by juritrustlaw | Oct 29, 2023 |
The Nigerian Medical Association said it would adhere to the directive of the acting Inspector General of Police, Olukayode Egbetokun, to treat gunshot victims without asking for police report.
The NMA said prior to the directive, medical doctors in the country had always attended to emergency cases without demanding a police report.
Egbetokun had issued the directive while urging health workers to sensitise Nigerians about the issue.
The IGP’s directive, based on the Compulsory Treatment and Care for Victims of Gunshot Act, 2017, was contained in a Police internal memo dated October 25, 2023, and signed by the Force Principal Staff Officer, Olatunji Disu.
The memo was addressed to all Deputy Inspectors-General of Police, Assistant Inspectors-General of Police, Commissioners of Police and the Commandants of Police Colleges in Ikeja, Kaduna, Oji-River, Maiduguri and Enugu.
Speaking with our correspondent on Friday, the President of the NMA, Dr Uche Ojinmah said, “Prior to now, it has been that if it is an emergency, you treat the emergency if there is no report and then you report the case to the Police.
“I pray the IG can hold his policemen because it is always from them. You will come to say you admitted someone bleeding with a gunshot injury and the person is stabilised, but they will arrest you.
“The problem is not with the medical doctors, it is with the Police, as long as the Police will obey what the IG has said, I assure you that it will be a thing of the past.”
Credit: THE PUNCH
by juritrustlaw | Oct 28, 2023 |
Magistrates in Lagos State have been directed to stop granting remand orders to police to detain suspects in their cells.
The Deputy Chief Registrar, Legal, High Court of Lagos State, Joy Uggbomoiko, gave the directive in a circular dated October 18, 2023 and titled: “Re: Rejection of new inmates by correctional service.”
The circular indicated that the magistrates had earlier been given a directive to stop granting remand orders to the police to take suspects to prison, as the prison authorities, formally known as the Nigeria Correctional Service, had started rejecting inmates due to the congestion of their facilities.
Instead, the magistrates were encouraged to only grant remand orders for police to detain suspects in police station cells.
However, in the fresh circular, the DCR directed the magistrates to stop granting remand orders to the police altogether.
The DCR said the magistrates were only permitted to grant remand orders to the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission.
In the circular sighted by our correspondent, the DCR said, “I have been further directed to inform Your Honours to stop accepting overnight cases from any police station, formation or command except EFCC cases until directed otherwise.
“This overrides earlier directive that defendants be held in police custody. No magistrate shall order any police to detain a defendant at the station.”
A source told our correspondent that the circular was issued following a memo from the Chief Justice of Nigeria, in response to a complaint by the Nigeria Correctional Service stating that the prison were congested and they had started rejecting new inmates.
Credit: The Punch
by juritrustlaw | Oct 25, 2023 |
Today Nigeria prevailed in its monumental challenge to arbitral awards worth more than $11 billion that were obtained by a small offshore company following a failed gas project in Nigeria. The High Court ruled that Process & Industrial Developments Limited (P&ID) paid bribes when brokering the lucrative gas processing contract, and then “practised the most severe abuses of the arbitral process” in order to procure awards in their favour from a London tribunal.
Given the secrecy of arbitration – a way of privately resolving disputes outside the usual court process – these corrupt payments remained hidden until the High Court gave Nigeria the green light in 2020 to challenge the awards. A lengthy public trial earlier this year lifted the lid on an audacious conspiracy involving Nigerian officials, Irish businessmen and London lawyers who stood to receive eye-watering sums under the arbitral awards, which have grown by $1.3 million every day in interest. Today’s judgment pulls the plug on P&ID’s claim to enforce this $11 billion award against Nigeria, relieving the African nation of a bill equivalent to almost a third of its total annual budget for 2023 and over seven times its current health budget.
The court found that P&ID not only made corrupt payments to a key Nigerian official who helped broker the gas deal, but also colluded to cash out the profits through an arbitration that was compromised by false evidence and conflicted lawyers. Far from being a fair fight, the court found that continued concealment of the truth by dishonest witnesses and the improper conduct by lawyers acting for P&ID meant the arbitration was “a shell that got nowhere near the truth”.
