WJP Rule of Law Index

Data evaluations for 142 countries and jurisdictions around the world. The global rule of law index.
Credit : World Justice Project

Data evaluations for 142 countries and jurisdictions around the world. The global rule of law index.
Credit : World Justice Project
Fines are a common sanction in countries in all regions of the world. They also pose a significant risk of economic discrimination. Unless they are perfectly scaled to defendants’ financial circumstances, they over-penalise people living in poverty both directly and by triggering additional sanctions where defendants cannot afford to pay. These effects add up to what we call “poverty penalties”: tougher punishments for low-income people resulting from inadequately scaled fines and their snowballing consequences.
In our article “Poverty Penalties as Human Rights Problems” published in the American Journal of International Law in July 2023 together with five other co-authors, we explore harmful poverty penalties around the world and discuss the human rights concerns they raise. We have drawn on the work of domestic scholars, activists, and journalists to identify laws or practices in many countries, including (among others): Australia, Brazil, China, Croatia, Denmark, the Democratic Republic of the Congo, France, Germany, Ghana, Great Britain, Hungary, India, Japan, Jordan, Kenya, Mexico, Nicaragua, Nigeria, Papua New Guinea, Poland, Qatar, Romania, Russia, South Korea, Switzerland, the United Kingdom, and the United States.
Poverty penalties come in many forms. Consider the following varieties:
Using fines and costs without adequate attention to individual financial circumstances. Financial sanctions are often imposed without adequately considering the financial situation of the person charged. Many countries set mandatory minimums on certain fines. In Qatar, for example, the fine for intentionally bouncing a check is a minimum of QR 3,000. Even in countries that use “day fines” (income-based fines theoretically scaled to a person’s ability to pay), these fines may be set too high. In 2016, nearly 8,000 people entered German prisons for the petty crime of fare evasion because they couldn’t pay their day fines.
Incarcerating for failure to pay fines. In many countries, if you can’t pay a fine, the typical consequence is imprisonment. In Kenya, for example, Penal Code Section 28 provides that whenever a person is sentenced to a fine, the court may order prison time for defaults on payment of that fine, even if the offence was originally punishable only by a fine. These practices are especially troubling for people in poverty who may never be able to afford the fines in the first place.
Piling on more fines, costs, and fees. Failing to pay fines and fees can result in additional financial sanctions, including through the use of unrealistic installment payment plans. These practices can create a snowballing cycle of debt that is nearly impossible for people living in poverty to escape. For example, in South Korea, if someone cannot pay their fine for a minor offence, then Article 8 of the Punishment of Minor Offences Act provides that they must pay the fine plus a 20% surcharge within twenty days of the original payment deadline. Per Article 9 of that same act, failure to pay by the new deadline can result in additional fines.
Imposing other legal sanctions for defaulting on fine payments. People who fail to pay fines may be subject to other legal sanctions, like drivers’ license suspensions, denial of access to social welfare, or loss of voting privileges. In Brazil, for instance, people can be removed from voter rolls and lose their right to work for nonpayment of fines. Drivers’ license suspensions are common in the United States, where, as of 2021, at least 11 million people could not drive because of their inability to pay fines and fees.
Fining socially marginalised communities. Fining practices can target or disproportionally harm people who are already vulnerable because of race, gender, disability, or other protected statuses. During the COVID-19 lockdowns in the United Kingdom and France, for example, fines for violating the lockdown fell disproportionately on people of colour, raising concerns not just about disproportionate effects but also about intentional targeting.
Although we give only one or two examples for each of these practices here, our research uncovered many more (as discussed in our article). It is clear that nations around the world over-penalise low-income people through their uses of financial sanctions, even though the degree of over-penalisation can vary considerably from place to place.
Poverty penalties are a global issue. They have the effect of discriminating against low-income people, often lead to imprisonment, and can result in other disproportionately harsh punishments. These fining practices are counterproductive for states striving to achieve the Sustainable Development Goal of “[e]nd[ing] poverty in all its forms.”
Our article highlights how these practices may undermine international human rights instruments. In particular, these practices raise serious human rights concerns under the ICCPR and ICESCR. They can constitute discrimination on the basis of property. They can subject people to arbitrary arrest and detention because of their inability to pay. They can amount to disproportionally harsh punishments and intrude on the free enjoyment of economic rights by trapping low-income people in a cycle of never-ending debt. And they frequently target or disproportionately affect racial minorities and other socially marginalised groups. These are serious concerns that the international human rights community must address.
There is growing attention to the issue of poverty penalties, both domestically and internationally. Below are some examples of recent progress in this area:
These are just some examples of this important work around the world. Our article identifies harmful fining practices, analyses how they raise grave human rights concerns, and proposes reforms. But our work was limited to the languages our research team speaks and the data we could find. We call on stakeholders to examine fining practices in their jurisdictions and evaluate whether these too can act as poverty penalties in practice. With more data, international human rights and criminal justice communities can begin to combat the scourge of poverty penalties.
NOTE: The section on legal Briefs is a forum for frank and open scholarly notes by research staff and guest contributors. Views expressed in these notes are personal to the authors and are not to be attributed to the Centre.
DO YOU WANT TO SHARE YOUR VIEWS ON OUR BLOG?
JURITRUST Centre for Socio Legal Research and Documentation invites submission of short articles from VOLUNTEER CONTRIBUTORS who are interested in sharing their perspectives on salient issues in the administration and development of the Nigerian Criminal Justice System, comparative systems and related issues. CLICK HERE find out how to send us your articles. Thank you
The Nigerian Medical Association said it would adhere to the directive of the acting Inspector General of Police, Olukayode Egbetokun, to treat gunshot victims without asking for police report.
