by juritrustlaw | Jul 30, 2023 |

Introduction
Bail is a concept of liberty in criminal justice administration. It follows the constitutional presumption of innocence enshrined under section 36 (5) of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1999 as amended. Bail is basic, common place and do not require scholarly definition. However, in order to drive home the point, it is important to allude to the pronouncement of the Court of Appeal in the case of Ojo v. F.R.N. (2006) 9 NWLR (Pt. 984) 103, where it was stated that:
Bail is the freeing or setting at liberty one arrested or imprisoned, upon others becoming sureties by recognizance for his appearance at a day and place certainly assigned, he also entering into self-recognizance. The accused/convict is delivered into the hands of sureties, and is accounted by law to be in their custody, though they may free themselves from further responsibility if they surrender him to the court before the date assigned. (Pg 115, paras. E-F)
Bail is mainly of two types- bail pending trial and bail pending appeal. The two types of bail have been aptly described by the court as follows: “In bail pending trial, a court of trial, pursuant to provisions made by the enabling law or other statutes which create the offence(s) charged, may admit to bail any person to be tried before it, while he is awaiting trial or during his trial. In bail pending appeal, the convict who has lodged an appeal may be admitted to bail pending the determination of the appeal. The circumstances for bail vary in both situations. This is largely due to the fact that before conviction there is a presumption of innocence. After conviction, the convict, save under exceptional circumstances, has no right at all to bail.” (see Ojo v. F.R.N. (supra) Pp. 115-116, paras. F-A)
Bail and Judicial discretion
It is imperative to state that bail pending trial is mostly as of right which is often granted at the discretion of the Court; the discretion must be exercised judicially and judiciously. There are three circumstances under which the Court may consider bail pending trial. These are adequately captured by sections 161, 162 and 163 of the Administration of Criminal Justice Act (ACJA), 2015. The first circumstance is provided under Section 161 of the ACJA and it deals with bail when the defendant is charged with an offence punishable with death. In this case, bail will only be granted under exceptional circumstances which include ill health, extraordinary delay in investigation or prosecution or any other circumstances the judge may consider exceptional (see sections 161 (1) and (2) of the ACJA).
Another circumstance for granting bail pending trial is where the offence is punishable with imprisonment for a term exceeding three years. This is provided under Section 162 of the ACJA. Here, the defendant will be released on bail as of right except where there is evidence that the defendant if released on bail will:
a. commit another offence;
b. attempt to evade trial;
c. attempt to interfere with witness or investigation;
d. attempt to conceal or destroy evidence;
e. prejudice proper investigation; or
f. undermine or jeopardize the objective of criminal justice administration.
From the foregoing, it is clear that the duty is on the prosecution to show that the defendant will do any of the above before the court will deny bail; otherwise, the court will grant bail the moment it is satisfied that the defendant has shown reasons to be granted bail. In Ibrahim v. F.R.N (2017) 15 NWLR (Pt. 1589) 499, Okoronkwo, J. C. A. clearly explained this position when he held as follows:
Section 162 of the Criminal Justice Administration Act did not merely codify principles relating to bail as learned counsel for the respondent argued in 4.08 and 4.09 of his brief. The section i.e. 162 ACJA properly placed the burden of proof where it customarily should be – on the prosecution. (See page 516 paras F – G)
Further to the above stated two sections of the ACJA, Section 163 also states: “In any other circumstances other than those referred to in section 161 and 162 of this Act, the defendant shall be entitled to bail, unless the court sees reasons to the contrary”. This simply implies that where the offence is not punishable with death and does not attract terms of imprisonment exceeding three years, the court would ordinarily grant bail. The conditions for bail under this provision, although discretionary, are mostly simple and very liberal.
Bail Pending Appeal
Bail pending appeal is governed by the Court of Appeal Act, the Supreme Court Act, Court of Appeal Rules, 2021 and the Supreme Court Rules. For instance, section 28(1) of the Court of Appeal Act provides: “The Court of Appeal may if it thinks fit on the application of an appellant admit the appellant to bail pending the determination of the appeal”.