Describing Nigeria’s challenge as “a stand-out example of a case where ‘justice calls out for’ correction”, the court has unravelled an elaborate conspiracy to use a London arbitration as the unwitting vehicle for defrauding the Nigerian people. This near-miss exposes the vulnerability of arbitration to fraud and the need for more robust safeguards in high-stake commercial disputes involving state parties.
The court also made damning findings against two English lawyers acting for P&ID in the arbitration whose conduct in retaining legally privileged Nigerian documents was described as “indefensible”. Following the court’s referral of its judgment to the relevant legal regulators, it is imperative that appropriate steps are taken to ensure any professional misconduct is robustly sanctioned. This extraordinary case should also be a wake-up call about the need for urgent reforms to ensure lawyers and other professional enablers are not enlisted as accomplices, unwitting or otherwise, to corrupt schemes that undermine the integrity of our financial and legal systems.
Dr Helen Taylor, senior legal researcher at Spotlight on Corruption, said:
“It is difficult to overstate the importance of today’s ruling for the Nigerian people, given the economic prospects of an entire country have been held hostage by a tainted arbitral award for a gas project that was built on bribes and lies. The prospect of a release from this $11 billion debt will come as a huge relief to Nigeria, while the court’s damning findings about the conduct of London-based lawyers will weigh heavily on those who care about the integrity of our legal system. There must be further scrutiny of the role played by these lawyers and proper accountability for any professional misconduct that may have compromised the London arbitration.”
Source: Spotlight on Corruption
by juritrustlaw | Oct 20, 2023 |

In a historic collaborative move, leading organizations dedicated to the defence of whistleblowers worldwide have united to submit an amicus curiae brief to the International Labor Organisation Administrative Tribunal (the Tribunal) in the landmark case of World Health Organisation (WHO) whistleblower Dr. Francesco Zambon. This joint effort by GlobaLeaks, Government Accountability Project, Transparency International, Transparency International Italy, Whistleblower Aid and the Whistleblowing International Network, reflects a strong collective commitment to advancing whistleblower protection and advocating for transparency and accountability within international organizations, particularly the United Nations.
Long before the emergence of this critical whistleblower case in 2020, these organizations have tirelessly championed whistleblower rights and shed light on the flaws and loopholes embedded in the United Nations’ whistleblower framework. The Tribunal has added this amicus brief to the case file and that is already a crucial step toward clarifying international principles and best practices related to whistleblowing.
Francesco Zambon, a former WHO scientist, made headlines in early 2020 when he coordinated a group of researchers who prepared a report on Italy’s pandemic preparedness. Italy was the first European country to be devastated by the COVID-19 emergency, and the report was meant to help inform the pandemic responsiveness of other countries. Initially published online by the WHO in May 2020, the report was hastily withdrawn 24 hours later. The report’s findings exposed a serious lapse in the Italian Ministry of Health’s pandemic plan which had been left untouched since 2006 despite a review being periodically required; and this plan having been the responsibility, among others, of a high-ranking WHO official during his tenure at the Italian Ministry of Health from 2013 to 2017. The result was a plan that was completely inadequate to support Italy to face the challenges of the outbreak of the coronavirus that occurred in 2020.
As a result, Zambon was pressured by the high-ranking WHO official implicated by the report to alter its findings – a move that would have jeopardized the WHO’s reputation, public health, and global policy-making by enabling the spread of disinformation. Zambon refused to obey this unethical order, which prompted the WHO to remove the report entirely from the public domain – thus tragically preventing its public service as an essential guide for future pandemic prevention, preparedness and response. Zambon’s unwavering commitment to scientific integrity and transparency prompted him to report what had happened internally. Zambon’s disclosures and retaliation complaint to the WHO were met with vagueness and significant delays, ultimately denying him recognition as a whistleblower and failing to provide him with any protection.
Transparency International’s paper Whistleblower Protection at the United Nations, further highlights the pervasive risk of retaliation United Nations workers face, a major deterrent to reporting misconduct. Fragmented and unclear whistleblowing policies, retaliation by staff, and a top-down culture within the United Nations threaten and undermine its whistleblowing system and exacerbate the challenges facing potential whistleblowers.
