ILLEGAL MINING AS A TRANSNATIONAL ORGANIZED CRIME by Serah Onyeche Sanni, (PhD Partner, Seson Legal Practitioners)

ILLEGAL MINING AS A TRANSNATIONAL ORGANIZED CRIME by Serah Onyeche Sanni, (PhD Partner, Seson Legal Practitioners)

Introduction

Illegal mining has emerged as a significant global concern, with devastating consequences for the environment and national security. In countries like Nigeria, Colombia, and South Africa, to mention a few, illegal mining has reached alarming proportions, posing grave threats to natural resources, economic stability, and the social fabric. This article explores the issue of illegal mining as a transnational organized crime in Nigeria with reference to other jurisdictions, highlighting its multifaceted implications and the urgent need for comprehensive action toward a sustainable solution.

Understanding Illegal Mining as a Transnational Organized Crime

Illegal mining usually in the form of artisanal and small-scale mining (ASM), refers to mining activities conducted without the required licenses, permits, and adherence to environmental and safety regulations. When illegal mining activities are organized, coordinated, and driven across national borders with the involvement of criminal networks, it becomes a transnational organized crime. It involves foreign countries, networks, and actors working to achieve specific objectives, often for financial gain. In the case of illegal mining, transnational criminal networks exploit weaknesses in governance, border control, and law enforcement to conduct illicit mining operations, smuggling, money laundering, and tax evasion on an industrial scale.

Also, this category of crime has a direct impact on the environment. Illegal mining activities have led to rampant resource depletion, ecological degradation, and biodiversity loss. The unregulated extraction methods employed by illegal miners often result in deforestation, soil erosion, pollution of water bodies, and destruction of wildlife habitats. These activities undermine the country’s ecological balance and threaten the livelihoods of communities dependent on these resources. Therefore, environmental crime is a collective term for “illegal activities harming the environment and aimed at benefiting specific individuals, groups or companies through the exploitation and theft of, or trade in natural resources”.

The enormous negative impact of illegal mining and exploitation on several countries recently led to it being classified as the fourth largest criminal sector worldwide, after drugs, counterfeit goods, and trafficking.

Illegal Mining in Nigeria and Africa

Africa’s artisanal and small-scale gold mining sector has enormous development potential. However, it is undermined by criminals profiting from it at the expense of vulnerable populations. In recent years, there has been an increased nexus between escalated insecurity and mining activities in some Nigerian states, such as Zamfara, Plateau, and Osun State. This is despite earlier efforts taken by the federal and some state governments to curb the menace. It will be recalled that sometime in January 2019; the federal government banned mining activities in Zamfara state and constituted an anti-illegal mining team to enforce compliance. The Zamfara state government complemented this move and established an anti-illegal mining committee. Unfortunately, this move was short-lived as these illegal activities continue till present and have resulted in escalated insecurity.

In addition to this is the growing presence of the Chinese in various economic activities in Nigeria including illegal mining of gold and other solid minerals.  These illegal mining activities have been linked to Chinese nationals’ sponsorships and funding. A news report according to the Nigerian Tribune reveals some sort of collaboration between some ‘Nigerians in high positions of authority’ and Chinese corporations in illegally mining gold, thereby driving rural banditry and violent local conflicts in some parts of Nigeria, mainly the North West, North Central and South West regions because of its strategic importance and economic value. The Zamfara state governor in the year 2000 announced the arrest of some Chinese citizens for their involvement in illegal mining activities. Although the Chinese government denied the allegation, the truth of the allegation is not far-fetched.

The “Mountain Boys” case in South Africa illustrates a similar alarming complexity. The criminal syndicate smuggled vast amounts of precious metals, mainly platinum, which were stolen from South Africa’s mines. To operate successfully, the criminals bribed their way through the enforcement agencies such as the Police. They also deployed a sophisticated network of armed men to guarantee their unimpeded exploration and exportation of precious metals to refineries in Western Europe and North America. When accosted by custom officials, they made representations that undervalued and falsified the nature of the consignment, thereby circumventing the requirement for prescribed permits and licenses to possess and deal in precious metals.

While illicit mining and trafficking of precious metals and minerals is an issue of global concern, the question is why is this crime on the increase in Nigeria and Africa, and what are the underlying enabling forces? A detailed analysis reveals that these activities are not carried out in isolation. The harsh reality is that some collaboration exists between the criminals and the law enforcement agencies. Although this collaboration comes in different forms, while some are intentional & voluntary, others are induced.

Also, illiteracy and poverty are two major factors that enable illegal mining. The rural communities where these activities occur in Nigeria are impoverished. For example, in the North Western region, the local populations carry out an estimated 80% of all mining illegally and artisanally, thus, the people become vulnerable and available tools in the hands of the cartels as a means of survival. Another major factor one can point to in some African countries is the overwhelming power and arms controlled by these syndicates, whereby whoever stands in their way will be risking their lives.

The Impact of Illegal Mining in Nigeria

In light of the above, there is no doubt that illegal mining activities have several implications on Nigeria in terms of economic impact, revenue loss and national security.