The clear text of the section shows that the constitutional right to bail is lost at the moment of conviction. The Court of Appeal can only grant bail where the applicant applies and the Court “thinks fit”. Therefore, the appellant must show exceptional circumstances which will entitle him to bail. Those circumstances are not exhaustive but have been alluded to in many judicial pronouncements. For instance, it was held in George v. F.R.N. (2010) 11 NWLR (Pt. 1206) 531:
The Court of Appeal will not as a rule grant bail to a prisoner pending the determination of his appeal unless there are exceptional and unusual reasons why bail ought to be granted to him. It is the duty of every applicant for bail to present the necessary materials before the court in support of his application to enable the court exercise its discretion in his favour. The exercise of the discretion must be judicial and judicious. (P. 555, paras. E-G)
Bail and Terrorism Charges
From the foregoing, it is clear that bail pending trial has a lot to do with the nature of the offence and its gravity will come to play in considering application for bail by the defendant at that stage. However, bail pending appeal does not necessarily consider the nature of the charge, although it may come to play in considering the exceptional or unusual circumstances to warrant bail or deny same.
Offences of terrorism in the last decade have become common in Nigeria with attendant threats to corporate existence and survival of the country. For a long time, what constitute offences of terrorism was not poignantly defined by Nigerian laws save sparring reference made to it by the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) Act. Nevertheless with the enactment of a law on Terrorism in 2011 the offences became codified in our laws. (Note that the 2011 Act was amended in 2013 and re-enacted in 2022)
Section 2(1) of the Terrorism (Prevention and Prohibition) Act, 2022 prohibits all acts of terrorism and terrorism financing while subsection (3) of the same section gives elaborate definition of what an act of terrorism means. Punishments for different categories of acts of terrorism ranging from death sentence to different terms of imprisonment including life imprisonment are well outlined under the Act. Offence of terrorism is one of the most serious and heinous crimes in Nigeria. This was alluded to by the Supreme Court in the case of Ogwuche v. F.R.N. [2021] 6 NWLR (Pt.1773) 545 – 547. The Apex Court stated in the case that:
The offence of terrorism which creates intense fear and anxiety both physically and psychologically in the minds of members of the public and which in most cases leads to the death of innocent persons should not be trivialized. It must be given the weight it deserves.
In view of the above, courts are usually circumspect when faced with bail application either pending trial or pending appeal in offences bordering on terrorism. This is not unconnected with the seriousness of the offences, the punishments attached to the offences and the national security consequence of the offences. In Dokubo-Asari v. F.R.N. (2007) 12 NWLR (Pt. 1048) 320; the Supreme Court stated it clearly that where national security is threatened, individual liberty is secondary. Taking a cue from the above, it is not surprising that the Courts are weary of granting bail in terrorism related cases. In fact, section 66 of the Terrorism (Prevention and Prohibition) Act, 2022 empowers the Court upon application ex parte to order detention of a suspect for terrorism related offences for 60 days pending investigation. The detention order is renewable for a similar period where there is a justification to so do. This provision, which is in pari materia with the provision of section 27 of the Terrorism (Prevention and Prohibition) Act, 2011 as amended has been held to be a valid derogation from right to personal liberty and it is not contrary to section 35 of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1999 as amended. In the case of Ogwuche v. F.R.N. [supra], the Supreme Court held that:
The provision in section 27(1) of the Terrorism(Prevention) (Amendment) Act 2013, which empowers the trial court to remand a person reasonably suspected of committing terrorist offences pending conclusion of prosecution or trial of the case is not contrary to section 35(4) of the1999 Constitution (as amended). Section 27(1) of the Terrorism (Prevention) (Amendment) Act, 2013 is empowered by section 35(7)(a) of the Constitution. (P. 560, paras. G-H)