The NMA said prior to the directive, medical doctors in the country had always attended to emergency cases without demanding a police report.
Egbetokun had issued the directive while urging health workers to sensitise Nigerians about the issue.
The IGP’s directive, based on the Compulsory Treatment and Care for Victims of Gunshot Act, 2017, was contained in a Police internal memo dated October 25, 2023, and signed by the Force Principal Staff Officer, Olatunji Disu.
The memo was addressed to all Deputy Inspectors-General of Police, Assistant Inspectors-General of Police, Commissioners of Police and the Commandants of Police Colleges in Ikeja, Kaduna, Oji-River, Maiduguri and Enugu.
Speaking with our correspondent on Friday, the President of the NMA, Dr Uche Ojinmah said, “Prior to now, it has been that if it is an emergency, you treat the emergency if there is no report and then you report the case to the Police.
“I pray the IG can hold his policemen because it is always from them. You will come to say you admitted someone bleeding with a gunshot injury and the person is stabilised, but they will arrest you.
“The problem is not with the medical doctors, it is with the Police, as long as the Police will obey what the IG has said, I assure you that it will be a thing of the past.”
Credit: THE PUNCH
Magistrates in Lagos State have been directed to stop granting remand orders to police to detain suspects in their cells.
The Deputy Chief Registrar, Legal, High Court of Lagos State, Joy Uggbomoiko, gave the directive in a circular dated October 18, 2023 and titled: “Re: Rejection of new inmates by correctional service.”
The circular indicated that the magistrates had earlier been given a directive to stop granting remand orders to the police to take suspects to prison, as the prison authorities, formally known as the Nigeria Correctional Service, had started rejecting inmates due to the congestion of their facilities.
Instead, the magistrates were encouraged to only grant remand orders for police to detain suspects in police station cells.
However, in the fresh circular, the DCR directed the magistrates to stop granting remand orders to the police altogether.
The DCR said the magistrates were only permitted to grant remand orders to the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission.
In the circular sighted by our correspondent, the DCR said, “I have been further directed to inform Your Honours to stop accepting overnight cases from any police station, formation or command except EFCC cases until directed otherwise.
“This overrides earlier directive that defendants be held in police custody. No magistrate shall order any police to detain a defendant at the station.”
A source told our correspondent that the circular was issued following a memo from the Chief Justice of Nigeria, in response to a complaint by the Nigeria Correctional Service stating that the prison were congested and they had started rejecting new inmates.
Credit: The Punch
Today Nigeria prevailed in its monumental challenge to arbitral awards worth more than $11 billion that were obtained by a small offshore company following a failed gas project in Nigeria. The High Court ruled that Process & Industrial Developments Limited (P&ID) paid bribes when brokering the lucrative gas processing contract, and then “practised the most severe abuses of the arbitral process” in order to procure awards in their favour from a London tribunal.
Given the secrecy of arbitration – a way of privately resolving disputes outside the usual court process – these corrupt payments remained hidden until the High Court gave Nigeria the green light in 2020 to challenge the awards. A lengthy public trial earlier this year lifted the lid on an audacious conspiracy involving Nigerian officials, Irish businessmen and London lawyers who stood to receive eye-watering sums under the arbitral awards, which have grown by $1.3 million every day in interest. Today’s judgment pulls the plug on P&ID’s claim to enforce this $11 billion award against Nigeria, relieving the African nation of a bill equivalent to almost a third of its total annual budget for 2023 and over seven times its current health budget.
The court found that P&ID not only made corrupt payments to a key Nigerian official who helped broker the gas deal, but also colluded to cash out the profits through an arbitration that was compromised by false evidence and conflicted lawyers. Far from being a fair fight, the court found that continued concealment of the truth by dishonest witnesses and the improper conduct by lawyers acting for P&ID meant the arbitration was “a shell that got nowhere near the truth”.
Describing Nigeria’s challenge as “a stand-out example of a case where ‘justice calls out for’ correction”, the court has unravelled an elaborate conspiracy to use a London arbitration as the unwitting vehicle for defrauding the Nigerian people. This near-miss exposes the vulnerability of arbitration to fraud and the need for more robust safeguards in high-stake commercial disputes involving state parties.
The court also made damning findings against two English lawyers acting for P&ID in the arbitration whose conduct in retaining legally privileged Nigerian documents was described as “indefensible”. Following the court’s referral of its judgment to the relevant legal regulators, it is imperative that appropriate steps are taken to ensure any professional misconduct is robustly sanctioned. This extraordinary case should also be a wake-up call about the need for urgent reforms to ensure lawyers and other professional enablers are not enlisted as accomplices, unwitting or otherwise, to corrupt schemes that undermine the integrity of our financial and legal systems.
Dr Helen Taylor, senior legal researcher at Spotlight on Corruption, said:
“It is difficult to overstate the importance of today’s ruling for the Nigerian people, given the economic prospects of an entire country have been held hostage by a tainted arbitral award for a gas project that was built on bribes and lies. The prospect of a release from this $11 billion debt will come as a huge relief to Nigeria, while the court’s damning findings about the conduct of London-based lawyers will weigh heavily on those who care about the integrity of our legal system. There must be further scrutiny of the role played by these lawyers and proper accountability for any professional misconduct that may have compromised the London arbitration.”
Source: Spotlight on Corruption