousness of the offence and the punishments attached thereto take the right to bail away from the defendant either pending trial or subsequent to conviction. It is however important to emphasise that it is not within the powers of the state to detain indefinitely. Save as provided under section 66 of the Terrorism (Prevention and Prohibition) Act, 2022 which provides for remand protocol in terrorism cases and allows the detention of a suspect for 60 days, renewable for the same period, the state must present a suspect before a competent court of law for prosecution after the exhaustion of the remand period. The tendency of the security apparatus of state to abuse this window is rife. The Courts are therefore, called upon to stand as the bulwark against executive terrorism by granting bail where there are justifiable reasons to do so in line with their powers under section 6 and Chapter IV of the 1999 Constitution as amended notwithstanding the charge of terrorism.

DO YOU WANT TO CONTRIBUTE TO OUR BLOG?

JURITRUST Centre for Socio Legal Research and Documentation invites submission of short articles from VOLUNTEER CONTRIBUTORS who are interested in sharing their perspectives on salient issues in the administration and development of the Nigerian Criminal Justice System, comparative systems and related issues. Click here find out how to send us your articles. Thank you

South Africa: WHISTLE BLOWING – PPLAAF Develops Guidelines for Journalists

Whistleblowers play a crucial role in our anti-corruption toolkit, shedding light on wrongdoing that would otherwise go unnoticed and unreported. In the battle for transparency and accountability, the media serves as their powerful ally, amplifying their voices and bringing vital issues to the public’s attention. The bond between whistleblowers and the media is a symbiotic one, built on a foundation of trust. Both parties rely on each other to expose hidden truths, with journalists acting as responsible conduits for whistleblowers’ valuable information.Drawing on various engagements with the media and journalists with expertise in whistleblowing, PPLAAF has developed a useful guide for journalists dealing with whistleblower cases. Although developed for use in South Africa, the Guidelines are of relevance to whistleblowers in Nigeria too.

Pls click here to download the guide