Illegal mining deprives the Nigerian government of substantial revenue that could be generated through legitimate mining operations. The absence of taxation and royalties from unlawful mining activities exacerbates the precarious economic situation on the country. Moreover, the competition between illegal miners and licensed mining companies creates an uneven playing field, discouraging potential investors and undermining the growth of the formal mining sector.

As a transnational organized crime, illegal mining has profound implications for national security. The presence of criminal networks involved in illegal mining contributes to a range of security challenges, including money laundering, arms trafficking, and the financing of other criminal activities such as terrorism and drug trafficking. The erosion of state control in mining areas also leads to increased lawlessness, social unrest, and conflicts over resource control, further destabilizing affected regions.

Recommendations for Addressing the Challenge

To effectively tackle illegal mining as a transnational organized crime in Nigeria, a multi-dimensional approach is necessary by exploring the following measures:

  • Honesty of Purpose: The need for true political willpower and sincerity of purpose by the federal government, state government and regulatory agencies involved in enforcing legal and licensed mining goes to the root of every other action that needs to be taken to ensure that the problem is resolved in totality. The mindset of the enforcement bodies needs to be reformed towards maintaining an unwavering dedication to promote honesty and focus. This crucial factor will foster trust, integrity, and compliance.
  • Enhancing Border Security and Surveillance: To curb the cross-border movement of illegal miners, smuggled minerals and illicit proceeds, there is need to improve border control mechanisms. Promoting international cooperation to disrupt transnational criminal networks involved in illegal mining would go a long way in addressing this global concern.
  • Strengthening Law Enforcement: by providing adequate training and resources to law enforcement agencies responsible for combating illegal mining, they are better positioned to address the challenges head on. To further strengthen law enforcement, multi-agency collaboration and inclusiveness should be encouraged between law enforcement, environmental agencies, and local communities to gather intelligence and apprehend those involved in illegal mining.
  • Promoting Responsible Mining Practices: Encourage the formalization of artisanal and small-scale mining by providing legal support, technical assistance, and access to finance. Promote sustainable mining practices that prioritize environmental protection and community engagement.
  • Public Awareness and Education: Conduct targeted awareness campaigns to educate local communities, miners, and relevant stakeholders about the negative impacts of illegal mining. Encourage community participation and support in reporting illicit mining activities to the authorities.

Conclusion

Addressing illegal mining as a transnational organized crime requires concerted effort from the government, law enforcement agencies, local communities, and international partners. By implementing the suggested measures, Nigeria can protect its natural resources, boost economic development, and ensure national security. Only through such comprehensive action can the negative impact of illegal mining be mitigated, allowing Nigeria sustainably harness its mineral wealth for the benefit of its people and protect its environment.

 

 

DSN teams up with NBA Human Rights Institute to lead other CSOs and Stakeholders in providing Free Legal Advice and Services at the Nigerian Bar Association Annual General Conference to be held in Abuja, FCT in August 2023

                          

Every year the Nigerian Bar Association (NBA) holds an Annual General Conference (AGC) for lawyers across Nigeria. This gathering has the reputation of being the largest gathering of lawyers and judges in sub-Saharan Africa. At the 2022 NBA AGC Conference held in Lagos State, Duty Solicitors Network (DSN) in Partnership with the NBA (through the office of the 1st vice president), government and non-government legal aid service providers facilitated the 1st NBA AGC free legal Aid intervention initiative which involved about 20 volunteers from over 8 organizations providing pro bono legal services. These volunteers attended to over 120 people at the conference venue.

DSN Volunteers, Police and Correctional Officers

This year, between August 25 and September 1, the NBA-HRI will lead the intervention with other partners which includes; the Legal Aid Council of Nigeria, National Human Rights Commission, NAPTIP, AWLA, Juritrust Centre , British Council RoLac, DSN; just to mention a few

Our partners’ intervention will be to support the efforts of Legal Aid service providers by bringing volunteers from different organizations to serve the legal needs of indigent Nigerians who are expected in and around the NBA Conference venue. Lawyers will also be on ground to help mediate disputes and provide other basic legal services.

Mr Bayo Akinlade, Convener DSN

According to Mr Bayo Akinlade, Convener DSN, activities this year will also include a workshop to train lawyers in some aspects of the administration of criminal justice, visits to police detention facilities under the Police Duty Solicitors Scheme (PDSS) and a visit to Kuje Prisons

LEDAP/NBA KICKSTARTS MANDATORY CONTINUOUS LEARNING EDUCATION PROGRAMME ON THE ACJA FOR LAWYERS IN CALABAR WITH THE SUPPORT OF THE MACARTHUR FOUNDATION

           

The Rules of Professional Conduct 2007 states that lawyers who wish to carry on practice as a legal practitioner shall participate in and satisfy the requirements of the mandatory Continuing Professional Development (CPD) programmes organized by the Nigerian Bar Association. These programs include seminars, workshops and conferences for the purpose of furthering their legal knowledge.