In determining whether a defendant facing trial for offences of terrorism is entitled to bail as envisaged under section 35(4) of the Constitution, the Supreme Court stated clearly that the defendant is not entitled to bail especially where the punishment for the offence is death. In the words of the Supreme Court; “… by virtue of section 35(7)(a) of the Constitution, section 35(4) of the Constitution could not apply to the case of the appellant who was arrested and detained upon reasonable suspicion of having committed an act of terrorism, a(b)capital offence”. (Ogwuche v. F.R.N. [supra] P. 560, paras. A-G)
On bail pending appeal in terrorism cases, the Court of Appeal, towing the line of the Apex Court’s decisions held in ACHEM v. FRN (2014) LPELR-23202 (CA), that:
It should be mentioned that the applicant was convicted and sentenced for offences relating to terrorism, which in recent times have grown in intensity and magnitude and have become a threat to our national security. Courts should therefore be very circumspect in granting bail pending appeal to a person convicted for any offence relating thereto. See also Mohammed v. State (2015) 10 NWLR (pt. 1468) 496 at 512
Conclusion
The summation from the above decisions of both the Court of Appeal and Supreme Court is that despite the provision of right to bail in some circumstances, the right does not inure in a defendant charged with offences of terrorism. The seriousness of the offence and the punishments attached thereto take the right to bail away from the defendant either pending trial or subsequent to conviction. It is however important to emphasise that it is not within the powers of the state to detain indefinitely. Save as provided under section 66 of the Terrorism (Prevention and Prohibition) Act, 2022 which provides for remand protocol in terrorism cases and allows the detention of a suspect for 60 days, renewable for the same period, the state must present a suspect before a competent court of law for prosecution after the exhaustion of the remand period. The tendency of the security apparatus of state to abuse this window is rife. The Courts are therefore, called upon to stand as the bulwark against executive terrorism by granting bail where there are justifiable reasons to do so in line with their powers under section 6 and Chapter IV of the 1999 Constitution as amended notwithstanding the charge of terrorism.
DO YOU WANT TO CONTRIBUTE TO OUR BLOG?
JURITRUST Centre for Socio Legal Research and Documentation invites submission of short articles from VOLUNTEER CONTRIBUTORS who are interested in sharing their perspectives on salient issues in the administration and development of the Nigerian Criminal Justice System, comparative systems and related issues. Click here find out how to send us your articles. Thank you
by juritrustlaw | Jul 27, 2023 |
Ghana’s parliament has voted to abolish the death penalty. The move comes three decades after the last death sentence was carried out in the West African nation. Rights group Amnesty International has hailed the Tuesday vote, describing it as a “landmark decision,” and urged President Nana Akufo-Addo to sign it into law.
Under current law, the death penalty in Ghana can be imposed after convictions for genocide, piracy, smuggling, murder or high treason. Under the 1960 Criminal and Other Offences Act, the punishment can be carried out by hanging or by firing squad.
However, the West African country has not executed anyone in 30 years, and this week, parliament approved a bill to eliminate capital punishment completely.
Francis-Xavier Sosu, the opposition MP who sponsored the bill, tells VOA the development is a milestone for Ghana’s democracy and called on President Akufo-Addo to commute the sentence of those on death row now to life imprisonment.
“This is a very good news for Ghana because it adds to our democratic credentials and adds to our human rights record as a nation, particularly when since 1993 we haven’t been able to use the death penalty as a means of punishing offending persons and people who were condemned to serve death sentences were only kept in the condemned cells. So, I think it’s a win for Ghana,” he said.
Since 1977, Amnesty International has been campaigning for the global abolition of the death penalty. Reacting to news that Ghana’s parliament voted to abolish the practice, the international rights group issued a statement saying, “it is a victory for all those who have tirelessly campaigned to consign this cruel punishment to history and strengthen the protection of the right to life.”
However, not everyone in Ghana welcomes the lawmakers’ decision. Harry Agbanu, a religious lecturer at the University of Ghana, said the abolition of the capital punishment will be an incentive for people to take the law into their hands.