This collaborative effort represents a pivotal moment in our collective pursuit of justice, accountability, and transparency. Together we stand committed to safeguarding the values of honesty, integrity, and truth within international organizations, thereby securing a brighter and safer future for all.
Amicus Brief Summary and Background Information
Zambon’s case illustrates the flaws within the WHO and the United Nations common system regarding whistleblowing procedures and policies. The amicus brief advocates for the protection for whistleblowers who refuse to commit unethical or illegal acts, the freedom to choose their reporting channel, protection against retaliatory criminal and civil liability lawsuits, and immunity waivers, as important cornerstones of an effective policy. It argues that the WHO failed to adhere to its internal rules and procedures regarding whistleblower protection. The brief importantly highlights that suffering retaliation is not a necessary condition for someone to be considered a whistleblower while also pointing out that whether someone uses the designated channels cannot be a decisive criteria on whether they are a whistleblower – whistleblowers who have not yet decided to blow the whistle but are investigating reporting channels and how to use them safely also deserve protection. The amicus brief urges the WHO to apply international law principles to its handling of whistleblower employment disputes argues that the WHO’s whistleblowing policy falls short of international standards for whistleblower protection, and points out the lack of fairness and independence in the organization’s procedures for addressing whistleblower complaints is a critical factor.
Despite the chilling effect of an internal justice system repeatedly shown to be ineffective, Zambon is valiantly bringing his claim against the WHO to the ILO Tribunal where he is seeking recognition as a whistleblower and compensation for the suffering he endured. His perseverance offers hope for future scientists and ethical workers within the United Nations that they will receive the time, attention, protection, and fair procedures they rightfully deserve.
This case is significant, as its outcome will reverberate throughout the WHO and similar United Nations’ agencies, funds, and programs and influence the broader whistleblowing culture within the United Nations. The stakes are high given the United Nations’ mandate to tackle crucial global challenges ranging from climate change to public health, peacekeeping, relations between States, sustainable development, and the protection of human rights. Whistleblowers are the failsafe to ensure that United Nations’ agencies can effectively deliver on their mission.
The amicus’ aim is to support the Tribunal in its deliberations and the promoting organisations hope for a result that will encourage United Nations’ bodies to significantly improve their whistleblowing rules and practices, and in the long run to allow top scientists and all other workers within UN agencies, funds and programs to feel safe coming forward with any wrongdoing without fear of reprisals and knowing they will be heard. Scientific integrity should thrive without fear or favour and the importance of whistleblower frameworks is underscored by the WHO’s obligation to safeguard human rights, freedom of expression, freedom of information, and to ensure the protection of researchers’ independence and the public’s right to access to information.
Source: Whistleblowing International Network
by juritrustlaw | Oct 20, 2023 |
Short articles from VOLUNTEER CONTRIBUTORS interested in sharing their viewpoints on important issues in the administration and advancement of the Nigerian Criminal Justice System, comparative systems, and related issues are invited to be submitted to the JURITRUST Center for Socio Legal Research and Documentation.
The Center conducts research and monitors matters pertaining to government, development, and law. It produces a monthly newsletter with brief pieces that analyse anti-corruption and criminal justice issues in-depth.
Focus areas for submitted works should include arrest and pre-trial matters, trial and interlocutory matters, sentencing and ancillary orders, money laundering and corruption, electoral crimes, criminal justice reform, restorative justice, sexual and gender-based violence, human rights, and other criminal justice system-related issues with an eye towards understanding of how they relate to and address the prevailing gender equality, diversity elements and social inclusion gaps in our society.
It is expected of all volunteer contributors to:
- Compose and submit unique articles that have not been published elsewhere prior to submission to the editor;
- Not violate copyright or intellectual property rights.
- Refrain from copying and pasting other authors’ writing from other sources.
- Take a balanced stance while discussing any subject or problem.
- Refrain from making false accusations or disparaging any individual or group.