Cross Section of Participants

Just as other professional bodies, the practice is dynamic and being that as the society progresses, the laws in place either become obsolete, supplemented, replaced or developed. Learning is a continuous exercise which demands all lawyers to hon their skills and develop themselves so that they will not become part of the menace associated in the legal system.  A lawyer ought to be diligent and exhibit versatility, where these are lacking can be injurious to the legal profession. The packages of these programmes deal on all round solidification of the lawyer and his everyday practice.

Justice Ajileye delivers his lecture on Digital Evidence in Calabar

The Legal Defence and Assistance Project (LEDAP) is partnering with the Nigerian Bar Association to organize hybrid trainings for lawyers in diffrent branches of the NBA in Nigeria. It is a two-day training program held among the six geopolitical zones in Nigeria. The training modules focuses on core areas of the Administration of Criminal Justice which are:

  • Fundamentals of Criminal Procedure in Nigeria
  • Human Rights Law
  • Economic and Financial Crimes in Nigeria
  • Freedom of Information
  • Restorative Justice System & Non-Custodial Sentencing
  • Evidence Law
  • Witness Management and Protection: SGBV, Children & Other Vulnerable Groups
  • Law Practice Management and Advocacy Skills

According to Chino Obiagwu SAN, National Coordinator LEDAP the uniqueness of the programme is the forging together with a team of experts comprising retired Justices, Academics and senior lawyers to to produce lecture synopses and guides while also facilitating trainings in the selected NBA branches. Some of the organisations providing technical support to the programme are the Juritrust Centre for Socio-Legal Research & Documentation and the Centre for Socio-Legal Studies (CSLS). Both organisations are primarily involved in building capacity of legal practitioners and are grantees of the MacArthur foundations On Nigeria Criminal Justice Project.

The inaugural session of the programme was held last week in Calabar, Cross River State on 13 – 14 July with more than 60 participants. Before the kick-off LEDAP organized on 8 and 9 June in Lagos a 3 day team building an Curriculum Development meeting.

CALL FOR SHORT ARTICLES

https://juritrustcentre.org/index.php/information/events/132-call-for-short-articles

JURITRUST Centre for Socio Legal Research and Documentation invites submission of short articles from VOLUNTEER CONTRIBUTORS who are interested in sharing their perspectives on salient issues in the administration and development of the Nigerian Criminal Justice System, comparative systems and related issues. Click link above to find out how to send us your articles.

Thank you

Nigeria can fight corruption to standstill — Ribadu, EFCC

With the ongoing battle against crime especially corruption and other related crimes in the country, Anti-graft Agencies along with other Stakeholders expressed their resolve to continue in the war against crime in Nigeria. At the just concluded 2023 African Union Anti-Corruption Day in Abuja, organised by the Inter-Agency Task Team in collaboration with the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime, MacArthur Foundation and the Centre for Democracy and Development, with the theme, ‘African-union-convention-on-preventing-and-combating-corruption 20 years after: Achievements and prospects’.

The Acting Executive Chairman of the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission, Abdulkarim Chukkol, highlighted the effects of corruption, including poor infrastructure, economic and political crises, poverty, and security challenges. Chukkol expressed concern about the involvement of youths in economic and financial crimes, particularly cybercrime observing that “Corruption is one monster that has troubled and remains a huge challenge to Africa.“When so-called future leaders are themselves enmeshed in the criminality of uncommon dimension, it is difficult to imagine what the future holds for Africa,” He further expressed faith in the war against corruption stating that it was a war that can be fought and won.“A corrupt-free Nigeria, or corrupt-free Africa, is not an Eldorado”, he said.

The Solicitor-General of the Federation, Beatrice Jedy-Agba emphasised on the need to combat corruption for the attainment of Sustainable Development Goals. She observed that “To ensure progress, we must take steps to combat corruption which is one critical factor that relegates democracy, security and development to the backseat”, she said.

The National Security Adviser, Mallam Nuhu Ribadu, examined  the root causes of corruption, including the erosion of value systems.He reiterated the need for value reorientation and attitudinal change among citizens to strengthen their moral character. He further went on to emphasise that  corruption contributes to poverty, hunger, and unemployment, which in turn can generate insecurity at various levels.The Director of the Centre for Democracy and Development, Idayat Hassan, amplified the importance of the African Union Convention on Preventing and Combating Corruption, a multilateral instrument adopted 20 years ago to combat corruption. She applauded the 48 African countries that have ratified the AUCPCC and urged the remaining seven to follow suit. Hassan stated that effectively combating corruption required building strong and capable institutions that deepen democratic values and justice and support gender equality.

Idayat also highlighted the need for African states to halt the financial haemorrhage and recover illicit assets taken from the continent, citing Nigeria’s progress in tracking and recovering stolen assets through improved international cooperation. She declared that – “The Africa we want can only be achieved through the diligent implementation of the provisions of the AUCPCC and state parties renewing their unalloyed commitments to it,”