“The floodgate has been opened for violent, criminal activities by some members of society, and that is unfortunate. I’m praying that the opportunity is not being created for people to take the law into their own hands by engaging in mob action. There has not been any sound argument in favor of the abolishment of the death penalty,” he said.
For his part, Alexander Afenyo-Markin, a lawyer and a governing New Patriotic Party MP, said the decision is not meant to embolden criminals but rather to uphold more humane ways of dealing with criminals.
“This is not to say that those who have taken it upon themselves to take the lives of others are being encouraged to do so. God gives us life and under no circumstances should a person’s life be taken nearly [merely?] because of commission of such an offense. In its place we have introduced a life imprisonment,” he said.
The total number of people facing the death penalty in Ghana at the moment stands at 176, including six women, according to prison authority’s records.
President Akufo-Addo is expected to assent to the bill in the coming weeks, administration sources say. Ghana now joins a league of 29 out of 55 African countries that have abolished the death penalty.
Source: VOA
by juritrustlaw | Jul 27, 2023 |
The British billionaire owner of Premier League side Tottenham, Joe Lewis, was arrested on Wednesday ahead of a court appearance in New York on insider trading charges, US prosecutors said.
The 86-year-old Bahamas-based Lewis surrendered voluntarily after traveling to the United States to answer the charges, his lawyer told AFP in a statement.
Lewis is accused of furnishing employees and lovers with inside information for years in a “brazen” scheme that raked in millions of dollars.
The Attorney for the Southern District of New York, Damian Williams, announced on Tuesday that the Bahamas-based Lewis had been indicted along with two co-conspirators.
“The defendants were arrested this morning and will be presented later today,” Williams’s office said in a statement.
David Zornow, attorney for Lewis, said the US government had made “an egregious error in judgment” in charging his client.
“Mr Lewis has come to the US voluntarily to answer these ill-conceived charges, and we will defend him vigorously in court,” he added.
The prosecutors allege that for years Lewis “abused his access to corporate board rooms and repeatedly provided inside information to his romantic partners, his personal assistants, his private pilots and his friends.”
“Those folks then traded on that inside information and made millions of dollars in the stock market, because thanks to Lewis those bets were a sure thing,” Williams said.
The attorney alleges that Lewis passed on the inside information as a way of compensating employees or giving gifts to friends, describing the scheme as “classic corporate corruption.”
Lewis has been charged with 16 counts of securities fraud, the most serious of which carry a maximum sentence of 25 years in prison, and three conspiracy counts, which carry a maximum sentence of five years.
His two alleged co-conspirators, Patrick O’Connor, 66, and Bryan Waugh, 64, are two pilots employed by Lewis to fly his private aircraft, according to the prosecution.
Lewis is reported to be one of Britain’s richest men with a fortune worth an estimated $6 billion, building his reputation as a currency speculator in the 1980s and early 1990s.
Lewis’s holding company ENIC bought a controlling interest in Tottenham in 2001 from then-owner Alan Sugar, another prominent British tycoon.
Source : The Punch
by juritrustlaw | Jul 23, 2023 |

*… describes Court Order as unrealistic and unrealisable
Former governor of Delta State, Chief James Onanefe Ibori has vowed to appeal the latest United Kingdom (UK) forfeiture judgement against him saying that he was being persecuted by the British Judge.
The United Kingdom authorities had reportedly launched proceedings to seize more than £101.5 million from Ibori, who had pled guilty to money laundering charges and served a sentence.
Those knowledgeable about the case say that Ibori’s lawyers had advised him to plead guilty in possible exchange for a lesser sentence.
David Tomlinson, a judge at Southwark Crown Court said he has made “factual findings” about the funds and made a formal order on Friday to compel Ibori to refund a further £ 101.5 million.
Jonathan Kinnear, the senior prosecutor, told the court on Thursday that the total amount of money that should be confiscated from Ibori was £101.5 million.
The lawyer further informed the court that Ibori risks a fresh five to 10 years prison sentence should he fail to pay the money.