- Make sure the articles are timely, relevant, or reflect recent events and advancements in the socio-legal field.
- Grant JURITRUST Center, the right to publish the article(s) and to republish it on its website in any manner that it sees proper. NOTICE: The author retains the right to publish their work elsewhere, provided that they provide credit to the original publication.
- Not purport to speak for the Center or its opinions, unless hired to do so.
Please take note that articles must be submitted in the following formats:
- in clear, succinct English with Times New Roman font size 13 and 1.5 line spacing;
- with cited Laws and Acts hyperlinked
- without footnotes or endnotes
- with the author’s complete name, description, and email address included;
- are completely voluntary as JURITRUST Center neither pays nor receives remuneration for the work; and
- will only be published if reviewers provide a good report.
If you are interested in submitting an article or becoming a JURITRUST Volunteer Contributor, please send a sample of your original article to publications@juritrustcentre.org.
by juritrustlaw | Oct 19, 2023 |
Senior judge quoted by the Times says ‘biggest concern’ over guidance is those convicted of sexual assault likely to stay on bail.
Judges have been told to delay the sentencing of convicted criminals currently on bail – including rapists and burglars – because prisons are full, the Guardian understands.
The guidance reportedly came from the senior presiding judge for England and Wales, Lord Justice Edis, on a private call with senior crown court judges.
Earlier this year, in a court of appeal case, Edis said that for offences that attracted shorter terms, judges and magistrates
should consider imposing suspended sentences given “current prison population levels”. The prison population has grown since then –
to more than 88,000 – and, according to
the Times, Edis is said to have responded by issuing fresh guidance to judges.
A government source told the Guardian it applied to those who have been on bail throughout the court process and had therefore already been assessed as lower risk. The suggestion was that they would be left on bail between conviction and sentence, as it was thought to be safe enough to do so, and only be jailed on sentencing, assuming they were handed a custodial sentence. The source stressed that it was not a government policy, as sentencing is the preserve of the independent judiciary.
A senior crown court judge was quoted by the Times as saying that, from Monday, judges have been “ordered/strongly encouraged” not to jail someone who appears before them.
They were said to have added that the “biggest concern” was defendants charged with historical rape or rape of a child under 13 and other sexual assault, as even if convicted they were now likely to remain on bail.
The prison population was 88,016 last week, an increase of more than 6,500 in a year, almost 10,000 up on two years ago and close to the capacity of 88,667. Last year, the government announced Operation Safeguard, the emergency use of 400 police cells to hold inmates. To much criticism, it recently said it would seek to rent prison cells in foreign countries to alleviate the squeeze in England and Wales.
In his court of appeal judgment in March, Edis cited a letter from the then justice secretary, Dominic Raab, which said: “Detention would be harsher than before on account of high occupancy levels, reduced access to rehabilitation programmes and the possibility of prisoners being detained further away from home.”
The Ministry of Justice (MoJ) blamed the coronavirus pandemic and last year’s barristers’ strike for the backlog in courts, which it said was contributing to the high number of remand prisoners. While the backlog has increased since the pandemic, it was already high before it started, and
reached another record high (in crown courts) of 64,709 open cases at the end of June. Coronavirus restrictions were lifted last year and
the strike ended in October.
On Tuesday, the president of the Prison Governors Association blamed a lurch to the right by ministers for the overcrowding in jails, citing a stream of announcements about crimes that would now attract custodial sentences, or increased sentences for offences that already did.
Speaking to Times Radio, the health secretary, Steve Barclay, refused to confirm or deny that judges had been told not to send some convicted criminals to jail owing to prisons nearing capacity, but acknowledged prisons were under “huge pressure”.
An MoJ spokesperson said: “We are categorical that the most serious offenders should be sent to prison and that anyone deemed a risk to public safety is remanded in custody while awaiting trial. Reports to the contrary are false.
“This government has done more than ever before to protect the public and keep sex offenders locked up for longer, ending automatic halfway release for rapists and serious violent offenders and sending rapists to prison for three years longer than in 2010.”
The judicial press office declined to comment.
SOURCE: THE GUARDIAN UK