The judgement comes seven years after the former governor returned to Nigeria upon serving his time, has since maintained a low profile until his recent political resurgence following his old time friend, Asiwaju Bola Ahmed Tinubu’s emergence as President of Nigeria.
His political foes, especially in his home state, Delta, have been reportedly shaken by his reemergence on the political stage, and are alleged to have sponsored a rash of negative media commentaries about him.
Reacting to the latest UK order, Ibori said Judge Tomilson’s ruling was difficult to understand and even harder to accept having believed that justice and fairness would triumph, hearing after hearing, through the years.
He said since 2005 the British Prosecutors had investigated his assets worldwide, have had a restraint order in place on most of those assets and they are well aware that the total monetary value of those assets is nowhere close to the sums that were the subject of the recent Court Order.
This is notwithstanding the fact that many of the assets are not and have never been owned by him, he said and cried foul against the judgement.
Said Ibori: “Albert Einstein is quoted as saying that the “definition of madness is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting a different result”.
“If that is true then I must be going mad because in over a decade since the British Courts have been persecuting myself and those close to me, I kept believing that justice and fairness would eventually triumph.
“In hearing after hearing through the years, despite some of the most logic defying rulings against me- I still believed. Despite clear evidence of police corruption against the main officer in my case (evidence so strong that it caused the lead prosecutor to resign from my case), I still believed.
“Despite a clear victory in my 2013 confiscation hearing which left the Judge unable to make an order against me, only to have him rule that the prosecution should start the trial afresh some years later – I still believed.
“However, today’s ruling from Judge Tomlinson is difficult to comprehend and even harder to accept. I have to move past the fact that the British Courts found themselves competent to sit in Judgment over contracts awarded in Delta State; contracts that were legitimately awarded and completed. I have come to accept my fate despite the inability of the British prosecutors to show any evidence whatsoever of monies defrauded or indeed missing from Delta State.
“Since 2005, the British Prosecutors have investigated my assets worldwide; they have had a restraint order in place on most of those assets and they are well aware that the total monetary value of those assets is nowhere close to the sums that were the subject of today’s Order.
“Not withstanding the fact that many of the assets are not and have never been owned by me – it seems that if you are my friend and you allowed me to spend some holiday time in your house, then by this order I now own your home and must ask you to sell it to satisfy the Order.
“The Order made today was to be paid immediately, this was made in the full knowledge that it could take many months to actually realise the sale of many of these assets.
“There is an eight year default sentence, which means that if I do not co-operate and pay nothing at all, then the prosecution can apply for the imposition of the default sentence. However as the prosecution already has a Restraint Order over the assets – the situation of my not co-operating or paying should not arise.
“However, an issue arises if my Restrained Assets are sold, and the total realised from the sale does not equal the amount in the Order, then the Prosecution can still apply for part of the default sentence to be applied, but they could only ask for a sliding scale reduction of the eight years default sentence based on the amounts that remain outstanding.
“If such an application were to be made it would be vigorously contested. In the normal course of events, any talk of a default sentence would normally be stayed until any outstanding Appeal has been concluded.
“The Judge, in this case, has appeared to have cast aside any pretence of impartiality and has made an Order which is both wholly unrealistic and unrealisable. He has completely disregarded any arguments, evidence or expert witnesses in my favour. It was apparent during these last two days that he has forgotten many of the important elements of the case which is unsurprising as it almost 2 years since the case concluded.
“It has taken him two years to write this Judgment and in the interim he has presided over hundreds of cases, but I refuse to make excuses for him.
“At this point in time words fail me and so the question for me as I take my case to the Court of Appeal, is, if I continue to believe that I may finally get some Justice, is this the definition of madness?
“I know one thing for sure, that if I do not go to the Court of Appeal to contest this outrageous Order the people will definitely say that I am a madman!”
Source: Vanguard
Buy Cheap Fake Omega Watches For Free Shipping,you can konw aboult Omega Replica at Omega Awards.
Get information about replica Breitling watches from Breitling Replicas.
Bienvenue dans la boutique en ligne de répliques de montres de haute qualité, achetez les meilleures répliques de montres en FR.
by juritrustlaw | Jul 18, 2023 |

Every year the Nigerian Bar Association (NBA) holds an Annual General Conference (AGC) for lawyers across Nigeria. This gathering has the reputation of being the largest gathering of lawyers and judges in sub-Saharan Africa. At the 2022 NBA AGC Conference held in Lagos State, Duty Solicitors Network (DSN) in Partnership with the NBA (through the office of the 1st vice president), government and non-government legal aid service providers facilitated the 1st NBA AGC free legal Aid intervention initiative which involved about 20 volunteers from over 8 organizations providing pro bono legal services. These volunteers attended to over 120 people at the conference venue.

DSN Volunteers, Police and Correctional Officers
This year, between August 25 and September 1, the NBA-HRI will lead the intervention with other partners which includes; the Legal Aid Council of Nigeria, National Human Rights Commission, NAPTIP, AWLA, Juritrust Centre , British Council RoLac, DSN; just to mention a few
Our partners’ intervention will be to support the efforts of Legal Aid service providers by bringing volunteers from different organizations to serve the legal needs of indigent Nigerians who are expected in and around the NBA Conference venue. Lawyers will also be on ground to help mediate disputes and provide other basic legal services.

Mr Bayo Akinlade, Convener DSN
According to Mr Bayo Akinlade, Convener DSN, activities this year will also include a workshop to train lawyers in some aspects of the administration of criminal justice, visits to police detention facilities under the Police Duty Solicitors Scheme (PDSS) and a visit to Kuje Prisons
by juritrustlaw | Jul 18, 2023 |

The Rules of Professional Conduct 2007 states that lawyers who wish to carry on practice as a legal practitioner shall participate in and satisfy the requirements of the mandatory Continuing Professional Development (CPD) programmes organized by the Nigerian Bar Association. These programs include seminars, workshops and conferences for the purpose of furthering their legal knowledge.

Cross Section of Participants
Just as other professional bodies, the practice is dynamic and being that as the society progresses, the laws in place either become obsolete, supplemented, replaced or developed. Learning is a continuous exercise which demands all lawyers to hon their skills and develop themselves so that they will not become part of the menace associated in the legal system. A lawyer ought to be diligent and exhibit versatility, where these are lacking can be injurious to the legal profession. The packages of these programmes deal on all round solidification of the lawyer and his everyday practice.

Justice Ajileye delivers his lecture on Digital Evidence in Calabar
The Legal Defence and Assistance Project (LEDAP) is partnering with the Nigerian Bar Association to organize hybrid trainings for lawyers in diffrent branches of the NBA in Nigeria. It is a two-day training program held among the six geopolitical zones in Nigeria. The training modules focuses on core areas of the Administration of Criminal Justice which are:
- Fundamentals of Criminal Procedure in Nigeria
- Human Rights Law
- Economic and Financial Crimes in Nigeria
- Freedom of Information
- Restorative Justice System & Non-Custodial Sentencing
- Evidence Law
- Witness Management and Protection: SGBV, Children & Other Vulnerable Groups
- Law Practice Management and Advocacy Skills
According to Chino Obiagwu SAN, National Coordinator LEDAP the uniqueness of the programme is the forging together with a team of experts comprising retired Justices, Academics and senior lawyers to to produce lecture synopses and guides while also facilitating trainings in the selected NBA branches. Some of the organisations providing technical support to the programme are the Juritrust Centre for Socio-Legal Research & Documentation and the Centre for Socio-Legal Studies (CSLS). Both organisations are primarily involved in building capacity of legal practitioners and are grantees of the MacArthur foundations On Nigeria Criminal Justice Project.
The inaugural session of the programme was held last week in Calabar, Cross River State on 13 – 14 July with more than 60 participants. Before the kick-off LEDAP organized on 8 and 9 June in Lagos a 3 day team building an Curriculum Development meeting.